hawk - the mystery blend arrived yesterday but I was at the shore. When I pulled your envelope from the mailbox today, even without opening the letter, I could smell the prominent vanilla easily. Morley's was last Thursday, so that part of the project didn't take place as planned. So I went to the Haverford Tinder Box, and opened the letter there. The first jar I opened was TB's 1Q, labeled Wilshire. The smell and appearance of the blends are very very similar.
I have about 1200 blends on hand in my cellar, and have tasted close to 2000 blends, but I guessed that 1Q was a likely bet. Curiously, I have never puffed 1Q, since I gravitated to Lats within weeks of my pipe initiation in 1961. (I, however, have puffed 79, Cherry Blend and quite a few OTCs, because I started with them before I discovered the Dunhills).
Jim, who is a longtime puffer at the TB, sniffed and looked at your blend, and he thought of other possibilities such as Chartwell among the several dozen TB jars. He came around to my original guess, although we think it is possible your friend's B&M may have added something to 1Q to customize it.
I need to calibrate myself on 1Q for a few bowls before I try puffing your stuff. The Lehigh Valley PC will meet in a week and hopefully RussO will show. John and several other members have a lot of experience themselves and we will puff the control Wilshire and then the mystery blend and try to decide what it consists of.
hp
les