David Bowie Wrote Good Songs...

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

36 Fresh Chacom Pipes
180 Fresh Peterson Pipes
2 Fresh Wandi Riyadi Pipes
120 Fresh Savinelli Pipes
New Cigars

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

HawkeyeLinus

Lifer
Oct 16, 2020
5,857
42,250
Iowa
He's a "Greatest Hits" artist for me and only a few of those, but the 2 or 3 I like, I like a lot.

IMO, there have been some great albums but few and far between if you are looking for something top notch and all the way through, just didn't work that way most of the time for obvious reasons.

But the truly great albums are truly great, many live.

"Fillmore East" is awesome.

I've found over the years many of the "great" albums are jazz albums - few tracks, but great tracks.
 

Jan 27, 2020
3,997
8,123
I feel like his “hits” on his albums are just so damn good that they can overshadow the other songs a bit but The Rise and Fall… and Low are great albums.

I agree about Low but most of it seems more like it's a Brian Eno album featuring Bowie.

Early one morning years ago I was waiting to get a coffee at some coffeeshop and overheard these two dudes in tight black jeans and unwashed looking hair discuss how T. Rex had a great album but Bowie didn't, can't recall if they were arguing over it...
 

K.E. Powell

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 20, 2022
610
2,262
37
West Virginia
I'm a pretty big admirer of Bowie, so naturally I'm going to disagree.

Depending on how you tally the numbers, he released 25 studio albums (that is excepting live albums, anthologies, etc.) before his death. Bowie was constantly experimenting and challenging himself, so yes, many of his albums do sometimes sound disjointed and uneven (especially his late 80's and 90's releases). But others are grandiose experiments that are aurally and thematically cohesive, taking the listener through a kaleidoscope of wonderful art rock and baroque pop. The obvious examples are Hunky Dory, his fourth album where he truly cemented both his sound and his core artistic approach; and Rise of Ziggy Stardust, a blistering weird and joyous concept album that would lay the thematic foundations of his alien persona(s) during the early and mid 70's. These albums have obvious hits and deep cuts, and both are sequenced well and the latter tells a narrative, however bizarre.

But it's not just those heavy hitters. Blackstar is a jazz-infused album exploring one's mortality. Low is an album cleaved in two parts, the first part a baroque pop affair that uses the metaphors of intimate relationships to talk about (and around) getting over drug addiction, and the second half an atmospheric and purely instrumental collection of compositions that are moody and just plain wonderful. The Next Day and Scary Monsters, though both very different in sound and composition, both share a similar thematic backbone in that lyrically much words are spent looking back on a career with a sense of irony and bemusement, and both albums are straightforward and complete affairs, laden with deep cuts (The Next Day in particular is loaded with them, with Valentine's Day being a particular favorite of mine).

There are some people who treat Bowie as a greatest hits artist, and those people are usually married to his 70's output. It's understandable. His output in the mid-to-late 80's was lousy, and his 90's works, though admirable in the experimental qualities, were uneven. Many fans, especially stateside, had checked out by then. Which is too bad, because his last four albums, Heathen, Reality, The Next Day, and Blackstar are all excellent, with Heathen being a particularly underrated gem.

But even in at his worst, Bowie was always an album oriented artist; for the exception of his some of his more commercial albums such as Let's Dance--albums he made in part to thumb his eye at RCA records for practices he viewed as stifling his creativity--he always worked to make complete albums. Many of the songs he would push as singles were the kind of songs that most publishers were keen not to push, thinking they didn't have radio potential (Ashes to Ashes is the obvious example). Don't write off Bowie as a GH artist. You're missing out if you do.
 

Winnipeger

Lifer
Sep 9, 2022
1,288
9,693
Winnipeg
Waiting until 2 days before you die to release your final album on your own birthday, which turns out to be a deep requiem on your own death, was at the very least the most badass music marketing of all time, not to mention it's a great, innovative album, coming late in — literally at the end of — a decades-long career, proving he was still a vital, creative, artist, until the end, right through sickness and death. Check out the video for Black Star. Talk about creepy...and wonderful.

