Best of the Best

shanelktown

Lifer

Feb 10, 2015

1,041

71

• Mar 2, 2015

• #1

List the best pouch tobacco the best tinned tobacco and best bulk tobacco.

 

blueeyedogre

Lifer

Oct 17, 2013

1,552

30

• Mar 2, 2015

• #2

Not sure about the best but my favs are......

Pouch- Prince Albert

Tin- Capstan Blue Flake

Bulk- McClelland 5100 Red Cake

 

shanelktown

Lifer

Feb 10, 2015

1,041

71

• Mar 2, 2015

• #3

Yeah I understand it's all personal perspective.

 

twoonefive

Starting to Get Obsessed

Jan 6, 2014

293

696

Willow Grove, PA

pipesandpens.com

• Mar 2, 2015

• #4

Tin - Dunbar

Bulk - C&D Briar Fox

I have yet to smoke any pouches.

 

forest7

Starting to Get Obsessed

Sep 8, 2014

190

2

• Mar 2, 2015

• #5

pouch --- Skandinavik full aroma

tin --- Dunhill Night Cap

bulk --- PS LBF

 

oklansas

Can't Leave

Apr 16, 2013

441

0

DC

• Mar 2, 2015

• #6

I going to go with the "impossible to quantify" answer.

 

derfargin

Lifer

Mar 3, 2014

2,028

28

Kennesaw, GA

• Mar 2, 2015

• #7

Pouch - Carter Hall

Tin - Gaslight

Bulk - PS - Luxury Navy Flake, just for sheer value on quality of the tobacco and price.

 

Perique

Lifer

Sep 20, 2011

4,098

3,884

www.tobaccoreviews.com

• Mar 2, 2015

• #8

Pouch: Sir Walter Raleigh
Tin: goodness...... Not broken down by style of blend? Well, if I had to pick only one: Escudo. But I could name about a dozen runners up
Bulk: Stokkebye's Luxury Navy Flake, again, with about a dozen runners up.

 

andrew

Lifer

Feb 13, 2013

3,043

402

• Mar 3, 2015

• #9

Well in the UK you can get G&H and SG in pouches. So I guess this would be an american survey.
Best bulk in my opinion would be El Ricon de la Pipa #1, it's only available in bulk form too.
P.S flakes would be subjective as they actually come in boxes.

 

peteguy

Lifer

Jan 19, 2012

1,531

909

• Mar 3, 2015

• #10

Pouch- Prince Albert

Tin- FVF

Bulk- McClelland 5100 Red Cake

 

matches

Starting to Get Obsessed

Feb 22, 2015

103

0

Dunedin, NZ

• Mar 3, 2015

• #11

Not had pouch

tin - HH Vintage Syrian

Bulk - nightcap

 

dottiewarden

Lifer

Mar 25, 2014

3,053

57

Toronto

• Mar 3, 2015

• #12

Best is too subjective to answer, but my current favorites are:

Pouch - Mac Baren Cube Silver

Tin - Samuel Gawith Balkan Flake

Bulk - Whole Mexican cigar leaf for blending
All three will change as my taste and experience evolve.

 

shanelktown

Lifer

Feb 10, 2015

1,041

71

• Mar 3, 2015

• #13

Pouch captain black cherry (first ever pipe tobacco smoked)

Tin SPC Mississippi River

Bulk Boswells northwoods/ uhles bishops move

 

F

frozenchurchwarden

Lifer

Mar 1, 2014

3,647

4,917

• Mar 3, 2015

• #14

I'll go with Condor for the pouch (even though I've never had any I have no reason to doubt it's good).

Similarly Ennerdale is my vote for the tin (this I have had).

Then pick up some Samuel Gawith St. James Flake in a 250g box for the best bulk.

 

zekest

Lifer

Apr 1, 2013

1,136

9

• Mar 3, 2015

• #15

Pouch: Carter Hall

Tin: Dunhill Elizabethan Mixture

Bulk: Cornell & Diehl Bayou Morning​