An Illustrated Guide to Buying a Good $20 Pipe

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

Watch for Updates Twice a Week

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
6,368
21,951
Humansville Missouri
Over in the Middle East there are men born to be oil sheiks. They can own gilded billion dollar motor yachts and half billion dollar 747s and ten million dollar cars with young nubile “Instagram Models” draped all over their palaces, yachts. jets, and cars, and hunt with falcons. They can buy anything in this sin cussed world of woe they can imagine.

But you can smoke a pipe fit for an oil sheik for $20.

In my experience the best of the very best briar came from Algeria harvested by Berbers and selected by Frenchmen before the November 1, 1954 revolution where perhaps a million natives died in an incredibly cruel civil war that lasted eight years and ended in utter French defeat. When it was available the best makers used nothing else on their best grades.

Why French made pipes are the Rodney Dangerfield of pipe collecting I have no idea. Perhaps because French women are mysterious and desirable and exotic but a hairy legged French guy smoking a pipe in a beret is not a staple Hollywood leading man character. In any event if a pipe is made in France it usually sells for less than one made in Britain, Ireland, Denmark, Germany, Italy or America.

Varnished pipes are cheapies. But 4/0 steel wool removes varnish and once gone you can’t tell it was ever varnished.

So, if you wait awhile on eBay you’ll find a like new, barely smoked, varnished, French made pipe that is stamped Algerian Briar.

This one cost $12 and $8 tax and shipping.

IMG_0695.jpegIMG_0696.jpegIMG_0698.jpegIMG_0697.jpegIMG_0699.jpegIMG_0703.jpeg


When it came before I did anything else I stripped the varnish with 4/0 steel wool and cleaned it up with grain alcohol and applied mineral oil.

IMG_0692.jpegIMG_0693.jpegIMG_0694.jpeg

Then you must break in your oil sheik grade $20 pipe. Take one tiny dab of honey and coat the bowl, and I used Granger tobacco.

Smoke it slowly, all the way down. Then take steel wool and alcohol and strip it all down again and apply mineral oil.

And yes it tastes even better than it looks. It will look better and taste better for a lifetime if properly rested and rotated and oiled and cleaned.

There are decent substitutes for ancient Pre 54 oil cured, aged, unvarnished, unstained, and unpainted Algerian briar only because the French lost the war.

This is the best briar that ever was or ever will be, period. This pipe will color to a deep reddish brown oxblood shade all over it, as the oil or sap or precious flavor mojos—-something mysterious and magical and wonderful—seep out.

It will never get hot to hold after break in.

It will taste better than I can describe.

Try only one, and you are hopelessly hooked.


IMG_0705.jpegIMG_0706.jpeg
IMG_0707.jpegIMG_0708.jpegIMG_0709.jpeg


Living the good life isn’t expensive.

You just need to learn how.;)

Sing one Lefty!

Down by the Railroad Track

 
Last edited:

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
6,368
21,951
Humansville Missouri
What a beautiful guide and a beautiful pipe. I love the orientation of the grain and the chip in the stem.

Thank you.


I just bought another Royal Ascot Deluxe medium Apple for $10 and $9 mailing and taxes.

When buying these, look at the stems.

The outside and inside clean up but if the stems are chewed up, there’s not much to be easily done about that, and like an Arab sheik’s golden yacht, it is possible (although unlikely) to use up all the goodie from the best of the best of anything.

Varnish is bad. It’s easily stripped, but these were varnished to lower production costs.

IMG_0724.jpegIMG_0723.jpegIMG_0722.jpegIMG_0721.jpegIMG_0720.jpegIMG_0719.jpegIMG_0718.jpegIMG_0717.jpeg


The one I just bought maybe was smoked a dozen or two times and the varnish trapped whatever seeps out of real Algerian briar, and it looks like it’s a dog turd pulled from the mud. The stem still looks new. It can be vastly improved.

Four smokes after stripping.

IMG_0725.jpegIMG_0726.jpeg


The shank has a “shake” that will eventually fill all the way up with the reddish black whatever it is that weeps from the best briar ever found on the planet. Everything else is a substitute.

These “flaws” are why Dunhill got out his sandblaster.:)

IMG_0727.jpeg

You can buy a $20 pipe and live like an oil prince, right here in America!

Sing one, Whispering Bill Anderson

Po Folks


The French evacuated quite a bit of this briar over to their homeland before their day of reckoning came in 1962.

I wonder if somewhere forgotten in a warehouse there’s any more left?

IMG_0728.jpeg
 
Last edited:

tubbyninja1337

Can't Leave
Nov 21, 2024
475
9,336
Southern California
Thank you so much for the write up. Are there any other brands in particular we should be on the lookout for? In addition to Royal Ascot of course.

I've recently been picking up a few inexpensive French pipes and have thoroughly enjoyed cleaning them out and smoking them.
 

Pypkė

Part of the Furniture Now
Aug 3, 2024
676
1,864
East of Cleveland, Ohio. USA
I "discovered" cheap French pipes with the Algerian Briar last Fall. They are inexpensive, or at least they were until the lurkers descend on eBay like <insert whatever euphemism you want.> I'm still slowly reconditioning a few that came with heavily oxidized stems that are nasty to smoke, but those that were OK are a pleasure to smoke from.
 

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
6,368
21,951
Humansville Missouri
Thank you so much for the write up. Are there any other brands in particular we should be on the lookout for? In addition to Royal Ascot of course.

I've recently been picking up a few inexpensive French pipes and have thoroughly enjoyed cleaning them out and smoking them.