 

Egg Shen

Lifer
Nov 26, 2021
1,187
3,960
Pennsylvania
I'm a pretty big admirer of Bowie, so naturally I'm going to disagree.

Depending on how you tally the numbers, he released 25 studio albums (that is excepting live albums, anthologies, etc.) before his death. Bowie was constantly experimenting and challenging himself, so yes, many of his albums do sometimes sound disjointed and uneven (especially his late 80's and 90's releases). But others are grandiose experiments that are aurally and thematically cohesive, taking the listener through a kaleidoscope of wonderful art rock and baroque pop. The obvious examples are Hunky Dory, his fourth album where he truly cemented both his sound and his core artistic approach; and Rise of Ziggy Stardust, a blistering weird and joyous concept album that would lay the thematic foundations of his alien persona(s) during the early and mid 70's. These albums have obvious hits and deep cuts, and both are sequenced well and the latter tells a narrative, however bizarre.

But it's not just those heavy hitters. Blackstar is a jazz-infused album exploring one's mortality. Low is an album cleaved in two parts, the first part a baroque pop affair that uses the metaphors of intimate relationships to talk about (and around) getting over drug addiction, and the second half an atmospheric and purely instrumental collection of compositions that are moody and just plain wonderful. The Next Day and Scary Monsters, though both very different in sound and composition, both share a similar thematic backbone in that lyrically much words are spent looking back on a career with a sense of irony and bemusement, and both albums are straightforward and complete affairs, laden with deep cuts (The Next Day in particular is loaded with them, with Valentine's Day being a particular favorite of mine).

There are some people who treat Bowie as a greatest hits artist, and those people are usually married to his 70's output. It's understandable. His output in the mid-to-late 80's was lousy, and his 90's works, though admirable in the experimental qualities, were uneven. Many fans, especially stateside, had checked out by then. Which is too bad, because his last four albums, Heathen, Reality, The Next Day, and Blackstar are all excellent, with Heathen being a particularly underrated gem.

But even in at his worst, Bowie was always an album oriented artist; for the exception of his some of his more commercial albums such as Let's Dance--albums he made in part to thumb his eye at RCA records for practices he viewed as stifling his creativity--he always worked to make complete albums. Many of the songs he would push as singles were the kind of songs that most publishers were keen not to push, thinking they didn't have radio potential (Ashes to Ashes is the obvious example). Don't write off Bowie as a GH artist. You're missing out if you do.
Good critique, but you evoke the Christian Bale character in American Psycho when he gives that discourse about Genesis haha.
 

brian64

Lifer
Jan 31, 2011
10,053
16,121
David produced his best work when he lived next door to Michael Caine.

I couldn't understand anything the Bowie character said but that was still funny.

I never really got into Bowie's music much...liked a few of his songs ok, but most of it that I've heard just didn't resonate with me in a way that motivated me to delve into it more.

But he was a good actor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smudgersmissingleg
Jun 9, 2018
4,508
14,471
England
LOL that clip was from a 1990's UK tv show called Stella Street. It was a comedy show where Michael Caine, Joe Pesci, David Bowie, Jack Nicholson, The Rolling Stones and others all decided to get away from the spotlight and live on a regular British street. Mick and Keith ran the local corner shop/mini mart.


Love Bowie. Ziggy Stardust, The Jean Genie, Heroes, Life On Mars, Starman. So many songs. He was great in The Man Who Fell To Earth.
 

anotherbob

Lifer
Mar 30, 2019
16,847
31,595
46
In the semi-rural NorthEastern USA
When you are the kind of artist that experiments the out put can be very varied. From stellar to meh that's why other people don't write songs like that.
Sorry, I take it David Bowie was an English rock singer?
Yes and a dog is a mammal that induces sweeping in human habitats. See how that statement is factual but not even close to explaining what a dog is. Bowie was Bowie. Great musician and one of the least interesting aspects of what he did too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ron123