I was a cigar smoker for over 15 years, did tons of my ordering from cigarintl.com (these guys have great pricing and are out of PA) and since you have a humidor/by the box purchase will help bring costs down per cigar...
Some Reqs (this should get you going....sorry so many good ones out there to smoke) :wink:
Ashton VGS (one of many favs) (med-full)
La Perla Habana/Black Perl (a good med-full cigar)
5 Vegas (All lines; Red (med-full), Gold (light-med), A (med), Realic (med-full)
Rocky P Vintage line (med-full)
Drew Java (sweet, mild aro)
Drew Estate Tabak Especial Limited (again one of my favs, sweet mild aro)
Nub (get the sampler and try them all...Nub Plus Habano one of my fav/full)
Gurkha Micro-Batch (I have sooooooooooooo many favs..I can't stop but smoked a few cigars over 15yrs)
Any of the Gurkha lines are FANTASTIC smokes...
Cu-avana (all lines natural, etc.)
Indian Tabac Classic
Puros Indios Viejo