I agree, with Styler though, why so heavily topped?
Styler never said they were heavily topped, he said: seems to be... which implies that this is what he thinks...but not from experience...
As I have learned from members here, most of the pipe smoking world smokes Aromatics... so it shouldn't be a surprise.
The just4him blends are not so heavily topped that you can't taste the tobacco. I've been buying 2 of them in bulk for years... A purist or non-aromatics smoker might not like them, but they are by no means full of low grade, heavily flavored Cavendish... Their descriptions reveal that they don't use much flavorings.
Just4him blends some great stuff... Dennis? Forget his name...
It wasn't too many years ago that this forum was talking about these tobaccos and I got the recommendation to try them.
I keep shortcut and ruins in my wider rotation year round. I find them to be barely flavored at all.
I'm not much of an aromatic smoker.
I think that shortcut and ruins have a nice dark, earthy sweetness.
Gimmicky or not, J4H does a great job with this series and they have been around for quite a while.