Blends like MCC Oriental mixture No 6?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

29 Fresh Eltang Basic Pipes
36 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes
12 Fresh Castello Pipes
New Cigars
1 Fresh Missouri Meerschaum Pipe

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Sethology12

Might Stick Around
Jan 27, 2023
81
160
Richmond, Va
Hey everyone! I was lucky enough to purchase a couple of these tins from pipe stud and I have not put this tobacco down for the last few days. Delicious, just enough body, sweet vanilla from the orientals. Just a perfect all day smoke. Are there any tobaccos that taste similar? Maybe a dumb question. But I've smoked quite a few and most aren't thisnfriendly... probably due to the age, but still, anyone know of similar currently in production blends?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scottmi

Sethology12

Might Stick Around
Jan 27, 2023
81
160
Richmond, Va
Yenidje Highlander was in a similar vein, but it too was made by McClelland.
I kick myself for having primarily smoked aromatics back when mcclellands was still around. The 40th anniversary and Christmas cheer I have is superb. Not to mention the company ethos, aesthetic, and dedication to quality tobacco is one that is not easily replicable. I spend a silly amount of time missing them and wishing I had plumbed the depths of their offerings more thoroughly. Oh well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chasing Embers

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
45,530
120,960
I kick myself for having primarily smoked aromatics back when mcclellands was still around. The 40th anniversary and Christmas cheer I have is superb. Not to mention the company ethos, aesthetic, and dedication to quality tobacco is one that is not easily replicable. I spend a silly amount of time missing them and wishing I had plumbed the depths of their offerings more thoroughly. Oh well.
I only heavily cellared Yenidje Highlander, Christmas Cheer, and 40th Anniversary out of all they offered.
 

Sethology12

Might Stick Around
Jan 27, 2023
81
160
Richmond, Va
I only heavily cellared Yenidje Highlander, Christmas Cheer, and 40th Anniversary out of all they offered.
I recently purchase a little over a pound of CC. But other than the one tin of 40th, one frog morton, and 3 tins of oriental mixture I'm stuck combing through tinbids when my paycheck hits lol. I'm very curious about their grand oriental series. No one else has chosen to/is able to focus so specifically and charmingly on individual oriental varietals. It is very endearing and speaks volumes of their passion.
 

rmbittner

Lifer
Dec 12, 2012
2,759
2,024
I recently purchase a little over a pound of CC. But other than the one tin of 40th, one frog morton, and 3 tins of oriental mixture I'm stuck combing through tinbids when my paycheck hits lol. I'm very curious about their grand oriental series. No one else has chosen to/is able to focus so specifically and charmingly on individual oriental varietals. It is very endearing and speaks volumes of their passion.
You might enjoy listening to the couple of Pipes Magazine Radio Show episodes featuring McClelland owners Mike and Mary McNiel, if you haven’t already. They were unique personalities within the industry (to me, Mike particularly represents a true iconoclast), and they—and their products—are irreplaceable.
 

blackpowderpiper

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 19, 2018
845
3,960
Middle Tennessee
As with many others, I lament the passing of McC tobacco. Their is a unique flavor/taste to their Virginia tobaccos that I have not found elsewhere. I was lucky enough to have put away a few tins of Christmas Cheer, 40th Anniversary and some Blackwoods Flake. I ration it now, only smoking a bowl now and again. I miss the holiday tradition of picking up a couple tins of that years version of Christmas Cheer.
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
21,171
51,216
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Gone forever. Not coming back. Nobody is like them, nor can anyone produce an equivalent, despite the occasional bullshit claims. Done. Finito. They had a 40 year run until a combination of decreasing crop quality and illness persuaded them to pull the plug.

Buy them on the secondary market if the prices don't bother you. You will not see their like again.

Look for different blends that you enjoy, that are available, and when you do, stock up before their manufacturer swaps out components.
 

rmbittner

Lifer
Dec 12, 2012
2,759
2,024
Look for different blends that you enjoy, that are available, and when you do, stock up before their manufacturer swaps out components.
Sometimes inexplicably. Three Nuns, for instance, is marketed as “the blend that C.S. Lewis smoked,” but it isn’t. Not really. The original Three Nuns was a Virginia spun cut with a perique center. Today’s version, produced by MacBaren, is, bafflingly, a Virginia spun cut with a Kentucky burley center.

I don’t understand the decision making here; perique is still available, after all.

But if you’re going to change such a fundamental ingredient, release it under a different name. But don’t call it Three Nuns, because it no longer contains the ingredients that made Three Nuns Three Nuns. (In fairness to MacBaren, they took over the “new” recipe from Orlik/STG, which introduced the perique-free version when they resurrected the brand name.)
 

blackpowderpiper

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 19, 2018
845
3,960
Middle Tennessee
I wonder if McClelland blends would be as heavily sought after if they were still currently available?

