Newminster Round Slices Versus PS Luxury Bulls Eye Flake

prairiedruid

Lifer

Jun 30, 2015

2,005

1,137

• Aug 25, 2015

• #1

P&C has a 20% off sale on Newminster tobaccos for 1 week. I really enjoy the Peter Stokkebye's Luxury Bulls Eye Flake and was wondering how Newminster's Round Slices compare. They look and sound similar but was wondering if anyone had smoked both to give me some insight.

 

davet

Lifer

May 9, 2015

3,815

330

Estey's Bridge N.B Canada

• Aug 25, 2015

• #2

I found the Newminister slices milder or smoother, only tried them a couple of times but enjoyed them. I do like Peter Stokkebye's and cellar both.

 

cobguy

Lifer

Oct 18, 2013

3,742

15

• Aug 25, 2015

• #3

Just ordered another pound of #403 ... love it!
LBF is a Va/Per with a center of Cavendish while #403 is a Va/Bur using Dark Fired Kentucky.
Different beasts but both great values and tasty smokes.

 

P

pipebuddy

Guest

• Aug 25, 2015

• #4

Are the Medallions for each of comparable size?

 

andrew

Lifer

Feb 13, 2013

3,043

402

• Aug 25, 2015

• #5

I really wish I'd of ordered some NRS from Cup o Joes before, except they had the description of them the same as LBF, so I figured there was no point in getting any. A Newminister blend that's really good is their English Oriental too.

 

cobguy

Lifer

Oct 18, 2013

3,742

15

• Aug 25, 2015

• #6

Are the Medallions for each of comparable size?

Click to expand...

The LBF rounds are larger and appear more "spun" where SRS looks more like a rope cut.

 

prairiedruid

Lifer

Jun 30, 2015

2,005

1,137

• Aug 25, 2015

• #7

Thanks guys, just the info I was looking for.

 

mlyvers

Can't Leave

Sep 23, 2012

487

0

• Aug 26, 2015

• #8

Just my 2 cents here, I prefer PS LBF over the Round Slices. I am not a big fan of Kentucky Dark Fired tobac. Many guys here do like it. Good Luck Sir.

 

cosmicfolklore

Lifer

Aug 9, 2013

34,000

75,780

Between the Heart of Alabama and Hot Springs NC

• Aug 26, 2015

• #9

To me, the Round Slices seem more like what the new incarnation of Three Nuns should taste like, but the Nuns to me tastes acrid in the back of the throat. I cannot speak to the original Nuns, as I've never had it. But, give me Round Slices all day over the new Three Nuns. The Slices are much more sweet and flavorful without the nastiness, IMO.

 

• 

Reactions: Singlebevel

greyfoxactual

Might Stick Around

Jun 17, 2015

88

1

Minnesota

• Aug 26, 2015

• #10

Figures - goes on sale the day after I purchase more for cellaring.

 

bonehed

Part of the Furniture Now

Nov 27, 2014

636

0

• Aug 26, 2015

• #11

@greyfoxactual - try contacting the company? Maybe they credit you the difference...

 

derfargin

Lifer

Mar 3, 2014

2,028

28

Kennesaw, GA

• Aug 26, 2015

• #12

Didn't care for the Slices myself, I found bowls smoked bitter more often than not.

 

jiujitsubowl

Can't Leave

May 19, 2015

434

0

Muskegon Michigan

• Aug 26, 2015

• #13

Never tried round slices but I carry LBF with me everywhere.

 

jkrug

Lifer

Jan 23, 2015

2,867

8

• Aug 26, 2015

• #14

I have tried them both and like them both very much. It would be hard to pick one over the other but I might...just might...give an ever so slight preference to the Newminster Round Slices. Both have a place in my cellar. On sale you say....... ::

 

leacha

Part of the Furniture Now

Jun 19, 2013

939

8

Colorado

• Aug 26, 2015

• #15

Thanks for the heads up on the sale prariedruid!
jkrug is right on the money. One is hard to choose, having both is optimal.
I'd also like to add No. 400 Superior Navy Flake is great as well. I was gifted some flakes and was surprised by how good they were. I've been meaning to grab a pound or two and age it along side my McC 5100 (jar it and forget it for 5 years). You do that and the straight Virginia part of your cellar is complete IMHO.

 

12pups

Lifer

Feb 9, 2014

1,063

2

Minnesota

• Aug 27, 2015

• #16

Love them 403 slices. Didn't care for the PS as much, and haven't bought it again.
I buy 403 in bulk and jar what doesn't go in my pouch or spare tin to take to work with me. Also use 403 as a "base" of a parfait at times, testing different pairings to see what what adds/subtracts in the blend. I set it beneath a weak self-made blend of Virginias that was flat. Just the ticket! Got rid of the Virginia without having to monkey with it -- stretched out my larder's 403 a bit farther.
Also do like the 400 flakes, but not as well.
I bounce back and forth in a day between 403 and Orlik Golden Slices, believing (so far) that one is a pleasure unto itself but an invitation to the other. Complementary.

 

deathmetal

Lifer

Jul 21, 2015

7,714

32

• Aug 28, 2015

• #17

LBF is a Va/Per with a center of Cavendish while #403 is a Va/Bur using Dark Fired Kentucky.

Click to expand...

And no one makes a Va/Bur with a center of Cavendish?

 

cobguy

Lifer

Oct 18, 2013

3,742

15

• Aug 28, 2015

• #18

And no one makes a Va/Bur with a center of Cavendish? []

Click to expand...

I don't know ... typically, I avoid cavendish in my blends.
Which one are you referring too?

 

deathmetal

Lifer

Jul 21, 2015

7,714

32

• Aug 29, 2015

• #19

I was just riffing off the differences between the two:

LBF is a Va/Per with a center of Cavendish while #403 is a Va/Bur using Dark Fired Kentucky.

Click to expand...

In other words, if a Va/Per with a center of Cavendish is tasty, and some object to the Dark Fired Kentucky at the center of the Va/Bur slices, I would what a Va/Br with a cavendish center -- more like the Va/Per blend -- would be like. It's an interesting split between the two types.

 

L

lestrout

Lifer

Jan 28, 2010

1,763

302

Chester County, PA

• Aug 29, 2015

• #20

Being that Cavendish is a process, wouldn't some be made from Virginias, rather than burleys? I think most of the American Cavendishes are burley based, but maybe some of the English and European ones are Virginia?
hp

les