Pipes Magazine » Pipe Tobacco Discussion

Search Forums  
   
Tags:   

Frog Morton Cellar Match

(13 posts)
  • Started 11 months ago by foursidedtriangle
  • Latest reply from snoopy311
  1. User has not uploaded an avatar

    foursidedtriangle

    Member
    Joined: May 2018
    Posts: 265

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    FMC was a best seller in 2017 according to SP website and topped many a best of lists. It happens to be also a favourite of mine, and I quit pipe smoking just at the wrong time - didnt save any for later. Are any blenders working on a FMC match?

    Posted 11 months ago #
  2. User has not uploaded an avatar

    erhardt85

    Member
    Joined: Apr 2017
    Posts: 196

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    I haven't heard of any such project. It's my understanding that there's a twofold problem in recreating McClelland blends. The tobaccos other blenders use would be different, and on top of that the McClelland processing of tobacco and blends is pretty unique and time consuming I think. I'd be surprised if there was a match that did FMC justice I'm sorry to say. Hopefully I'm proven wrong.

    Posted 11 months ago #
  3. unkleyoda

    unkleyoda

    Preferred Member
    Joined: Aug 2016
    Posts: 1,102

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    Though not a match, but tobaccos in a similar flavor arena: Mac Baren The Solent Mixture, SG Bothy Flake, Boswell's Countryside, C&D Black Frigate


    So you say you can drink? Well, I'm from Wisconsin. Try to keep up.
    Posted 11 months ago #
  4. smittyd

    smittyd

    Preferred Member
    Joined: Feb 2018
    Posts: 659

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    #1 on Black Frigate. Defiantly not the same, but wonderful all the same!

    Brothers Of The Black Frigate
    Posted 11 months ago #
  5. pianopuffer

    pianopuffer

    Senior Member
    Joined: Jul 2017
    Posts: 443

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    Also check out Boswell's Northwoods. Derek Tant (of the YTPC community) did a series on the FMC "replacement project". Might find some good ideas there as well.

    Posted 11 months ago #
  6. blendtobac

    blendtobac

    Tobacco Blender Extraordinaire
    Joined: Oct 2009
    Posts: 1,219

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    It's doubtful that any blenders will be working on matches for any tobaccos. They would be considered new blends, and we have been restricted by the FDA Deeming Regulations from creating new blends since 8/8/16 unless they want to submit the blends for testing and approval, which would be expensive. Even after testing, there's no guarantee that the FDA would approve the tobaccos.

    Russ

    Posted 11 months ago #
  7. mso489

    mso489

    Preferred Member
    Joined: Feb 2013
    Posts: 26,287

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    For Frog Morton Cellar nostalgia, I don't even try duplicating the McClelland experience. Whatever you like in a whiskey aromatic might recall a little of the experience. Boy, Russ spells it out. It looks grim. I admit I'm aging a few tins of McClelland for future enjoyment, but no FMC.

    Posted 11 months ago #
  8. User has not uploaded an avatar

    foursidedtriangle

    Member
    Joined: May 2018
    Posts: 265

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    FDA sounds a lot like contrary to free market principles. If there is a huge demand for a legal good the government should not impede someone supplying it. The demand is sky high, sales from 2017 show that.

    The part about new blends is a bit ambiguous, there have been many new blends, such as HH Balkan from macbaren just now released.

    Posted 11 months ago #
  9. whiteburleydude

    whiteburleydude

    Member
    Joined: Dec 2017
    Posts: 137

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    For me, the overwhelming flavor I get from FMC is vanilla. I do enjoy a bowl here and there. I have about a half pound left. If you miss Cellar, look for something with similar components and vanilla topping.

    Posted 11 months ago #
  10. blackadderlxx

    blackadderlxx

    Senior Member
    Joined: Jun 2018
    Posts: 370

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    They would be considered new blends, and we have been restricted by the FDA Deeming Regulations from creating new blends since 8/8/16

    I thought it was 2007. Has that changed?

    Posted 11 months ago #
  11. sablebrush52

    sablebrush52

    The Bard Of Barlings
    Joined: Jun 2013
    Posts: 9,765

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    I thought it was 2007. Has that changed?

    It hasn't changed. All blends continuously on the US market since before the Predicate date of February 15th 2007 are grandfathered in. For now.

    Blends introduced into the US market after February 15th 2007, but PRIOR to the cutoff date of 8/8/2016, may continue to be offered for sale, but need to undergo either the Substantial Equivalency process or the Deeming process in order to remain available for sale after 8/8/21. Blends that do not pass either the SE of Deeming process must be removed the market after 8/8/2021.

    Blends introduced into the US market after the cutoff date of 8/8/2016 must go through the SE or Deeming process before they can be offered for sale.

    As for those blends that appeared to be offered to the US market after the cutoff date of 8/8/16? There were a couple of workarounds, like recording a sale of that blend prior to 8/8/2016, even if it wasn't yet on the shelf. But mostly they're just old blends in new packaging, figuring that most of you won't know the difference. The process required to create and market an actually new blend are now potentially way too expensive to justify such an undertaking.

    FDA sounds a lot like contrary to free market principles.

    That would be true if such a thing as a free market ever existed in the history of the earth. It's a popular myth, like the moon being made of green cheese, or tulips being a sound investment.

    It is better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt. - Mark Twain

    It is pointless to argue with a fanatic since a dim bulb can't be converted into a searchlight. - Jesse Silver
    Posted 11 months ago #
  12. jaytex969

    jaytex969

    Preferred Member
    Joined: Jun 2017
    Posts: 3,833

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    For me, the overwhelming flavor I get from FMC is vanilla. ..... If you miss Cellar, look for something with similar components and vanilla topping.

    I had a similar experience with Peter Stokkebye's Highland Whiskey. I've not tried FMC yet, so I can't comment there. My be worth a try, though, as PS stuff is inexpensive and available.

    Gunner, Black Frigate. Say "Hello" to my little friend!
    Posted 11 months ago #
  13. snoopy311

    snoopy311

    Senior Member
    Joined: Dec 2016
    Posts: 349

    offline

    Login to Send PM

    glad i have a nice stockpile.

    Posted 11 months ago #

Reply

You must log in to post.

 

 

    Back To Top  | Back to Forum Home Page

   Members Online Now
   jiminks, achtman, cornedbeef