(GAME#1) Pick The Correct Pipe

[Dshift]

In which of these 5 pipes does Nightcap smoke and taste the best?

Answer will be posted after 24h.

1. Meerschaum “Ascorti”
2. Charatan’s Make Belvedere
3. Raganella B34
4. 1976 Peterson’s Donegal Rocky 999
5. 1994 Peterson’s Dingle 999

 

[Briarcutter]

I'll guess........ the Charatan. My first guess was the meerschaum but once I saw the Charatan had to change my vote.

 

[Dshift]

The answer is: Charatan’s Belvedere
Great job @Briarcutter