This Ain't Tobacco. I'm Done.

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

Davy

Can't Leave
Nov 22, 2022
324
885
I have been smoking a pipe for the last 35 years. I started off with inexpensive briars, stuff like Captain Black, Sail and Amphora before moving on with tinned tobacco 5 or 6 years after beginning. Eventually, I have also upgraded my briars for something better.
I have tried hundreds of brands. I have made a lot of mistakes during these years but kept learning. I've smoked in cold, warm, dry and very humid weather.
Throughout these decades, I cannot remember pipe tobacco being so difficult to smoke as it has been over the last few years. Being never ending moist as the blends I have purchased over the last 3- 4 years have been.
I remember pouch tobacco like Mac Baren and Amphora, in the 90s. If they were not consumed within a few weeks, they would get really dry and bland. Now? Holy cow it never dries up.
What the hell are they doing to my tobacco?
I can't explain how tobacco like Doblone d'Oro, being bone dry (upon opening) and breaking when preparing it, will not light up properly and stay lit. Or how pouch tobacco, after being unsealed for 4 - 5 months, is still super moist and won't smoke properly, even after spending the night drying out on a sheet of paper.
In any case, this morning something snapped after I tried, once more, to enjoy a pipeful.
Frustration took the better out of me. Threw out a bunch of tins.
I've had it being sold garbage manufacturers call 'pipe tobacco'. That ain't it no more.
I am done. I am giving up smoking a pipe. This is not even worth it anymore.
Manufacturers can take whatever they add to the tobacco and shove it. I worked too hard for my money.
Yes, I am angry. Rightfully so.
I never thought this day would come, but it did.
I wonder how many new guys we're losing who try and try and try and say screw this and smoke cigars, instead.
Because this is what I am going to do, from now on.
Smoke cigars. At least, they are smokeable and still made of tobacco. Unlike pipe 'tobacco'.

Over the next weeks I will be putting up my cellar for sale, for the benefit of the Canadian members. Watch out for some really sweet deals.
 

FLDRD

Lifer
Oct 13, 2021
2,225
9,023
Arkansas
Way newer than you to the scene, so anything I have to say is naturally irrelevant -

but sometimes I find a good chamber scrubbing / sanding sort of helps things start over again, (or a new pipe)

Sort of like cleaning the soot out of the chimney now and again.

Smooooths it all out and makes it easy again. For me, it ain't always the tobacco.

Or I try a brand new-to-me tobacco

Or it's a conspiracy to sell less tobacco
;)
 

sablebrush52

The Bard Of Barlings
Jun 15, 2013
20,675
48,797
Southern Oregon
jrs457.wixsite.com
There could be a few factors involved, such as your preferred blends being loaded with polyglycol or some such inhibitor. Some blends, mostly bulks made for distribution using a variety of “house” names, have more of this sort of additive.
But Doblone d’Oro is quite dry in the tin. I’ve smoked quite a lot of it and never once had the slightest difficulty. So while you’ve been pipe smoking for 35 years, it’s possible that you never figured out how to do it properly.
Of course, the last few years have seen a downward trajectory with the quality of a number of blends, and maybe that’s happened with Doblone o’Oro. None of my stock is later than 2018.
If cigars offer a better experience, why not make the switch? They’re a simpler pleasure.
Personally, I moved away from cigars 20 years ago as the quality became more variable.
Enjoy your cigars and I’ll enjoy my pipes.
 

mso489

Lifer
Feb 21, 2013
41,210
60,610
I've not noticed this, though I have been smoking, with intermissions, for about 40 years. A few lauded blends that have been hard to keep lit I have run through a hand grater which improved their burn. But I would agree that a nice even burn without too many relights really makes a pipe worthwhile. If I'm twiddling too much with lights and tampers, the ritual and meditation of the activity goes away. Sorry to hear you've had it, but I appreciate the sentiment.
 

El Capitán

Lifer
Jun 5, 2022
1,175
4,853
34
Newberry, Indiana
I rarely get a smoke that burns down to white ash with no relights and sometimes the frequent relights can be a little frustrating. I just chalk it up to user error on my part but that’s just me.
Maybe take a break and come back to it?
I second taking a break. I have one pipe that always burn to white ash but usually I have a relight occasionally. I've gotten lucky with my tobacco being just right minus my last pound of Sutliff Mark Twain.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.