there's another point to be made here
the chicago show is a real asset to the entire pipe community. to the enthusiasts who are lucky enough to go, to the people who enjoy it vicariously by hearing about it from their friends, and, since the show is a primary vehicle for introducing new talent and giving it a forum for exposure, to pretty much everyone else who likes artisan pipes and tobaccos. if it disappeared i believe it would leave an awfully big hole that nothing else would quite fill
i've been told that the show ran in the red the last two years. the money made on tables and on tickets sold to walk-ins is pretty predictable in advance. what makes the difference between red ink and black is the silent auction. the same economics, by the way, are true at many pipe events across the country (the kc show and the seattle annual dinner are just two). so, at the margin, what keeps the show in existence is the generosity of everyone willing to contribute something to the auction, and the willingness of attendees to bid
there is good stuff available at the silent auction every year. but two ivarsson pipes is unprecedented. lars makes a pretty small number of pipes each year. for him to give up one for the chicago silent auction is a terrific sacrifice, both in absolute dollars and as a share of his annual income. there are people literally all over the planet badgering him for a single pipe. ditto for his daughter nanna, and ditto for wolfgang becker (who also donated a gorgeous pipe that sold for quite a bit)
i think a real shout-out is owed to everyone who contributed to the auction, and especially to lars, nanna & wolfgang. their generosity was stupendous, and i honor them for it. those three, by themselves, ensured that the show made money this year after two years of losses. and don't kid yourself. things that lose money don't go on forever, at least not without federal funding. anyone out there want to write a grant proposal?