Gawith Hoggarth Extra S Brown Pigtail Twist

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
This twist, being thin, curls like a pig’s tail - hence the name. The uncut rope has a bitter, woody pungency characteristic of dark fired Virginias. When cut into thin coins and rubbed out, the strong, peaty aroma intensifies and deepens, and you can get a brief and mild nicotine hit simply by sniffing it. There's also a detectable odour of maple syrup casing there.

It is very moist and so requires a deal of air drying time. After 5 hours' drying it still needed many relights and left a damp dottle. Leaving it out to dry overnight - bearing in mind that I am writing during a week of very moist weather in England in mid February - seemed to work best, but even then it needed loose packing. For those who don't like or want to spare the time for the ritual preparation of cutting, it is also available in ready-cut slices that just need a rub and a dry.

Thus dried, at first light, the smoke is voluminous and blue, and envelopes you a cloud of cigar-like vapour and the first inhalations are mouth-filling with lots of body. The taste is what I would describe as hot, in a spicy sense, which some might find harsh. It could almost be called peppery - the dark fired Virginia effect. Don't be tempted to puff too hard to keep it going, as it will bite. Slow and steady gets the best out of what few nuances it has. It mellows a bit after the first quarter bowl, and becomes less two-dimensional by the second half. Some sweet grass hints there, but mostly old barn hay notes start to be detected, and there's plenty of bold flavour. I found the nicotine hit strong but - despite what the GH blurb says - not as strong as the Black Irish XX Twist, nor as complex or pleasurable.

I first tried in in a Zulu, which was a mistake, as the conical chamber and bent stem encourages the collection of moisture and a gurgling, un-re-lightable dottle by the time you're nearly done. The second time I tried it in a long 19th Meerschaum, and it certainly suits a long-stemmed pipe with a near-cylindrical bowl far better than a short-stemmed pipe with a Dublin bowl. A longer airway gives a cooler smoke whereas in the previous trial it was borderline harsh. This second smoke was a glorious hour of euphoria.

For the third smoke I used a briar ‘cutty’ with a 5.5 inch stem and shank - and still wished it had been an inch or three longer. Again it was mellow and cigar-like, but relatively unvaried in flavours. Some salted caramel was evident during second half of bowl, which I suppose is the maple sugar casing, and quite pleasant. A retrohale clears the sinuses. Slow-burning, long-lasting. You might want to remind yourself that it is not compulsory to smoke an entire bowl at one sitting.

A manly smoke, for the company of other men. It occurred to me that, if the older GH blends in their present composition really do go back two centuries or more, the addition of rose geranium or tonquin in those Lakeland blends and 1792 might originally have been mainly to make the room note less unpalatable to ladies, whereas the GH twists are unapologetically robust in their aroma. By the late 18th and early 19th centuries, pipe smoking had declined among the upper classes for chiefly this reason, snuff being the preferred method of tobacco consumption and, to a lesser extent, cigars (which may also explain the cigar-like quality of this blend).

As a fairly seasoned smoker and of the addictive type, after half an hour’s smoking I began to have spelling difficulties whilst writing down my impressions in my notebook.If this weed were beer, in would be what the Scots call ‘a ninety shilling ale’: not something you would want to consume all the time but as a relaxing, heady reward after a morning’s or an afternoon’s heavy, physical work, or a few puffs snatched in the course of a brief rest.

Imagining myself back in the 19thC, I can’t see gentlemen or clerks smoking it, but mariners, soldiers and labouring men. After all, you want a smoke that will last you a fair while until the next opportunity. How they ever smoked it in a broken-off short clay ‘cutty’ I don’t know, but I suppose one can get used to anything, and of course a smoke of any kind is better than no smoke at all. I can also understand how it could lend itself to a quick, five-minute smoke in a small pipe, or if in a large pipe, simply pocketed when it went out and relit at some later opportunity for another quick hit.

I commend it to all of you who have a sense of history - and do try it in a long pipe - a churchwarden or something similar. It's unsubtle, compared with less ancient blends, which an original habitue of Brown Pigtail might well have considered effete; but if you like a good, strong, hearty smioke, the Brown Pigtail is your man.
 

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
Useful. I might get some and use the Chacom Cuba, which is almost churchwarden long. Is this the stuff Magwitch really smoked?
The tobacco Magwitch smoked, identified by Pip as "negro-head," was a dark kind of tobacco used, according to the Dictionary of Daily Wants (1858-9), almost exclusively for smoking (as opposed to snuff-taking, chewing, etc.) and was often "manufactured in the form of a thickish rope". So I reckon it would have been GH Black Irish XX.
 

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
I have lbs of the stuff and consume it very regularly. Strangely if you use your knife properly you should be able to slice the stuff to 1/32 ' and then rub it out and it will take a fire quite easily. The high moister content was designed to allow you to cart the stuff around in your jacket pocket.
Thanks for the tip. I'll try making a shag, instead of a ribbon, cut.
 

Skippy Piper

Part of the Furniture Now
Jun 19, 2023
828
10,336
St. Paul, MN
That was a very enjoyable review to read! I haven't tried the Pigtail twist yet, but I do smoke Brown Bogie with some regularity since even though the base tobaccos are the same it doesn't seem to have quite as much pungency (or foulness, if you ask me) as the larger Irish X sized ropes and the wrapper leaf seems to stay attached better and not fall off or come loose as easily.

