Deleted Account With 28353 Reviews On TR.Com

jaytex1969 · Aug 19, 2018

As I wander through the tobacco reviews, I often see multiple entries on every blend from this deleted account.
Is/was this anyone we know/knew?
This person must have posted a new review for each blend every time they smoked it. Usually in alignment with their previous reviews, although sometimes counter.
Just an amusing observation. Hopefully I am not picking a scab from some crazy old wound left by an unmentionable.

bigpond · Aug 19, 2018

They collate all deleted accounts into a single entry. Something new must have happened as a bunch of old time reviewers are now deleted which is a total bummer.

jazz · Aug 19, 2018

They collate all deleted accounts into a single entry. Something new must have happened as a bunch of old time reviewers are now deleted which is a total bummer.

I was pondering this very thing yesterday.

workman · Aug 19, 2018

I wondered the same thing. I noticed some of the reviews from this account look similar, same style, vocabulary etc. But not all. Very strange, and definitely not something to be steered by when choosing a blend to try.

rmpeeps · Aug 19, 2018

Back in 2012 I stepped away from smoking, until late 2017. Just since last October the “deleted account” entries has skyrocketed. Several of the reviewers I valued have disappeared into the ranks of deleted or one reason or another. While exploring ‘new to me’ blends those reviewers opinions were invaluable as I knew our tastes ran similar for a decade running.

This year I went to look up a VaPer, “he” was gone. I contacted him through the interweb and he said he’d not posted a review in so long that his account apparently just went inactive. But, NO, I hadn’t tried all the VaPers he’d reviewed!! Then another, and another....

Luckily, several others I trust still remain in the ranks and I’ve learned a few things about reading between the lines. The hobby is filled with helpful and astute members.

After several conversations one gentleman sent me some Brunello Flake, thinking it was right up my alley. He nailed me!! It’s sort of become one of my few desert island smokes and is sufficiently cellared for the long haul.

Don’t just read reviews. Reach out and make a friend.

mso489 · Aug 19, 2018

That was the Lone Ranger ....

jaytex1969 · Aug 19, 2018

Awww, man.
You guys have destroyed my mental delusion of a multiple personality disorder chain smoking maniac obsessed with tobacco reviews...

curl · Aug 19, 2018

Whenever I find out about a blend heretofore unknown to me, I always check Tobacco Reviews to see what Deleted Account says about it. As often as not, Deleted’s tastes align with mine, If Deleted likes a blend, I’m confident I will like it too.

JimInks · Aug 19, 2018

There have been people who canceled their accounts, a few have been banned over time, and a great many accoutns that were inactive ended up on the deleted list.

rmpeeps · Aug 19, 2018

Jay -

It sounds like your opportunity just presented itself.

jaytex1969 · Aug 19, 2018

I didn't want to go there, but since you've opened the door.... :rofl:

3rdguy · Aug 19, 2018

How do you get banned on a review site??

checotah · Aug 19, 2018

How do you get banned on a review site??

"Deleted" doesn't necessarily mean "banned". If people deactivate or delete their account on any given site, very often their posts, if they do not disappear with them (ala Facebook), are automatically converted to a generic, such as "Deleted". As already mentioned, if an account is inactive for some varying amount of time, the moderators may likewise turn them into "deleted", or some such. On here, I believe those folks, including those who get banned, become "Anonymous", but their posts (generally) remain, unless removed because of offense.

JimInks · Aug 20, 2018

If you break the rules, and are a jerk to the site admin. or a moderator when called on it, I can see somebody being banned. I really doubt many people have been banned there, though.

admiral · Aug 20, 2018

I reached the same conclusion when noticed 29K reviews from a Deleted Account

Started wondering why Sykes, Colonel Panic and etc got their accounts closed.

Due to inactivity seems a good reason

bigpond · Aug 20, 2018

It’s a super bummer. Some of the old users have passed and their reviews were a deep well of insight that is near impossible to source elsewhere particularly to new pipe smokers with no link to real world pipe smokers.
One of my favorite reviewers, Briarpatch, was just deleted. He only had 33 reviews and posted them all in a narrow window of time in (I think) 2009. He was on a mission and once it was accomplished he never posted again, but his reviews were insightful, provocative and filled with fascinating tobacco lore. He was trying to find a replacement for English made Dunhill Standard Mixture and over the course of his reviews he discovered what Va’s did for a blend and ultimately found happiness in Skiff Mixture and FVF which he cautioned should never be dried.
Anyway, just one of many reviewers now anonymous that have added insight and helped a new piper along the road.

workman · Aug 20, 2018

OMG! I just realized that someday Jiminks and Pipestud are also going to be swallowed by the great Anonymous, boosting him to 1000.000 reviews and making the site utterly ridiculous :crazy:

jamban · Aug 20, 2018

Why merge all of them into a single entity? A strange system. Far too spiritual for a tobacco review site, no? ;{p

swilford · Aug 20, 2018

Started wondering why Sykes, Colonel Panic and etc got their accounts closed.

Wait, huh, I didn't realize my account was deleted. It's gone, though. I guess part-owning and maintaining TR.com for a few years (2001-2007) and writing bits of the codebase (prior to the rewrite in, what, 2012?) doesn't rate. And Colonel Panic was one of my favorite reviewers (and he was a much better, and far more prolific, reviewer than I). Bummer.
I'm sure it was completely non-systematic, associated with accounts missing key bits of information we didn't require in the early days that were part of a rewrite spec, but, um, still, it's a bit like walking past a house you once owned and discovering that the shutters were painted pink by a recent owner.
Admittedly, I haven't actually logged in for years.
Do we know when this happened?

JimInks · Aug 21, 2018

It happened a few weeks ago, I believe.

Deleted Account With 28353 Reviews On TR.Com

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Sultan of Smoke

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Sultan of Smoke

Starting to Get Obsessed

Lifer

Lifer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Starting to Get Obsessed

Sultan of Smoke