Reading Tobacco Attributes

Strength of the tobacco is usually meant to be the level of nicotine in the blend.

Your guesses are correct on the others.

I find those are all relative assessments, and can't always rely on them to fit my own definitions.

Super8mm, if you switch back and forth between 12 samples your not going to get any of the nuances of the blends, pick a sample and smoke the whole ounce to get a real feel for the blend. Also if you want to get scientific write notes about anything you like/hate it will help us make other suggestions for things to try. Just some friendly advice
I don't look at the intensity/room notes ect anymore, there's no set measurement they don't help me at all, I just got a feel for what types I liked and looked for those types in a blend. Example would be I like Latika, so I look for blends with a "smoky" description or that just say they have Latikia in them.

When I'm trying to decide on trying a tobacco I've never had before, I always look at an on-line independent site. The reviews on the retailers site are helpful, but usually one mans view/taste. The independent sites have several, if not hundreds of reviews from pipe smokers from all over the globe.

Topd the only problem with that is it's so subjective you probably won't taste the same things anyone else does. One review says it taste like a burnt tire the other says they taste plum with a hint of honey and the third swears it's a tea. I find those sites more frustrating than helpful.

I don't use the individual reviews, I use the averaging blocks on Strength, Flavoring, Taste and Room Note. The one I use also has how many rated it with one star, through four stars. It gives you a good average of what a large percentage thinks.

Suppose that's a good way to go at it. What site do you use? Is it tobaccoreveiws.com?

TopD, Could you either link the review site you use or send it in a PM please? As a new pipe guy, I would like to have reviews before I spend cash on a new tobacco in order to refine my guess as to what I would like.

js:
I believe TopD's referring to TobaccoReviews.com. If, after reading some reviews and trying some blends, you find that your tastes seem to align best with specific reviewers, you can also look up those reviewers and see all the blends that they've rated (and how many stars they gave them).
Just be aware, going in, that there's a lot of "noise" on TobaccoReviews -- that is, a lot of "reviewers" seem to be more interested in hearing themselves talk (or more concerned with impressing their readers with their wit and "erudition") than in actually offering a clear and cogent review of the blend under discussion. And you may need to do some additional homework to really figure out a blend (like, say, posting about it here!); I recently read the reviews before trying a new blend, and the reviews ranged from 1 star -- "tasteless" -- to 4 stars -- "excellent flavor". And one reviewer complained about "way too much perique in this blend". . . when there is NO perique in the blend at all. So you have to make allowance for people's inexperience, uneducated palates, and flat-out ignorance.
I realize that doesn't sound like a ringing endorsement! But I do find the site helpful.
Bob

Yes, that's the one....