Too bad about that specific pipe. As far as the size/shape, I'd say it depends on what you want. If anything, my 312 is a bit big (should've gone with a 314), and while the 317-sized Wellington I have may be a bit small, it makes a great "travel" pipe, meaning it fits comfortably in a suit/sport jacket pocket and is great for clenching. It also smokes latakia flakes very well.