I Just had a Pipe-smoking Revelation ...

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Drucquers Banner

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate
Nov 12, 2014
43,446
109,367
  • Like
Reactions: Anchovies

JimPM

Starting to Get Obsessed
Mar 14, 2021
260
1,615
Title edited. Capitals!

I was browsing through this page as it's Saturday morning and just sipping some coffee..


... it's actually a site sponsor and I would highly recommend checking out their site if you have not already, it's the best quality online pipe shop I've seen yet. Huge photos of pipes with all the dimensions etc. clearly marked.

Anyway ... I didn't post to plug them, just when you see something good it's nice to share ... anyway, so I was reading through that article and came to the bit that said the pipe should be packed so that the draw is like sucking liquid through a straw.

Mine has never been that tight, I always packed far more loosely. My usual packing method was basically "sprinkling" the tobacco into the bowl and then just "neatening it up and patting it down", and doing that 2 or 3 times until the bowl is full. When I draw on it unlit, there is mostly no difference to drawing on it when the bowl is empty.

I thought to myself okay, maybe I'm packing too loosely here. I wonder how tight I can pack and still get a good draw while it's unlit? The answer really surprised me. I took the amount of tobacco I usually fit into a full bowl and this time with each packing I actually pushed it down a little harder and kept drawing on the pipe as I was packing to ensure the draw wasn't too tight. Nope - just like sucking water through a straw.

However, what was normally a full bowl of tobacco for me now barely took-up half the bowl. I was sceptical that this was right but thought I'd give it a shot ... it was definitely right.

Not only did I get less bite, but the tobacco burned so much nicer and tasted so much better. I never really got a "hot bowl" in my hand, but now the heat in the briar was barely noticeable against my hand. It wouldn't have been noticeable if it were a warm day. That half-bowl only required a single re-light (not that I care about re-lighting, just saying) and took the same amount of time to smoke as a full bowl of my previously loosely-packed method.

Conclusion: I've been packing my pipes like a sissy!! All the warnings "DO NOT PACK TOO TIGHTLY" ... I took them all a bit too seriously and kind of skipped over the "... or too loosely" bit. I mean, on the third packing I jammed it down pretty good while constantly testing the draw. I was surprised at just how hard I could pack it in there in the end. But maybe that's . because I've been packing them so loosely a "normal" pack felt unusual.
Packing tight tends to make the burn hot. I just kind of set the bowl up like I'm building a campfire. Layered with a combination of looser pieces stage with layers of denser masses. I never jam or pack hard. Just a push each layer until I feel resistance. Seems to work for me.
 

Anchovies

Might Stick Around
Packing tight tends to make the burn hot. I just kind of set the bowl up like I'm building a campfire. Layered with a combination of looser pieces stage with layers of denser masses. I never jam or pack hard. Just a push each layer until I feel resistance. Seems to work for me.
I have found it burns cooler - and considerably so.

Which makes sense - a looser pack = more oxygen = a hotter cherry.

I also acknowledge it's all subjective a personal. Maybe my new "tight pack" is your "loose pack" or maybe our smoking techniques just lend themselves to one or the other ...
 
  • Like
Reactions: dunnyboy

briarcudgel

Starting to Get Obsessed
May 6, 2016
108
108
Packing tight tends to make the burn hot. I just kind of set the bowl up like I'm building a campfire. Layered with a combination of looser pieces stage with layers of denser masses. I never jam or pack hard. Just a push each layer until I feel resistance. Seems to work for me.
I‘ve found this method works best for me. I do it unconsciously now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dunnyboy