The Popsicle Stick Trick

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
6,864
20,018
Reaming thick cake buildup is a PITA. Messy, takes special tools, and if not done carefully can cause permanent damage to a pipe. Depending on the tobacco smoked and chamber height, it can also be EXTREMELY difficult to remove. I've seen it nearly as hard as ceramic and take a half hour.

That's all part of pipe smoking, though, right?

Nope.

You never have to mess with it again. :col:

There is a low cost, low effort, foolproof alternative.

Just get some wooden popsicle sticks---the rounded-end ones about a half inch wide (NOT the mega wide tongue depressors that doctors use)---and before each smoke scrape the sides of the chamber with one. Use firm pressure and don't hold back. The wood they are made from is EXACTLY the right hardness to level the carbon without chipping it, and also the right stiffness to flex slightly and "follow" the surface.

The rounded end also reaches & cleans the bottom of the chamber without any chance of digging into it like a metal blade.

I keep a mug of sticks by my rack, and take the eight seconds to scrape the chamber of a selected pipe as part of the "gather and prep" process before each smoke. (Before smoking rather than after to assure the pipe is cool and dry... reaming cake while it is still hot and wet, even with wood, will give a less even and smooth result.)

Not only is the cake "higher quality" (for lack of a better term), but reaming "as you go" is like a golf course mowing its greens every morning... You'll never have to deal with heavy buildup again.

The rule that every engineering decision involves trade-offs seems to not apply here. There are no negatives. Even the cost---$11 for a thousand---is vanishingly small. (Each end of a stick can be used about four times. That's 8000 reams per package, or ten year's worth at two smokes per day.)



Screen Shot 2022-10-07 at 3.07.03 PM.png
 
Aug 1, 2012
5,004
5,909
USA
So now we'll be searching for the perfect grain on the popsicle sticks...I wonder if blasted ones have less friction due to the surface area to diffuse the heat from reaming therefore causing a cooler reaming experience. Also, do Peterson popsicle sticks have the wrong coating or does their staining process have any effect on the reaming process? As we know, Dunhill popsicle sticks are not as good as their older ones and are overpriced...I wonder if they could be used in bonsai. And of course we know that Lee made the best popsicle sticks in Humansville too.
 

Papamique

Part of the Furniture Now
Mar 11, 2020
864
4,071
Thank you! A great recommendation that I will certainly try. The other thing I do before smoking is empty the ash tray.
 

simong

Lifer
Oct 13, 2015
2,760
16,594
UK
First off, you sir have got to be the most talented, gifted & professional ‘pipe man’ the forum’s have ever seen. But come on, you’re taking the mick, surely? If not, well, not sure what to say really.
Must be an American thing, dry tobacco, wide open draw, water rinsing & now popsicle sticks. I’m speaking for myself of course but I doubt I’m alone in thinking you guys are always overthinking things, no?
Cake is good, good tobacco is even better. Maybe over here in the UK & Ireland we’ve been spoilt with knowing nothing but the best, negating the search for ‘a better way’ of doing things?
I & many others have learned a lot from yourself & other restorer’s over the years but I’ll pass on the popsicle stick trick George, sorry.
Pipe, pipe knife & tobacco. All one needs, if not ‘ vive la difference’.
 
  • Like
Reactions: romaso

Ryan

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 30, 2021
692
5,241
Noblesville Indiana USA
So now we'll be searching for the perfect grain on the popsicle sticks...I wonder if blasted ones have less friction due to the surface area to diffuse the heat from reaming therefore causing a cooler reaming experience. Also, do Peterson popsicle sticks have the wrong coating or does their staining process have any effect on the reaming process? As we know, Dunhill popsicle sticks are not as good as their older ones and are overpriced...I wonder if they could be used in bonsai. And of course we know that Lee made the best popsicle sticks in Humansville too.
To be honest, if you aren’t using sticks that have been aged at least ten years and oil cured, I’m not even sure there is a point to any of it.

Personally I only use sticks made of old growth Algerian, aged in a cave underneath the Black Forest and attended by small gnomes to coax the essence of the wood out to the “blade edges” of the stick. It enhances the nuances of Virginia blends and seems to strengthen some burley blends.
 

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
6,864
20,018
So now we'll be searching for the perfect grain on the popsicle sticks...I wonder if blasted ones have less friction due to the surface area to diffuse the heat from reaming therefore causing a cooler reaming experience. Also, do Peterson popsicle sticks have the wrong coating or does their staining process have any effect on the reaming process? As we know, Dunhill popsicle sticks are not as good as their older ones and are overpriced...I wonder if they could be used in bonsai. And of course we know that Lee made the best popsicle sticks in Humansville too.

