the ways to identfy a birthyear pipe (feel free to complete)
Direct dating:
Based on the stamping
Based on hallmarks (attention some bands are added as a repair, so the pipe in fact could be older)
Based on the series (Pipe of the year, Xmas pipe...)
Indirect dating:
Based on a combination of many things (shape, carver, series, finishes, stamping, catalogs,...) you can usually have a good indication of the production date. Sometimes pinpointing to an exact date, sometimes covering an era of a few years...
The pleasure of a birthyear pipe is not only functional (unless you are a firm believer that everything was better in the earlier days) but more nostalgic. Usually looking for it can also be great fun as the older you get the more difficult you find shapes, finishes to your liking. You are looking for a special pipe to become one of the pinnacles of your collection to be admired or maybe to smoke on special occasions, or maybe to be your all-day smoke, ... You have a piece of briar, that, before it was shaped into a pipe, has been already a few decades in the ground and was produced when you were born. It will age together with you, be there for you during all important stages in life and will probably be in your possession until the day you die. Usually these are higher quality pipes, although some brands are nowadays also producing entry-level series (ideal for birthyear pipes of children and grandchildren without having to break the bank
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Smile :) :)"
)
I have 3 of them now from 1981
A Peterson Mark Twain - bought on this forum. I was looking for a Mark Twain and then this one came up and 1+1 makes 2
A Peterson Deluxe 3s - after having bought the MT, I was looking for my favorite shape -> et voila
A Peterson golden supreme 03 (unsmoked) - as described in a previous post - and for the moment I have no clue what to look for as my next holy grail birthyear pipe. Mind you, I keep collecting modern age Petersons (just in case my GF is reading this
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Smile :) :)"
) This process all in all took over 2 years... and I can imagine it taken longer as well