I've got all three, but haven't smoked Officers Club yet. I really favor the Royal Challenge, but then I seldom smoke it by itself. I usually use it to mix with GH Rum Flake, C&D Black Frigate, Blockade Runner and GLP Sextant, which I normally smoke straight, but when I want a milder sweeter smoke I add a little of the Royal Challenge. Overall I think these are nice aromatic blends that are not over the top with artificial flavors and I like them. For the aro fan, these are probably a nice easy smoke with fairly interesting flavors that are not too strong.