Since It Is Baseball Time Again- Greatest Hitter Ever?

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

New Cigars




PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Status
Not open for further replies.

judcole

Lifer
Sep 14, 2011
7,150
32,941
Detroit
There is, according to Charlie Steiner, a steroid player already in the Hall of Fame, though Charlie refused to name him.
Not worth much, then, is it?

As far as I am concerned, a comparison between Rose and steroid users is irrelevant. Rose violated the rules of baseball, knew it, and shows no remorse. Why should he be reinstated?
I thought Barry Bonds was the best hitter - has that changed?

I'm not sure anyone ever thought that; if they did - how can you make a claim like that for someone who is a heavy steroid used?

I can think of no better example of hubris in modern athletics that Bonds. He had huge amounts of talent, and would probably have gotten to the Hall of Fame. Now...

 
Dec 24, 2012
7,195
456
Jud are you saying Barry Bonds isn't in the hall of fame? Doesn't he have the most home runs in the history of the game? How can that be?
Ok, admittedly this Canuck knows zilch about baseball.
I know there has been some controversy about steroids in sports. Was it actually not allowed in baseball during the time bonds is alleged to have used them?

 

docrx

Part of the Furniture Now
Jan 9, 2011
842
1
I 'll mention Stan Musial , Hank Greenberg,and Ralph Kiner as 3 of the best!

 

eaglerico

Lifer
Jan 8, 2011
1,134
1
Just to throw out some lesser know people but great hitters none the less. I hate that hitting debates almost always turns into a HR debates, not that his one has. I like this one. (I can't believe no one jumped on my Jordan comment)
Craig Biggio

Jeff Bagwell

Ivan Rogriguez

Cal Ripken Jr.

Tony Gywn

Ken Griffey Jr.

Chipper Jones

Todd Helton

 

kcghost

Lifer
May 6, 2011
13,159
21,434
77
Olathe, Kansas
I hope the guys referring to Rose as the greatest are joking. He isn't remotely in conversation. Holding a counting statistic record isn't a validation of quality.
There are only three guys in the conversation for greatest hitter: Ruth, Williams, and Bonds. Ruth dominated the game that is unfathomable today. He also lost some years as a pitcher so that neutralizes the Williams war factor. Bonds was the most feared hitter of his day, but there were a bunch of guys who were hitting the cover off the ball in the home run/steroid era.
I'll take Ruth.

 

uberam3rica

Lifer
Sep 7, 2011
4,015
9
Capac, Michigan
Heres an interesting thought about Babe Ruth. In his time onely white people were allowed to play. I wonder if he would still be so o great. There might have been someone better, but they were black

 

teufelhund

Lifer
Mar 5, 2013
1,497
3
St. Louis, MO
I would like to point out that hitting the most home runs has nothing to do with being a good hitter. Hell the babe struck out something like 2x as many strike outs as he does homers. Give me the guy who gets on base and has the legs to get the triple when he should rather than be winded reaching second base.

 

judcole

Lifer
Sep 14, 2011
7,150
32,941
Detroit
I 'll mention Stan Musial , Hank Greenberg,and Ralph Kiner as 3 of the best!
Amen!
I would like to point out that hitting the most home runs has nothing to do with being a good hitter. Hell the babe struck out something like 2x as many strike outs as he does homers. Give me the guy who gets on base and has the legs to get the triple when he should rather than be winded reaching second base.
Cobb.
Jud are you saying Barry Bonds isn't in the hall of fame? Doesn't he have the most home runs in the history of the game? How can that be?
Steroids.
Uber has an interesting point - there were some great black ballplayers that, because of racism, never got a chance to play in the MLB. Josh Gibson and Cool Papa Bell come to mind right away.
"I remember one game I got five hits and stole five bases, but none of it was written down because they didn't bring the scorebook to the game that day." - Cool Papa Bell

 
Dec 24, 2012
7,195
456
A hall of fame that doesn't have the best players in it like Bonds and Rose really doesn't have much credibility, does it? It's a little like a museum devoted to the world's best sports cars that doesn't have any ferraris.
I don't really understand the whole steroid thing. It is their body and a personal choice. Then again, I confess I have never followed the whole thing.

 

cigrmaster

Lifer
May 26, 2012
20,249
57,280
66
Sarasota Florida
Guys, you need to look at that site and then look at all the different categories, yes more hit home runs, yes more had more rbi's, yes more had hits, but you are not taking into account 5 years lost do to war, plus all the other categories. Look at the categories I listed and then compare your favorites to Williams. It is not just one category that makes the best hitter, it is a multitude. If you look at all the categories and see where Williams places in all of them, it is hands down Williams.
On another note, the greatest fielder in the history of the game was without a doubt Brooks Robinson, he did things that I have never seen anyone else do. The most dominant pitcher was Sandy Koufax, look at his numbers, they are mind boggling.
Every player that took steroids is automatically out of the running, they cheated and are not worthy of consideration.
Also look at Ichiro's numbers and look at how many consecutive 200 hit seasons he had, simply incredible.

 
Dec 24, 2012
7,195
456
I'm pulling your chain. I'm not even sure who ted Williams is - is he the guy who was married to Marilyn Monroe?

 

teufelhund

Lifer
Mar 5, 2013
1,497
3
St. Louis, MO
I am ashamed to admit this oversight, but I feel it is my duty to rescind my previous nomination and say +1 for Stan the Man... As a St. Louis native I feel it is my duty. Rest in peace Stan...

 
Dec 24, 2012
7,195
456
My vote goes for the guy who married Marilyn Monroe (whoever that was) - I mean, who wouldn't try to hit that.

 

ghost

Lifer
May 17, 2012
2,001
4
Not having the Expos is still painful, but I digress...
The beauty of baseball is that you can have a conversation like this that compares players over generations unlike any other sport because the game itself hasn't changed that much, steroids be damned. I believe that if you had a time machine and had Carl Hubbell at his prime pitch to Bonds in his prime, you would still have an epic matchup that could go either way. Put the 1939 Bruins against the 2013 Bruins, using hockey as an example, and you have a massacre.
Getting back to the topic at hand, even though I never saw any of them play, I'd vote for Ted Williams but I probably could be lured to Willie Mays side too.
Babe Ruth can't be left out of the conversation for greatest hitter of course, but I would say that he should be considered the greatest player of all time since he was also a heck of a pitcher! All on a diet of booze and hot dogs...breakfast of champions!

 

ghost

Lifer
May 17, 2012
2,001
4
peck, don't even make me take a bat to your head, besides what the hell do canucks know about the American pastime. lol
This one knows more about baseball than hockey, baseball was always my favourite sport although I played both. I'm the kid that memorized the stats on the cards, and would read Total Baseball over and over. I still love the game, and I follow the Red Sox now, but my heart is still with an ugly UFO shaped monstrosity in east end Montreal. :mrgreen:

 
Status
Not open for further replies.