Short shank or no shank, but the rustication and patterned stem save it. monk, I don't see it as an author but as a ball, that under-reported shape. I have one made out of Mountain Laurel by the evanescent pipe carver Jerry Perry of Colfax, N.C. But shapes are often in the eye of the beholder. I though my XXL Johs pipe was a brandy for a year, until I came across the invoice and found Mogen Johansen, the carver, called it an apple, so apple it is.