All the twists do have a really neat historical flair though, and every time I smoke them it always conjures up mental images of 16th or 17th century life; when most tobacco was sold in ropes and almost everyone smoked a pipe, or just chewed the rope tobacco when smoking was inconvenient. It might be silly but I can't help but imagine being back in the 16th century parked in a smokey old tavern with a pint of cider or on the deck of a ship sailing the high seas every time I smoke a twist!

There are definitely better tasting, less musty, and less cigar-like dark fired Virginia blends out there (in my opinion, at least) but none of them create quite the same emotional response and historic mental imagery for me as a brown twist. puffy
 

andrew

Lifer
Feb 13, 2013
3,150
663
Winnipeg, Canada
There are one or two folks here who chew the stuff first, then dry it out and smoke it afterwards. Personally I am not inclined to try, so my review must necessarily be less than comprehensive :)
That comes from the tradition of miners and sailors. Miners would chew during the day as you couldn't smoke in the mines, then dry it out and smoke in the pipe in the evenings. Sailors as when you're on deck I don't think smoking a pipe would be practical, then drying and smoking in the evening
 

Sobrbiker

Lifer
Jan 7, 2023
4,755
64,094
Casa Grande, AZ
Thanks for the tip. I'll try making a shag, instead of a ribbon, cut.
Good take on the twist, I’ve not had the pigtail (I haven’t seen it grace our shores, but I’ve not seen everything either).
I’ve tried quite a few ways, and have landed on slicing longways in half, then as thin as an old Sicilian guy slicing translucent slices of garlic. Rubbed to a shag, then dried almost to smoking dryness, then into a jar.
The pre-sliced is nice and easy too.

I’ve found the browns to be heavier in nic than the blacks.

I wish I could afford to have big-ass coils laying about…
 

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
That comes from the tradition of miners and sailors. Miners would chew during the day as you couldn't smoke in the mines, then dry it out and smoke in the pipe in the evenings. Sailors as when you're on deck I don't think smoking a pipe would be practical, then drying and smoking in the evening
Truth. And when ships were composed entirely of combistible materials (canvas, rope, tar, wood and as often as not, gunpowder, smoking was frequently allowed only in the galley. I had a great-uncle or two who were miners before the War, and I wish I'd asked more questions about their working lives back then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Puff nstuff

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
Good take on the twist, I’ve not had the pigtail (I haven’t seen it grace our shores, but I’ve not seen everything either).
I’ve tried quite a few ways, and have landed on slicing longways in half, then as thin as an old Sicilian guy slicing translucent slices of garlic. Rubbed to a shag, then dried almost to smoking dryness, then into a jar.
The pre-sliced is nice and easy too.

I’ve found the browns to be heavier in nic than the blacks.

I wish I could afford to have big-ass coils laying about…
Longitudinal slicing - that never occurred to me (though I do slice garlic that way and I did learn it from an old Italian guy). I'll try it for my next smoke. And I think you're right about the black ropes being less nicotine-heavy. And I also wish that I, too, could afford to have big-ass coils laying about :)
 

MisterBadger

Lifer
Oct 6, 2024
1,050
8,926
Ludlow, UK
That was a very enjoyable review to read! I haven't tried the Pigtail twist yet, but I do smoke Brown Bogie with some regularity since even though the base tobaccos are the same it doesn't seem to have quite as much pungency (or foulness, if you ask me) as the larger Irish X sized ropes and the wrapper leaf seems to stay attached better and not fall off or come loose as easily.

All the twists do have a really neat historical flair though, and every time I smoke them it always conjures up mental images of 16th or 17th century life; when most tobacco was sold in ropes and almost everyone smoked a pipe, or just chewed the rope tobacco when smoking was inconvenient. It might be silly but I can't help but imagine being back in the 16th century parked in a smokey old tavern with a pint of cider or on the deck of a ship sailing the high seas every time I smoke a twist!

There are definitely better tasting, less musty, and less cigar-like dark fired Virginia blends out there (in my opinion, at least) but none of them create quite the same emotional response and historic mental imagery for me as a brown twist. puffy
Strange. I have found the bigger ropes behave better than the smaller ones, in terms of the wrapper leaf not unwinding. Perhaps it's a batch thing. And I'm with you entirely on the history-mystery dreaming. And about there being tastier dark fired Virginias out there, too. But they don't lend themselves half as much to time travel, do they?
 

woodsroad

Lifer
Oct 10, 2013
13,600
24,782
SE PA USA
And I also wish that I, too, could afford to have big-ass coils laying about :)

Get a second and third job. Sell your blood, or a kidney. Pimp out your sister. Rob a bank. Roll a bum. So many easy ways to bring home the bacon.

Personally, I prefer to abandon my responsibilities to my family and spend my entire paycheck on obscure tobacco blends. Children are forever, an Esoterica drop is very temporary.
 
Last edited:

Brad H

Part of the Furniture Now
Dec 17, 2024
797
5,987
Get a second and third job. Sell your blood, or a kidney. Pimp out your sister. Rob a bank. Roll a bum. So many easy ways to bring home the bacon.

Personally, I prefer to abandon my responsibilities to my family and spend my entire paycheck on obscure tobacco blends. Children are forever, an Esoterica drop is very temporary.
have you been spying on me?