Recommend me a New All Day Smoke to Replace Carter Hall and Prince Albert

[towhee89]

So, I'm a simpleton when it comes to blends, preferring to buy pipes and keep the tobacco the same. Dominican CH or PA mixed with a little 5 Brothers has been my all day smoke for a while now. I've always noticed a bit of a chemical taste especially with CH, but throwing 5 Bros in the mix, toned it down some. I've tried airing out both and it seemed to help, but these last few tubs I have noticed are particularly chemical tasting. I tried other blends I have and didn't taste chemicals, but my allergies have been known to really mess up the taste of smoke. The old pouches of PA were more chemical tasting to me than the new Dominican funnily enough.

I guess I'm at the point where I am really wanting to find a non codger/otc blend that is still in the same ballpark to smoke mindlessly all day. I was thinking of trying Pegasus by C and D as I heard it's a souped up modern codger blend, but I'd love to hear your suggestions. LJ Peretti and Uhle sound right up my alley, they're just a tad pricey to smoke all day. Also a friend recommended me Cowboy Coffee from Country Squire.

 

[greatdane]

Milan Tobacconists sells "their version" of several Middleton classics, including PA and CH. Have heard good things but haven't tried them myself. Worth a try.

I agree with you, the Prince Albert produced in Dominican Republic is less chemical tasting. It's better than the original IMO.

 

[dd57chevy]

I would suggest Watch City or Wilke . You can get as little as 2 oz of several blends from each .
I like WC Fat Bastard blend .

 

[Kobold]

Boswells premium burley or old school are good options.

 

[Butter Side Down]

PS 41 Cube Cut maybe. A bit pricier than Carter Hall, but not outrageous.

Uhle's 00, 300 and Perfection Plug are all good too, but as you pointed out, quite a bit more expensive.

 

[philobeddoe]

Try C&D Briar Fox, it’s a Burley/Virginia blend, nice, easy and still tasty smoke.

 

[Lumbridge]

Try D&R Two Timer if you like simple, quality burley.

 

[Brad H]

Try C&D Briar Fox, it’s a Burley/Virginia blend, nice, easy and still tasty smoke.

I was going to say Briar Fox as well. It has the bonus of coming in a pound brick.

Also can’t go wrong with cowboy coffee but I don’t think of cowboy coffee as an all day smoke.

 

[Lumbridge]

Try D&R Two Timer if you like simple, quality burley.

There's also Two Timer Gold which has a bit of Virginia added.

 

[towhee89]

Try D&R Two Timer if you like simple, quality burley.

I am a huge fan of d and r blends for myo sticks, I've wanted to try this for years but never got around to it. Windsail Platinum and Vengeur I really liked also.

 

[Bbailey324]

C&D Winchester is a good codger-ish blend. Other C&D blends previously mentioned are good as well.

WCC FUSTG and American Cut Plug also fall in that codger niche. I've just recently tried these two and find myself reaching for one of them when I might otherwise smoke PA. Winchester is a long time favorite at this point.

 

[Lumbridge]

I am a huge fan of d and r blends for myo sticks, I've wanted to try this for years but never got around to it. Windsail Platinum and Vengeur I really liked also.

I like their blends that come in a thicker pipe cut. It's just good, plain baccy at a great price.

 

[Sig]

C&D Pegusus is a great mostly Burley blend.
C&D Yorktown is a great straight Virginia that is also mindlessly great.
And both are cheaper than CH and always available.
I was recently turned on to D&R Ryback which is also very inexpensive and good.

 

[Piping Abe]

I think you owe it to yourself to try an ounce of Haunted Bookshop again. Also, the recommendations of Pegasus, Brair Fox and Yorktown. C&D blends will always be available, always stay lit easy and are guranteed to go on sale a few times a year 20% off.

 

[OzPiper]

You could get a bag of samplers from The Country Squire.
@SunriseBoy generously sent me samples of Cowboy Coffee, Cherokee and Black Arrow.
All 3 are easy going smokes.
One or two could qualify easily as all-day smokes.

 

[OverMountain]

Wilke or Boswell. Save your time and money and go straight for the best.

 

[towhee89]

I think you owe it to yourself to try an ounce of Haunted Bookshop again. Also, the recommendations of Pegasus, Brair Fox and Yorktown. C&D blends will always be available, always stay lit easy and are guranteed to go on sale a few times a year 20% off.

C and D is my #1 choice at the moment, I will for sure be trying some of them first.

 

[Hutch Piper]

If you like PA and CH then you must try the match blends for both at Milan Tobacconists. They are both excellent blends made with high quality leaf. No chemical taste whatsoever.

 

[Skippy Piper]

I think your intuition is correct and C&D Pegasus is going to be the blend you're looking for.

 

[ashdigger]

Granger. You’re welcome.