Haddo and the Beast

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

24 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes
12 Fresh Ashton Pipes
36 Fresh Nørding Pipes
24 Fresh Ropp Pipes
3 Fresh Tom Eltang Pipes

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Oddball

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 29, 2022
513
2,752
TN
When C&D released the 2025 The Beast, I knew it was time to pop one of my 23 tins. In typical fashion, my first smoke of that was perplexing. The flavors started slow and took time to develop. In fact it took a while for it to be enjoyable. I was sort of disappointed.
Then, I jarred it, and let it sit for a couple of weeks. Now, it's every third bowl. Good, strong, weird, and lots of flavors. While I tried this, I did my usual manic deep dive into the blend and it's inspirations, causing me to link it up with G.L. Pease's Haddo's Delight.

So I asked my local tobacconist if they were getting any Haddo's Delight in. His answer was yes, it was on the last order and should be in the shop in a day or two. I picked up a tin and popped it and smoked a bowl with a cold one, then and there. Same effect, slow flavors, kind of meh. I got home and jarred it and pretty much left it, going back to the Beast and alternating between that and a few other standards.

Saturday night I was deciding what to smoke and decided to try Haddo's again. It's funny, this blend is apparently and love or hate blend for folks, with some not being able to get over the manure smell from the tin. I didn't really notice that strong of a musk in the freshly popped tin or in the jar a few weeks later.

What I did notice was a really really complex and delicious smoke. I didn't get much from the charring light, but a quick tamp and a true light really set it off. The next 45 minutes or so was filled with cocoa and spice and billows of delicious white-gray smoke. Maybe 2-3 quick relights. It was a really really yummy blend that was strong in flavor and kick, and mellow and smooth on the tongue. I didn't take notes of everything I was getting but it was good enough that I wanted to post something here about it.

This weekend I plan on going back to back with the Beast and Haddo's to do a true taste test. I will probably use two Briarwork's Princes for this comparison. The wide bowls really allow nuance flavor to develop and with two of the same shape the pipe bias should be null.
 

Brad H

Lifer
Dec 17, 2024
2,045
10,960
I smoked some beast last night as my last smoke for the night (least last planned smoke for the night) I hit a Peterson Elizabethan afterwards while I was waiting on shooting armadillos in the yard.

First take on beast was wow, not bad. I too let it sit in a jar for a bit. Like most C&D it opens up after a week or two. It won’t be a daily smoke but I put it in the routine. Sometimes I take a pinch from it and spice up another blend I’m smoking.
 

Oddball

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 29, 2022
513
2,752
TN
Part of my reviews will be in the form of revisits. This is one such revisit.

I had a Haddo's night cap. As I got into it, it was pretty odd. I had smoked a couple pipe earlier, I suppose my palette was a bit tired. However, about the mid point of the bowl it all bloomed. The flavors really jumped, and I was puffing like mad. Smoked it down to white ash.

Maybe I will unleash the Beast tonight to compare.
 
  • Like
Reactions: khiddy

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,064
11,708
54
Western NY
I bought 3 tins of The Beast this last Fall, 2024 edition.
I really like it, a lot.
And I'm not a huge fan of heavy Perique blends. The Perique used in this blend is more of the fermenting fruit Perique flavor, and not the horseradish burn Perique.
I'm not sure if it's how it's processed, or the type of Perique, or if this is just how Perique acts in large amounts, but it's fantastic. I was going to let the other 2 tins sit for awhile, but now I'm not sure. It could improve, or maybe not.
 

telescopes

Pipe Dreamer and Star Gazer
I bought 3 tins of The Beast this last Fall, 2024 edition.
I really like it, a lot.
And I'm not a huge fan of heavy Perique blends. The Perique used in this blend is more of the fermenting fruit Perique flavor, and not the horseradish burn Perique.
I'm not sure if it's how it's processed, or the type of Perique, or if this is just how Perique acts in large amounts, but it's fantastic. I was going to let the other 2 tins sit for awhile, but now I'm not sure. It could improve, or maybe not.
It will improve.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sig

craig61a

Lifer
Apr 29, 2017
6,623
58,889
Minnesota USA
I haven’t smoked Haddo’s for maybe 2-3 years now…

But I have some stashed away.

There are just to many good VaPers available out there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oddball

filmguerilla

Part of the Furniture Now
Oct 17, 2022
575
3,797
Memphis, Tennessee
I like The Beast quite a bit, Haddo's not so much. On paper, I should like both, but Haddo's just hits different. A bit harsh, with a bitter flavor in there that I can't put my finger on. I have two unopened tins of Haddo's that I'm going to forget about for ten years--maybe that'll fix it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oddball

Oddball

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 29, 2022
513
2,752
TN
Well the Beast and I went a couple rounds over the weekend.


I have to say I am finding it more monotone that I was hoping. It's strong and bold but may not be for me. The last round of Haddo's was much more complex than the last round of the Beast, but the order may matter. Next I will swap them, and go Beast first and a fresh palette and see how that shakes out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sig

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
2,064
11,708
54
Western NY
Well the Beast and I went a couple rounds over the weekend.


I have to say I am finding it more monotone that I was hoping. It's strong and bold but may not be for me. The last round of Haddo's was much more complex than the last round of the Beast, but the order may matter. Next I will swap them, and go Beast first and a fresh palette and see how that shakes out.
I had my only pipe smoking friend over the other day. He's a 25 year old Amish neighbor.
Hey, you gotta find piping friends where you can.
Anyways, he packed up a bowl of The Beast.....after about 20 minutes of watching him squirm, I told him to just dump it out......he did.
He has liked every blend ive ever gave him to try....except this one.
He's used to smoking RYO cigarette tobacco in his pipe. The Beast kicked his butt.
 

Brad H

Lifer
Dec 17, 2024
2,045
10,960
I had my only pipe smoking friend over the other day. He's a 25 year old Amish neighbor.
Hey, you gotta find piping friends where you can.
Anyways, he packed up a bowl of The Beast.....after about 20 minutes of watching him squirm, I told him to just dump it out......he did.
He has liked every blend ive ever gave him to try....except this one.
He's used to smoking RYO cigarette tobacco in his pipe. The Beast kicked his butt.
So after him smoking the beast, will he still be your pipe smoking friend?
 

ClenchedBilliard

Starting to Get Obsessed
May 19, 2021
141
456
Louisiana
I find that Haddos needs a particularly long time to breathe after opening a tin. I pretty much have to open it, forget I even opened it, then find it again a few weeks later in order to get the flavors to pop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Oddball

Oddball

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 29, 2022
513
2,752
TN
Well my final thoughts are as follows.

I had an afternoon meeting I took on the porch. Packed up a pipe with the Beast and sat in for the next 60 minutes.

I stand by my initial thoughts on the Beast. It's good and weird but it's also kind of singular. The Perique is pretty strong both in nic and over all flavor. I enjoyed it and could tell the bowl was ready to tamp out after the hour was up. I think this falls under the specialty category. Meaning I need to be in the mood to face this creature. A mid day or morning smoke, can reveal much more about a blend than one say after a big meal and a beverage, and vice versa.
I am in the tin popping mood, so who knows what is next. Also, I may pull a plug back out of Haddo's and fire up a long cold pipe that needs some new smoke love.

Final thoughts:

Haddo's is the more complex of the two, It's funky and good, and has lots of aforementioned flavor and body.
The Beast is more to the point, perhaps to the point of it's fermented tusks... but that's not a bad thing, just it's thing.

I'm happy to have them both caged up in my cellar for the next time.

Also, as seen in the What are you smoking thread, a big pinch of the beast in a good Virginia blend is really quite nice..