Since you like Captain Black Royal you might like the Mac Baren 7 Seas line. The 7 Seas Royal blend is very good and so is the regular. The royal is supposed to be a vanilla/fruit casing, but most people find it to be more of a rum/vanilla/caramel flavour. The Regular, which is my favourite, is a vanilla flavouring with a bit of chocolate.
Aromatics- Connoisseur's Choice by Peterson, Peterson Special Reserve 2011, McClelland's Best of Show, Mac Baren's Vanilla Cream (loose or flake cut), Sunset Breeze by Peterson, CAO's Eileen's Dream or Cherry Bomb, since you noted a few cherry blends might give Mac Baren's Cherry Amrosia a try as well it's a great cherry and Jamaica rum blend my only advice is to rub out the "broken flakes" yourself to keep the flavour more consistant
English/Latakia- Dunhill's Early Morning Pipe, or Nightcap, Mac Baren's Latakia Blend (Not an English/Latakia fan myself but I hear those are good starters)
Perique- Frog Morton on the Bayou (was my first Perique blend and loved the taste of it), or Robert McConnell's Scottish Cake (second Perique blend and enjoyed it as well)