This man ^^^^ understands how the ForumWorld works. rotf
 

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
6,864
20,018
To be honest, if you aren’t using sticks that have been aged at least ten years and oil cured, I’m not even sure there is a point to any of it.

Personally I only use sticks made of old growth Algerian, aged in a cave underneath the Black Forest and attended by small gnomes to coax the essence of the wood out to the “blade edges” of the stick. It enhances the nuances of Virginia blends and seems to strengthen some burley blends.

And so does this one ^^^^ bdw
 

renfield

Unrepentant Philomath
Oct 16, 2011
5,889
52,268
Kansas
All my popsicle sticks have sweet tasting frozen orange stuff on them. Should that be removed prior to de-carbonizing the bowl?

Great tip. It would take some real ingenuity to damage a pipe with a popsicle stick.👍
 
  • Like
Reactions: brian64

simong

Lifer
Oct 13, 2015
2,760
16,594
UK
Try it before hitting the eject button. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.
Because you said so, I’ll put a pipe by & try it……i’ll be flabbergasted though, if I notice an improvement or any difference at all. Being a heavy smoker most of my work pipes get caked up heavily before I get round to trimming the cake back. I’ve not experienced any ‘surprises’ pleasant or unpleasant, regards to cake thickness.
Are you saying with the ‘popsicle ream’ the cake is more ‘compressed & crack free‘ giving a cleaner or slightly more intense smoke?
One of those I’ll have to try for myself I suppose. Hitherto, if I feel the smoke is ‘lacking’ something, I just reach for a stronger blend.
I shall defer & give it a go, nonetheless.
 
  • Like
Reactions: romaso

georged

Lifer
Mar 7, 2013
6,864
20,018
Because you said so, I’ll put a pipe by & try it……i’ll be flabbergasted though, if I notice an improvement or any difference at all. Being a heavy smoker most of my work pipes get caked up heavily before I get round to trimming the cake back. I’ve not experienced any ‘surprises’ pleasant or unpleasant, regards to cake thickness.
Are you saying with the ‘popsicle ream’ the cake is more ‘compressed & crack free‘ giving a cleaner or slightly more intense smoke?
One of those I’ll have to try for myself I suppose. Hitherto, if I feel the smoke is ‘lacking’ something, I just reach for a stronger blend.
I shall defer & give it a go, nonetheless.

Something I didn't specifically mention in the original post (but should have to avoid possible confusion) is the popsicle stick is NOT a substitute for an actual steel reamer, regardless of type (bladed, triangular, etc.)

Any pipe you want to use a popsicle stick on should be reamed to the thickness you personally prefer---whether nearly none, a dime, a nickel, whatever---with a steel reamer (or sandpaper) before changing over.

Then, that pipe will stay AT that thickness pretty much forever and not have to be cut down again.

Another benefit is how the wooden stick scrapes the cake at a micro-level (for lack of a better term). It leaves it more structurally sound. Wood compacts and smooths while scraping as opposed to steel's chisel-like chipping and cutting, which after a while leaves the chamber looking and feeling almost like it has a black ceramic lining.

I truly wish I'd discovered this 48 years ago.

No mick-taking is underway, I promise. ;)
 

monty55

Lifer
Apr 16, 2014
1,738
3,516
67
Bryan, Texas
I see the benefit here with what you're doing. However, personally, I kinda enjoy spending some time on occasion scraping and fussing over my cake with my fancy dancy carbon cake bowl removal tools. I like seeing how thick I can get the cake, and I like seeing the pile of scrapings after I do a good job with my special tools. But hey, that's what makes pipe smoking great... everyone gets to do it they're own way!
 
Dec 10, 2013
2,806
3,619
Nijmegen, the Netherlands
Actually I discovered this 20 years + ago, but it seemed so silly I did not dare to share. And yes, you infidels , It works like a charm.
I'm quite happy you posted Maester George ; sharing silliness on the appropiate forum is the most wonderful thing imaginable. Keep on posting more of your wonderful eccentricities , it will help me posting mine.
 
  • Wow
  • Like
Reactions: romaso and Reggie

Hillcrest

Lifer
Dec 3, 2021
4,905
27,847
Connecticut, USA
Excellent idea ! Should we dedicate certain sticks to types of cake build up ? I would think natural birchwood would be better for aromatics. Also if you wipe the stick with a paper towel you might be able to use it on more than one pipe but YMMV. ;) :ROFLMAO: