Unfortunately buying cigars in NY from B&Ms is very expensive due to taxes. New York ain't exactly tobacco friendly.
Another comment or two about Barclay Rex. Back in the late sixties/early seventies when I was a newbie pipe and cigar smoker Barclay Rex was located in an old and cool looking shop on Maiden Lane, in the financial district. They sold some commercial pipe brands as I recall, but their real claim to fame was the freehand pipe, some of which were allegedly made by Nastri family members who were owners of the store. The freehands were mostly if not totally "natural " briars, i.e. with a wax finish only. The selling point was that natural briar smoked better than pipes that were stained. It was a pitch shared by Connoisseur, Wilke and some other lesser known shops throughout the city. Many of these freehands were large and styled as variations of classic French/English shapes. The best, in my view, were made by Joe Cortegiano an enormously talented local pipemaker who made many pipes for Barclay Rex, Wilke and in his later years, while essentially retired, for Connoisseur.
For the budget minded, factory made natural briar pipes came from metro area factories like Weber, Arlington and Andre Mermet. Several shops in the city had relationships with these factories. Kaywoodie may have been involved too as they were a big operation in those days, I just don't know. As was the case with many shops in New York, at least some their popular house tobacco blends were made by large manufacturers. Some of Barclay Rex's best selling English style blends were made by the House of Windsor in Pennsylvania. Remember those guys?