I started smoking a pipe around 1989. During the years after, while a fan of McClelland tobaccos, they were not my all time favorite. There were several of their blends that I enjoyed very much and I kept them around and in my rotation but I did not smoke them to the exclusion of everything else. I will admit to being a fan of their Virginia blends and looked forward especially to Christmas time so that I could pick up my yearly two tins of Christmas Cheer.

But I guess with most things in life, absence makes the heart grow fonder.
 

rmbittner

Lifer
Dec 12, 2012
2,759
2,024
I wonder if McClelland blends would be as heavily sought after if they were still currently available?
I think they might. McClelland was one of the few blenders with a distinct brand identity in terms of their blend flavors and leaf quality. I think that would be even more appealing now, when we’re seeing so many formerly independently produced blends being released (or re-released) by only a small handful of major manufacturers, such as MacBaren, STG, and K&K. In the midst of ever-more consolidation and genericizing among brands and blends, the boutique producers with unique flavor profiles and unique preferences would stand out even more than in the past.

And maybe enough time has passed that all of the—and I’ll just say it—ignorant people complaining about McClelland “ketchup” would have had a chance to actually educate themselves about what they were smoking.
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
21,171
51,216
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
Sometimes inexplicably. Three Nuns, for instance, is marketed as “the blend that C.S. Lewis smoked,” but it isn’t. Not really. The original Three Nuns was a Virginia spun cut with a perique center. Today’s version, produced by MacBaren, is, bafflingly, a Virginia spun cut with a Kentucky burley center.

I don’t understand the decision making here; perique is still available, after all.

But if you’re going to change such a fundamental ingredient, release it under a different name. But don’t call it Three Nuns, because it no longer contains the ingredients that made Three Nuns Three Nuns. (In fairness to MacBaren, they took over the “new” recipe from Orlik/STG, which introduced the perique-free version when they resurrected the brand name.)
Three Nuns has gone through several permutations by it's various rights owners, including a Kentucky DFK version and that's the version that MacBaren mistakenly bought. They thought that they were buying the rights to the Perique version.

The later Savinelli labeled Doblone d' Oro was an attempt to address that error, and the early years, 2014, 2015, maybe as late as 2018 tasted like the VaPer Three Nuns. Newer releases of Doblone d' Oro no longer do. The stuff currently labeled Three Nuns doesn't taste a lot like Three Nuns. There really isn't any VaPer Three Nuns being made.
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
21,171
51,216
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
I wonder if McClelland blends would be as heavily sought after if they were still currently available?
Probably not. With the exception of a few of their blends, Dark Star, the Cheers, Frogs, and a few of the Numbers, people didn't really talk about them here. It was more about H&H, MacBaren, SG, G&H, Germains, Rattray's, etc. C&D generally got mentioned as a joke when it got mentioned at all.

Situation has changed, a little.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Sethology12

Sethology12

Might Stick Around
Jan 27, 2023
81
160
Richmond, Va
Probably not. With the exception of a few of their blends, Dark Star, the Cheers, Frogs, and a few of the Numbers, people didn't really talk about them here. It was more about H&H, MacBaren, SG, G&H, Germains, Rattray's, etc. C&D generally got mentioned as a joke when it got mentioned at all.

Situation has changed, a little.
Poor Cornell and diehl seem to have a grim spectre on their back. Still regardless of criticisms they do offer an affordable, readily available product that is pretty good. I prefer GL peases blends, but their tobacco seems good enough for peases blends purposes so. A shame i only really awoke to some of the better stuff as tobaccos time twilights. Some of you all really took it for granted ;). But you're always gonna long for what you don't have. Best to live in the present I suppose
 
  • Like
Reactions: sablebrush52

fightnhampster

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 14, 2019
944
2,693
Indiana
Look for ... blends that you enjoy, that are available, and when you do, stock up before their manufacturer swaps out components.

This is huge! Even if you find something you like that is in regular production from a large company, it can change out of the blue, without notice.

Stock up, Stock up, Stock up.

I have had some favorites that do not taste like they used to even though they are still in production, by the same company. The only thing I can think of is that the process changed a little bit or the components changed.

Some would argue that my tastes changed, which is very possible, but not to the extent that I have noticed in some blends.
 

fightnhampster

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 14, 2019
944
2,693
Indiana
Poor Cornell and diehl seem to have a grim spectre on their back. Still regardless of criticisms they do offer an affordable, readily available product that is pretty good. I prefer GL peases blends, but their tobacco seems good enough for peases blends purposes so. A shame i only really awoke to some of the better stuff as tobaccos time twilights. Some of you all really took it for granted ;). But you're always gonna long for what you don't have. Best to live in the present I suppose
C&D/ Please comprise 90% of my cellar. I Love 'em 😍