I like colorful pipes, some of the brighter stains and lighter color stems. However, I have always had an attraction to black finished blast and rusticated. I have about nine, in Johs blasts Dublin, diplomat, and Canadian; a Parker poker/cherrywood shape; a blast billiard Tusge; and a Stanwell brushed black Canadian. Also a Kaywoodie billiard panel, a Rossi prince, and a BC bent billiard Caprice. Something about the black briar and stem make the shapes flow. The brim doesn't show the slight charring that most other finishes do, and they have a sort of solid traditional look that pleases me. I suspect some don't like a black finish at all, but for me and others, it has a lot of appeal. How about you?