Haven't smoked the nosewarmer yet but the other is a great smoker. It has that "old briar" quality where the wood is so dry that it makes a "tink" noise with the pipe nail, almost like its stone. The only pipe I have found this in before was a very old Dr.Grabow that I have. Smokes very dry and very cool once I removed the screw-in stinger. The bowl is on the smaller side with a wide open draw without the stinger but I like that in a Virginia pipe and it smokes 5100 and VaPers like a dream.