Would like some advice and opinions on tobaccos

[wadewright]

Hello I am in need of some help.I'm a really huge fan of vanilla tobacco and was wondering which tobacco I could go with for the very best taste and smell?thank you in advance for the help

 

[gervais]

Do you want some tobacco flavour in there as well, or just vanilla?

 

[sablebrush52]

Hello I am in need of some help.I'm a really huge fan of vanilla tobacco and was wondering which tobacco I could go with for the very best taste and smell?thank you in advance for the help

The two most popular are Lane 1Q and Captain Black White.

 

[wadewright]

Do you want some tobacco flavour in there as well, or just vanilla?

I would love a lot of vanilla maybe not all vanilla but want it to be the majority. I am willing to try them all just love it.I'm currently trying Stand-alone vanilla and am getting a weird smell from it..fresh tin

 

[wadewright]

I would love a lot of vanilla maybe not all vanilla but want it to be the majority. I am willing to try them all just love it.I'm currently trying Stand-alone vanilla and am getting a weird smell from it..fresh tin

Stanwell not stand alone

 

[Deano]

I like MB Vanilla but the vanilla taste is faint. Room note is where the vanilla shows up. Or is it smells up? Its one of the few MB blends that dont bite me.

 

[romaso]

For strong, sweet vanilla, try Lane MV-1000 (Capt Black Gold in bulk). For a lighter vanilla with tobacco taste, my favorite is Mac Baren Vanilla Cream. They are both mostly or all Virginia tobaccos.

The Lane is too sweet for me on it's own, so I blend in straight Virginia.

 

[cosmicfolklore]

Mac Baren: Vanilla Cream​

Of course this is based on whether or not you think tasting just the vanilla is best or if you want some tobacco taste in there.

 

[anotherbob]

Best advice is to try them all and see which ones you like. Sadly I don't know if I can find my favorite one any more. It was a Seatle Pipe Club blend made by Lane. It was in a metal round tin. And the thing that made it different was that the Vanilla had this liquor taste but also a very genuine Vanilla. Like some kind of booze infused with Vanilla or made from it.... But the Vanilla was very full spectrum Vanilla. And that kind of supports my point. There are lots of little touches that can make a big difference.
I personally don't smoke a lot of Vanilla blends (for reasons), but the only ones I haven't enjoyed have been Captain black and it was just because it has too much PG in it.

 

[MikeDub]

Mac Baren Vanilla Roll Cake is another one that has a very obvious vanilla flavor. They use Madagascar Vanilla for this one which I think stands out more than the usual vanilla flavors used for most aromatics. It's probably my favorite aromatic

 

[wadewright]

I like MB Vanilla but the vanilla taste is faint. Room note is where the vanilla shows up. Or is it smells up? Its one of the few MB blends that dont bite me.

I really enjoy it also just ordered a bag and I agree 100% the vanilla is faint.I wish they would fix it really great tobacco,wish I knew how to add vanilla myself.

 

[hoosierpipeguy]

MB Vanilla Roll Cake.

 

[Coreios]

Sutliff Cream Brulee aka Sutliff Molto Dolce.

 

[Winnipeger]

Sutliff Vanilla Custard is a very Vanilla-y Aro. Good mixer IMO. One more vote here for MacBaren Vanilla Roll Cake though, as the best of the bunch, but it also tastes like tobacco.

 

[wadewright]

MB Vanilla Roll Cake.

That's sounds so good!!!gonna order some

 

[wadewright]

Sutliff Vanilla Custard is a very Vanilla-y Aro. Good mixer IMO. One more vote here for MacBaren Vanilla Roll Cake though, as the best of the bunch, but it also tastes like tobacco.

See I love the tobacco taste!!!thank you

 

[ray47]

Lane BCA (Black Cavendish) is good by itself or mixed with other blends.

 

[lukasstrifeson]

MB Vanilla Roll Cake.

+1 for this Mac Baren

Great 'aromatic' where the tobacco is still front and center; as opposed to something like Creme Brulee - which is more of a snap-crackle-n-pop kind of aromatic.

 

[AppalachianPipe92]

+1 for Mac Baren Vanilla - either the Flake or the roll cake.

 

[fireground_piper]

Also suggest the Mac Baren vanilla trio. For me, the loose has the most topping experience. Flake is in the middle. Roll cake has more of a baking spice vanilla quality to it.