If you want a churchwarden for the cool smoke only, get a meerschaum churchwarden. They have some nice ones on pipesandcigars.com. I only have one Peterson churchwarden, but the bowl is a bit small for me, so it gets pretty hot. They make some of the most beautiful pipes though. Honestly though, it's hard to go wrong if it's on P&C at least in my experience. Just go with the one that looks best in your price range. My favorite churchwarden is my Butz-Choquin Jr Calabash. Beautiful and a cool smoke.