Are American artisan pipes in the same price range that much better?
For the most part, and especially for the upper-tier makers, I'd say yes to that question.
The good American makers are probably making some of the best stuff in the world at the moment.
It really is staggering about exactly how far the American artisan scene has come,
worldbeaters no doubt.
That said,
I have a pipe from a Brazilian maker named Martelo,
he's on point:
http://www.smokingpipes.com/pipes/new/martelo/moreinfo.cfm?product_id=169061
His FB page is well worth looking at,
he's doing some beautiful stuff...
https://www.facebook.com/martelopipes
...and,
there is a French maker who I've been interested in ever since I saw the Pipes&Tobaccos Magazine write-up about him,
David Enrique.
Finally this summer I approached him with a commission and he accepted,
I can't wait until the pipe is in my hands,
it'll be a tan blast and slightly shorter version of this:
http://www.enriquepipes.com/en/galerie/2014/squashrhodesianshell.htm
He's been making pipes for quite a good while now and knows what he's doing,
he should have more exposure because he's got the chops in my book!
You mention Il Duca,
and he's been on my list too,
ain't heard nothing but positive things about him and his work and I hope to get something by him at some point...
he's gotta great website:
http://www.ducapipe.com/
...and I keep an eye on lepipe or alpascia for new offerings,
I like how he has diverse shapes available, and he knows how to sandblast very well too!
http://www.lepipe.it/english/catalogo.asp?scat=57
If you may be interested in newer makers, there's a guy in Japan who's coming along quite nicely, I have one of his Dunhillesque 305 nosewarmers and it's a damn fine pipe --- I think he's doing interesting stuff,
his insta:
https://instagram.com/ks_pipes/
Glynn Quelch has been carrying his stuff...
http://www.gqtobaccos.com/ks-pipes/
My absolute favorite maker at the moment is Gian Maria Gamboni and nary a word is hardly heard about his stuff, yet it always sells pretty quickly, especially the signature squat stuff --- his eye for shaping is right up my alley and his pipes have a soul, which is important to me, the tactile feel is incredible, and the stainings he does are very pleasing to the eye --- I have 5 of his pipes and I'm eager for a few more!
http://www.gianmariagamboni.com/cgi-bin/jperl/jpipes.pl
:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/09fe3/09fe3d30f682a13e0fcd98b7037a48b7038833e1" alt="Puffy puffy puffy"
: