I have been smoking my Eaton and pony express more than ever lately. I can’t say that I notice much difference between the varnished (plastered?) pony express and the natural Eaton. I can say the bowl diameter—roughly .6 inch—is perfect for me and the tobacco I smoke. The bowl Depth is also ideal. Looking at the mm site, I see there are a number of other pipes with this bowl size, most of them varnished . I’m going to try more of them
The founder of Missouri Meerschaum did not invent the corn cob pipe, but did patent a process to plaster pipes to toughen them.
Missouri Meerschaum 5 cent pipes started an entire Missouri pipe industry with over 20 pipe factories in just Washington Missouri by the turn of the 20th century. After the patent expired all corn cob pipes were plastered.
If ever in Washington Missouri visit the factory.
On the west end there’s a chute where cobs that have been seasoned two years in the upper floors come down and on the East there are older women packaging the final product, and in between are a series of machines over a century old where workers perform work on the cob of each pipe at stations, then pass the cob on East, until an older woman puts the metal ring and plastic stem in the pipe and bubble wraps it, after final inspection.
Natural pipes are those that bypass the plastering and varnishing stations.
The ones you really want are the Freehands. One worker takes the largest cobs and hand makes pipes at one station on the west by the chute and then takes them in a box to the packaging stations on the East.
When I was there before Covid almost all the workers were multigenerational descendants of people who worked the exact same machines in same factory all of their lives.
They make the best cob pipes on this earth.
They’ve forgotten how to make bad ones over 150 years ago.