Best Lakeland to give a go?

aquadoc · Mar 22, 2017

I am leaning to Grousemoor but Bothy and Dark flake are there too. Seems Grousemoor is more of the traditional, true Lakeland style blend. Bothy seems like a Squadron Leader lite and Dark flake is another Virginia. Both good but not great examples of the Lakeland style.

cosmicfolklore · Mar 22, 2017

Dark flake is another Virginia

But, not "just" another Virginia. It's a mix of the strongest Virginias, and the scented is VERY Lakeland, while the unscented is just lighter in that topping stuff. It's my all time favorite of the genre.
There are lots of combinations of aromas in that Lakeland toolbox. You might try Kendal Flake or Coniston Cut Plug.

davet · Mar 22, 2017

Have you tried any yet? Bothy is definitely not a Lakeland.

fitzy · Mar 22, 2017

DON'T DO IT! :rofl:
However if you do I hope you'll use a cob you don't care about ghosting the shit out of.

cosmicfolklore · Mar 22, 2017

Should we call these Kendals, Lakelands, or what? I had just posted another thread about Kendals, apparently anything made by these companies can be called Kendal or Lakelands, which is confusing. So, Bothy apparently can be called a Lakeland. Maybe we should just call the scented stuff, dead grandma blends. : puffy

:

nukesimi · Mar 22, 2017

Bob's Chocolate Flake is great stuff.

davet · Mar 22, 2017

The OP mentions Squadron Leader and Bothy Flake, definitely not Lakelands. They are listed as English, Bothy has a " peaty, scotch top note " I don't really know what it is other than delicious :mrgreen:

mawnansmiff · Mar 22, 2017

It seems that Kendal and Lakeland have become synonymous to mean any blend coming from either Samuel Gawith or Gawith & Hoggarth which would be quite correct.
Kendal is the town where they are made and Kendal is in the Lake District National Park.
The only slight difference I have noted since being on this forum is that a Lakeland blend usually (but not always) refers specifically to the heavily scented blends that both houses produce in prodigious quantities.
Regards,
Jay.

hawky454 · Mar 22, 2017

Cosmic, have you trie Lakeland Dark by Sam G. yet? If you love the GH&Co. Dark Flake u/s than you've got to try LD. It has absolutely no perfume and I think I actually like it more than the GH&Co Dark Flake. It's one of my new favorites that I probably wouldn't have otherwise tried if it weren't for Troy (misterlowercase).
To the OP, I would recommend that you try Grousemoor, it's completely different than anything you'll ever try, even in regards to other Lakelands.

cosmicfolklore · Mar 22, 2017

I'll give them a shot, if they are easy to find here. But, I already have 5 pounds of DF in jars, and in just two years they are even more wonderful. I cannot wait till they get ten years on them.

aquadoc · Mar 22, 2017

Grousemoor it is.

aquadoc · Mar 22, 2017

Davet, I am confused by the naming of the blends from this region. Reading reviews, many insist that SL and Bothy are Lakeland in nature, not just origin, because of some of the casing but I am most likely just confusing the issue. No, I have never tried any of these blends.

toobfreak · Mar 22, 2017

To me, all the real Lakelands are made by G&H. They are all nice interesting smokes if you like Lakelands, or putrid garbage if you don't like them. No middle ground. Lakelands are good for driving vermin, raccoons and even termites away from your house. :worship: All those mentioned are nice. I will second Conniston, Bob's Chocolate is a nice light Lakeland, there is Brown Flake, Ennerdale, Bob's Square Cut, and if you want to dip both toes into the Lakeland waters, Grasmere, which will either kill you or make you a fan for life!

murica · Mar 22, 2017

Dark Flake. Both varieties. I like it so much that I buy two 500g boxes of each every month.

perdurabo · Mar 22, 2017

Alright, Everybody scoot out of the way.
Sonny, if you want to get the real Lakeland Experience, you've got to go with Samuel Gwaith's 1792 Flake and Gawith, Hogarth, &Co Ennerdale. Grab those two and you are well on the way to the full Lakeland Experience. Try some Ropes next time.

paulfg · Mar 22, 2017

I like Ennerdale ,Bobs and Dark Plug Aromatic and have just placed an order including Bosun cut plug and Coniston Plug as I have not yet tried them.

you either love or loathe them ,me I fall firmly into the first catagory

unkleyoda · Mar 22, 2017

Bothy and Squadron Leader are great, not 'Lakelands' though. Bothy is a Va/Lat flake with a Scotch topping. I think it is really good. It is not an aromatic mind you, just Scotch topped. The Scotch adds to the flavor of the tobacco. Both are great tobaccos.

loborx · Mar 22, 2017

Grousemoor is nice in the Spring and Summer. Very bright, lemongrass scent. The strands are bright golden with a slight green tint. I tend to let it dry out quite a bit. A fresh tin is pretty intense. YMMV. Bob's Chocolate Flake is also pretty great if you like latakia. : puffy

:

mso489 · Mar 22, 2017

'Haven't tried any Lakeland yet, but have some in tins. You have to decide if you want to contend with the famous Lakeland flavorings and their ghosts or not. If not, I believe Squadron Leader is a popular non-aro. If you have a cob or other pipe to designate and can tolerate full-strength tobacco, 1792 is well regarded by some. But I'd read up on the whole line. Your taste may not follow the general pattern. Just be decisive about the ghosting issue.

toobfreak · Mar 22, 2017

Haven't tried any Lakeland yet

Geese, Louise, MSO! You gotta give some of them a swing! Honestly, I don't let the ghosting thing worry me much. I just designate certain pipes for it and others that I do not.
I'm pretty sure a pipe can be deghosted anyway, if that is what you want.

Best Lakeland to give a go?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now

Lifer

Lifer