Country Squire's Tombigbee vs. Russ Oullette's Snickerdoodle

[sittingbear]

Has anyone compared these two aros, both of which claim to replicate a snickerdoodle cookie? I've been smoking Tombigbee (formerly Old Toby) and love it. Is Russ's version similar?

 

[krizzose]

I’ve had both, and I don’t think they are that similar. Snickerdoodle has a much more overt flavoring on it. Old Toby, to my palate, just has a lot of added sugar

 

[sittingbear]

I’ve had both, and I don’t think they are that similar. Snickerdoodle has a much more overt flavoring on it. Old Toby, to my palate, just has a lot of added sugar

Which do you prefer?

 

[krizzose]

I dont

Which do you prefer?

I don’t have a preference, but Snickerdoodle tastes a lot more like a snickerdoodle cookie.