The Problem of Too Much Selection

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Country Squire Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Tobacco Treasures Ad
Status
Not open for further replies.

Casual

Preferred Member
Oct 3, 2019
2,342
8,269
NL, CA
Since I’m new to this, I am trying to survey the breadth of blends available. I started with thirty or so well-rated blends from all sorts of the spectrum, to get a feel for what’s available. That took quite a while to get through, at my pace.

Each time I find something I like, which is often, I research to see if I got the best expression of that style of blend. Each time I find ten or more new blends to try. At this rate it seems like one has to become JimInks to settle on having found one’s favourites.

So when do you settle down and say, “this is good enough?” Sure, you haven’t tried Germain’s Esoterica Whatever, or McClelland’s 1997 crop of red Va, but you‘ve found a good place to stop, at least for now. Every time I declare that point, in two days I’m back on tobacco reviews hunting for the next thing to try.
 
  • Like
Reactions: danimalia

d4k23

Senior Member
Mar 6, 2018
395
449
Texas
For me it was when I realized my cellar is too large for my foreseeable consumption. The tobacco's I have will suit me just fine for quite some time, with enough variety that when I finish open tins (which could take a few months) I know I have something similar to replace it with.

That and I realized I have spent too much and ran out of tub storage space.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Casual

unkleyoda

Preferred Member
Aug 22, 2016
1,126
64
Your mom\\\'s house
Good question. For me it was when I started trying to fine things that tasted like something I had already smoked. Early on, I found that Latakia was my thing. I started chasing a flavor profile. I settled into the flavors I like best.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Casual

condorlover1

Preferred Member
Dec 22, 2013
5,911
12,879
New York
Well my friends that dilemma will be solved shortly if the FDA have their wicked way - we will have four state approved blends to choose from assuming you can get a 'Medical Tobacco Card'. Yours truly will be laying on the Beach having made a fortune as the first tobacco bootlegger who made a profit with Canadian tins of Mixture 79. On a serious note there are so many interesting things about that even an old curmudgeon like myself has discovered a few things outside of blocks of road tar and hedge clippings he enjoys. Enjoy the variety whilst it lasts my friends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: spartacus

rdoss16

Member
Sep 2, 2019
146
210
Since I’m new to this, I am trying to survey the breadth of blends available. I started with thirty or so well-rated blends from all sorts of the spectrum, to get a feel for what’s available. That took quite a while to get through, at my pace.

Each time I find something I like, which is often, I research to see if I got the best expression of that style of blend. Each time I find ten or more new blends to try. At this rate it seems like one has to become JimInks to settle on having found one’s favourites.

So when do you settle down and say, “this is good enough?” Sure, you haven’t tried Germain’s Esoterica Whatever, or McClelland’s 1997 crop of red Va, but you‘ve found a good place to stop, at least for now. Every time I declare that point, in two days I’m back on tobacco reviews hunting for the next thing to try.
this is literally how i feel right now. word for word. glad im not alone!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Casual

cosmicfolklore

Preferred Member
Aug 9, 2013
26,963
34,641
Helena, Alabama
Don't get caught up in bests or favorites... having come away from cigarettes, where one sticks to a brand come hell or high water, I am enjoying just grazing the selections. Try it all. I have only run across a handful out of the hundreds of blends that I have smoked that I thought were terrible.

Just when I think, "I am a Virginia smoker," along comes a few burley varieties that appeal to me... or, when I think, "I hate latakia," I find one that sparks me going through and re-trying latakias again. Just keep an open mind and enjoy the smoke.
 

haparnold

Preferred Member
Aug 9, 2018
1,562
2,357
Colorado Springs, CO
What Cosmic said.

And at the end of the day, if you like it, it's good tobacco. I know some very serious wine guys who enjoy a $10 bottle of something you can buy at a supermarket every bit as much as some really rare vintages. It's fun to graze, but don't feel like you're missing out just because the VA Flake/English blend/whatever you're currently smoking isn't considered the be-all-end-all by somebody else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Casual

Casual

Preferred Member
Oct 3, 2019
2,342
8,269
NL, CA
Interesting array of responses. I suspect it’ll be easier once I’ve tried enough blends to think that I’ve been there and done that when new ones come out.
 

mso489

Preferred Member
Feb 21, 2013
36,116
37,303
The quest is fun. I think we've all been conditioned, or more correctly conditioned ourselves, to keep the endless buffet of blends marching through our cellars. On the other hand, don't be afraid to settle down with what you have for a while and see how the experience of a blend can evolve over time. In my case, I try not to buy huge quantities of a blend, simply because that makes me look at newer offerings. At my moderate rate of use, using up the stash is unlikely. My dad smoked for fifty years, only using one pipe at a time, and only smoking Granger (with a few years off for King Edward cigars). So I remember that when the dance of variety takes over my brain.
 

danimalia

Preferred Member
Sep 2, 2015
4,168
24,469
39
San Francisco Bay Area, USA
Lots of good advice froim the wise folks above.

Man, I just love trying all the different blends. It is my favorite part of pipe smoking. I've only been pipe smoking for a few years, but every time I get a package or a new bag/tin from the B&M, I get a thrill.

I just keep buying new stuff, and I'll also mix in blends I know I love. For example, in my last order, I had 8 different tobaccos. 6 were new to me, but I also got tins of HH Bold Kentucky and Maltese Falcon, because they're favorites and I wanted to re-visit them.
 

shanez

Preferred Member
Jul 10, 2018
3,930
14,717
47
Las Vegas
In my cellar I have:

My occasional blends that are too strong for me to smoke regularly (GH&C Dark Flake Unscented, SPC Plum Pudding SR, C&D Dreams of Kadath, etc.).
My regular blends that I can smoke anytime (SG St James Flake, Ashton Artisan's Blend, Manil Le Petit Robin, etc.).
My regular of regulars that is my old reliable (Sutliff Sweet Virginia).

Then I have some stuff floating around that I don't cellar or smoke regularly but will probably buy more after it's gone just because it's nice to have options.

This is a good problem to have. With so many options I can wait for sales to take advantage of or for hard to get blends to simply show up in stock and not pay over inflated prices.
 

mso489

Preferred Member
Feb 21, 2013
36,116
37,303
I think chasing' did us a favor when he prompted at least several of us to try Mixture No. 79. Contentment comes in many forms. Then there is always mixing a limited number of single leaf or blends.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chasing Embers

hoosierpipeguy

Preferred Member
Jan 28, 2018
7,100
31,623
There is no such thing as too much of a selection with one possible exception. If quality has been compromised for the sake of quality. And I don't believe that is the case with pipe tobacco. Usually too little selection is the result of lack of competition which often leads to poor quality and high prices.

Find your favorite genre and read reviews for blends in that genre. Try a few. Then try a few more. Over time, you'll likely get to most of the ones that matter. Cellar the ones you like best and don't want to live without if they are ever discontinued.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.