At least a quarter of my stable of pipes were bought at local shops, independent and chain, and about a quarter were bought from my favorite in-state carver who is both talented and extremely moderate in prices. Online is a powerful temptation because they offer so many pipes, and because you can shop far and wide in a single evening, and take advantage of sales that pop up, as they come along, you really can satisfy your exact shape/weight/finish/stem ideas, often as not. When I buy from my carver, recently he will have something in mind to offer, and after looking at everything else first, I'll buy what he suggests. He just knows my collection by intuition. Last year it was a superb little pot pocket pipe, compact but not too small. He had many nice offerings, but that was it.