Greetings from a Texan Cigar Convert

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

TimeKiller

Might Stick Around
Feb 2, 2021
84
191
Texas
Happy to have found this place, I have been lurking here for several weeks and decided I wanted an account. These kinds of boards are great and I'm sure they are only seeing a tiny fraction of all the new smokers they have helped.

I always hated cigarettes with a passion, although I really did enjoy the occasional cigar. Sometimes I just wanted to relax and have a cigar, and honestly, they usually overpowered me, even as I started gravitating towards smaller and smaller ones. I would get maybe a third of the way in, was enjoying it, but at some point I was just DONE, although I wasn't done RELAXING hah. I found myself lamenting that half the cigar was usually wasted, especially since they are so expensive! Sometimes I kind of felt like maybe I was at the mercy of the cigar's self contained, pre-packaged experience more than that I was enjoying something the way that I wanted.

Then I started to think about pipe smoking. My grandfather smoked a pipe and of course I knew it was very popular historically. Most pipe smoking that I had ever been around wasn't offensive, almost like a mild incense, vs cigars that will make people run for the doors. I always thought maybe it was too fiddly with the kit and such, figured there was probably a good reason why it lost popularity so fast. But the whole thing seemed to be so chill, and check so many of the boxes I was looking for, so I grabbed a pear pipe, a few drugstore brands and gave it a try.

At first it was exactly as fiddly as I was expecting, burned my tongue immediately, of course. I made stupid mistake of going for a cherry soaked blend and it was super difficult to work with. Ashy taste and hot bowl. Barely a hint of the smell out of the pouch. Bleah! This is awful! Screw this!

But then, I started thinking... Come on now, this can't possibly be that experience that countless people have relished so enthusiastically over the centuries. Just not possible. And after all, I'm the one in control of everything here, like, it wasn't decided for me by a Nicaraguan cigar roller. So I gave it another try, avoided the fruity stuff and tried a more "basic" type of blend. Decided instead to just embrace the fiddly-ness and use a light hand. After some trial and error, the kind of thing that you only learn by experience no matter how much you read, the flavour started to come though. Then I had that.... "AHHH I get it!" moment.

And now here I am, of course, new smoker in that mode where I want to try different blends. Happy to be here. Please feel free to leave recommendations!
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,948
31,777
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
I personally like cigars but love pipes. And one of the things I love about pipes is the variety. All cigars to me have a sameness about them. Not that I can't tell the difference but I've never had a cigar that didn't taste like a cigar if that makes sense. Where as a pipe you can put what tobacco you want in the size of pipe you feel like smoking it in. I also reccomend trying a few cigar leaf blends. Like Key Largo or James Fox The Bankers, both excellent. And nope they aren't a substitute for cigars but their own thing with a certain cigarish quality.
 

BrokenRecord

Starting to Get Obsessed
Jun 26, 2020
192
661
PNW, US
I converted from primarily cigar and cigarettes to pipe smoking after I moved away from Texas. I now live in the Pacific North West and enjoy smoking a pipe in cold and blustery weather.

After moving up here, I remember walking around in a horse pasture smoking a triple maduro cigar that smelled exactly like the horse apples surrounding me. I haven't had a maduro cigar since, though I still enjoy a White Label Ashton on occasion.
 

TimeKiller

Might Stick Around
Feb 2, 2021
84
191
Texas
Welcome from NC!
My recommendations are to go to Smokingpipes.com and order 1 oz samples of a bunch of different bulk tobaccos. That way if you hate it, you are not heavily invested and can try many different types/styles of tobacco.
Thanks, I have done that, kinda sortta, I tried to get a few of the "classic" types that would give me an idea of the major categories. I got Bagpipers Dream, Presbyterian, and Elizabethan. It's pretty crazy how different they are all from eachother, not just in taste but also in the properties of how they smoke. I am lucky enough to have a real tobacconist (didn't even know that was actually a thing until recently hah!), not a headshop, a way up from where I am who also has some house blends I'm trying out. I've definitely taken a liking to the "English" style but I'm not really sure exactly how they are categorized that way.
 

TimeKiller

Might Stick Around
Feb 2, 2021
84
191
Texas
I personally like cigars but love pipes. And one of the things I love about pipes is the variety. All cigars to me have a sameness about them. Not that I can't tell the difference but I've never had a cigar that didn't taste like a cigar if that makes sense. Where as a pipe you can put what tobacco you want in the size of pipe you feel like smoking it in. I also reccomend trying a few cigar leaf blends. Like Key Largo or James Fox The Bankers, both excellent. And nope they aren't a substitute for cigars but their own thing with a certain cigarish quality.
I know exactly what you mean. I'm definitely not giving up my humidor anytime soon, but I can tell I'm going to be planting firmly in pipe tobacco territory. Really appreciate the recommendations, very interesting, definitely want to try that out and see how cigar type of blend would work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anotherbob

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,211
60,649
I used to enjoy a cigar now and then until the prices exploded through the roof. For the cost of one good stick you can buy a tin of premium pipe tobacco that will give you twenty smokes or more. Welcome aboard from central N.C. Besides, pipes are more flexible -- you can mix blends endlessly, once you get a feel for what goes with what, and maybe get a few condimental tobaccos like Latakia, Perique, Turkish, black Cavendish or cigar leaf (!), etc.
 

TimeKiller

Might Stick Around
Feb 2, 2021
84
191
Texas
I used to enjoy a cigar now and then until the prices exploded through the roof.
I wanted to buy a friend of mine a few cigars and a new cutter a while back, plus a few for myself to smoke with him, and my jaw dropped when I went to check out. Especially knowing that my near $100 purchase was only going to represent a few smoking sessions at most. Gaaahhh!! Meanwhile I could have bought 10 people corncobs with enough left over for them all to smoke for a week.

Old Captain Black was really laughing at me from behind the counter that day. :cry:
 
  • Like
Reactions: UncleRasta

macaroni

Lifer
Oct 28, 2020
1,015
3,196
Texas
Welcome from few hours away in NE Texas!
kind regards,
mike
p.s.--great intro post, I'm jealous! You've got at gift for writing--I'm gonna reread it more slowly and enjoy the journey you shared :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TimeKiller
Status
Not open for further replies.