Werdna: The blue tip matches you remember were Ohio Blue Tips, Diamond matches used to be red. The Ohio Blue Tip matches were the best ever! I have a case of 30 match packs from 1952, they strike literally anywhere. Unfortunately I can't use those every day, because they are no longer manufactured. Diamond bought them in the late '80's and immediately shut them down.
Assaad: I like those Redbird matches too, the reason I like Three Stars better is because of the smell. Redbirds have a stronger sulphur smell than the Three Stars, which smell almost sweet. Thank you for the link, I have never seen them in that bulk before.
Phil22: I didn't know Penley was still in business! I will have to check around, they used to be pretty good.
Checotah: They used to be good matches until they changed their formula 2 years ago. But now they smell and are hard to light, even on the box. The main reason I don't like Diamond is for killing off Ohio Blue Tips.
Here is a photo of a Three Stars box: