Muted Flavor from Cob.

[jaytex1969]

As I go through my rotation and also try different tobaccos in different pipes, I've noted at least two instances of getting less flavor from the cob than from the briar.
Is this an occurrence anyone else has had?
FYI, the cob is an MM Tom Sawyer. The tobaccos are John Cotton's #1 and Balkan Sasieni. Several different briars.
Thanks.

 

[pipesmokingtom]

Blends can have some different characteristics in different pipes for sure. What I'd say in your particular situation is that Tom Sawyer bowl is TINY. I only smoke pretty simple burley in my small cobs, because they don't really have the room to get complex blends really cooking like I think they should. Might be a whackadoodle theory, but that's where I've ended up.
I'd get ya a bigger cob, say a Country Gentleman or something, and see how you feel.

 

[jaytex1969]

One of my briars is smaller than the cob, a "pocket pipe", but it gives better flavor on the JC#1.
I know there's lots of variables. Just searching for possibilities.

 

[Chasing Embers]

Put Burley bombs and aromatics in cobs, and you'll be very happy with the results.

 

[tozert]

I agree with pipesmokingtom, a blend can be quite different from pipe to pipe, which is why it's important to try a blend in many types of pipes and chamber sizes to get the best from a tobacco.

 

[ray47]

Put Burley bombs and aromatics in cobs, and you'll be very happy with the results
Chaingembers hit the nail on the head with this answer.

 

[mawnansmiff]

I have to agree with the OP to some degree. My Mark Twain cob initially tasted very sweet as I was told it would do but now pretty much broken in that sweetness has gone. Now pretty much everything I smoke in it is 'missing' something that I don't experience with my briars.
FVF in any of my briars is stellar, smoked in my cob it's just another Virginia flake. Westmorland Slices in a briar tastes wonderful, in my cob it's just a strong smoke without any particular flavours.
I do intend on buying another cob, very different from the Mark Twain just to see if it is indeed the pipe or just me.
Regards,
Jay.

 

[jaytex1969]

This morning, I loaded some McClelland's Red & Black flake into the cob and it was a fine experience.
I've been struggling to enjoy the R&B in a briar.
I did dry it quite a bit, also, which I'm sure is part of the improvement.
Still learning the 'lay of the land" in Pipe-World...

 

[fitzy]

I think Tom hit the nail on the head.
In tend to find latakia blends and aromatics give more flavor in a larger diameter pipe.

 

[pipesmokingtom]

The wide open draw of a cob might be playing a part in this as well.
But hey - there's nothing wrong with preferring tobacco X in a cob and tobacco Y in a briar, so why sweat it?

 

[mso489]

I don't mean this as a put-down since I've made the oversight, but be sure you aren't smoking through a filter, easy to miss with a new cob bought at a convenience store, when you're just not thinking about it. This is likely NOT the problem, but it's happened. Otherwise, I agree that briar may do best with subtle, complex, multi-leaf blends. Cobs love burley and aromatics, but can do strong simple English and Balkans too.

 

[pipesmokingtom]

^ Good point. Those little Tom Sawyers aren't filter pipes, though. I really suspect it's the size of the chamber in combination with the open draw.

 

[mawnansmiff]

"The wide open draw of a cob might be playing a part in this as well."
Tom, my Mark Twain cob is a filter pipe but I made my own reducer which does exactly what I intended it to, however I still don't get the best from my blends whilst smoking it. I think the only exception would be Condor Flake, that smokes fine.
Regards,
Jay.

 

[jaytex1969]

No filter in mine. After the McC VA bowl, I also enjoyed a rubbed out load of Bold Kentucky in it.
No rhyme or reason to what works and doesn't work.
Thanks for all the input.

 

[pipesmokingtom]

No rhyme or reason to what works and doesn't

Sometimes.. There's your answer. Drives ya nuts though, don't it? 8)
That's why we all clearly need an infinite number of pipes.

 

[aeropuffer]

Since I smoke aero's in my pipes, It doesn't make any difference what pipe I smoke in. Cob or pear or briar.

 

[jaq6q]

I used to have Tom Sawyer. PS' English Luxury smoked great in there for first few times. And it started to deliver faint taste with other English blends and eventually bland. After many other attempts with other types of blend, it still was tasteless.

 

[prndl]

My experience is much the same as Duane's and Ray's. In my hands, cobs work fairly well with burleys and aros...not so well with much else.
Ymmv.