The joy of accumulating these rare survivors is there is zero collector interest.


Algerian briar was like Sally Was a Good Old Girl, except one day she got tired of being taken for granted.:)


Except for the King of Belgium’s Belgian Congo, the French atrocities and barbaric treatment of the Algerian natives is without any comparison or even imagination to modern sensibilities.

Until the Berbers grew tired of being starved, shot, raped, tortured, and worked to death by the hundreds of thousands the French exploited the natives to capture 80% of the world’s share of Mediterranean briar exports.

Then suddenly and without any warning one day the briar diggers started killing the French briar buyers. I doubt much was dug after November 1, 1954.

Other brands that used Algerian (even if they weren’t proud enough to stamp it as Algerian) were Marxman, Bertram, Rogers, Edward’s and there are lots of generic pipes that were Algerian briar, although not stamped as such.
 

tubbyninja1337

Can't Leave
Nov 21, 2024
475
9,336
Southern California
Thank you for the thoughtful response! Unfortunately I don't know much about the French atrocities against the Algerians but I do know of the Rubber Terror of Leopold the second. Very sad and dark times for the people of Congo.

On a side note, I had heard of and listened to Eddie Cochran and had to look up if there was any relation to Hank Cochran. There is no blood relation but I did learn the two formed a duo called the Cochran Brothers that lasted about a year. So thank you for that as well.

I will keep a look out for the brands you mentioned and will pay special attention to ones stamped Algerian briar.

Thanks!
 

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
6,368
21,951
Humansville Missouri
When you read Alfred Dunhill and Carl Weber and Bertram the Elder’s accounts of Algerian briar they stressed it was soft, it had to be oil cured (to be good) and it required aging.

Unsaid, unwritten, and not ever mentioned was the incredibly miserable, starving, and oppressed Berbers who dug it out and the French graders who bought it, developed a market system that is never again going to exist.

Even today, if you buy a bottle of Scotch that reads Straight Scotch Made in Scotland or a bottle of Champagne or Burgundythat reads Made in France or Straight Bourbon Bottled in Bond it’s really good, or it couldn’t wear those labels.

Every ship that loaded briar at El Kafa before June 1962 and cleared Franch customs was laden with the good briar.

It wasn’t all the same grade, but it was all the best quality,
 

cosmicfolklore

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 9, 2013
36,350
88,235
Between the Heart of Alabama and Hot Springs NC
Even today, if you buy a bottle of Scotch that reads Straight Scotch Made in Scotland or a bottle of Champagne or Burgundythat reads Made in France or Straight Bourbon Bottled in Bond it’s really good, or it couldn’t wear those labels
I don't believe that you really believe that. What those labels mean is that they followed some rules. But, there are many sour bottles of Burgundy that followed the rules but went sour. Or Scotch that just didn't pan out, or Bottled in Bond that just sucks. Those labels mean that they followed rules, and does not indicate quality in any way.

And, all of this in no way has any impact on whether a ship full of briar was really any good or not.
 

Sig

Lifer
Jul 18, 2023
1,229
6,465
54
Western NY
I have shown my Match Grain Yorkshire pipes here enough. I'm sure I have others, but I'm too lazy to inspect them all.
These Yorkshires were bought by my friends dad in or around 1957. He was born in 1939 and bought these pipes brand new in college. The stems were quite marked by teeth, but they were unsmoked. :)
The pipes were props for when old Chuck would drive around in his convertible MG Midget. He never once bought any tobacco.
About 10 years ago my friend found them and his dad insisted I have them. They came in a cheap plastic case that looked more like a fishing lure box, or your mom's Tupperware.
One Apple and one Billiard. Both pipes are great smokers.
1000004887.jpg
1000004722.jpg1000004721.jpg
 

NookersTheCat

Part of the Furniture Now
Sep 10, 2020
565
2,557
NEPA
I was about to secure my first Lee, a 3 star limited, the other week on ebay but got distracted and lost out :(
The search continues...
 

craig61a

Lifer
Apr 29, 2017
6,471
56,356
Minnesota USA
I don't believe that you really believe that. What those labels mean is that they followed some rules. But, there are many sour bottles of Burgundy that followed the rules but went sour. Or Scotch that just didn't pan out, or Bottled in Bond that just sucks. Those labels mean that they followed rules, and does not indicate quality in any way.

And, all of this in no way has any impact on whether a ship full of briar was really any good or not.
He was just taking the liberty of bullshitting ya…

15CA7F23-2FBD-4A39-9329-3043EA99C151.png
 
  • Haha
Reactions: cosmicfolklore

Briar Lee

Lifer
Sep 4, 2021
6,368
21,951
Humansville Missouri
I don't believe that you really believe that. What those labels mean is that they followed some rules. But, there are many sour bottles of Burgundy that followed the rules but went sour. Or Scotch that just didn't pan out, or Bottled in Bond that just sucks. Those labels mean that they followed rules, and does not indicate quality in any way.

And, all of this in no way has any impact on whether a ship full of briar was really any good or not.

I cannot develop a taste for Scotch or any kind of wine. But those that do, tell me that the way to know if the hooch is good is to read the label.

As for bourbon, there are no poisonous brands for sale, but if the bottle reads bottled in bond that will be good booze.

——

For collectors and connoisseurs, Bottled in Bond whiskey isn’t just a classification—it’s a guarantee of authenticity. Introduced in 1897, the Bottled in Bond Act was the government’s way of ensuring whiskey was made properly, under strict regulations that distillers still follow today.

A Bottled in Bond whiskey must:

  • Be distilled at one distillery, in one distilling season
  • Be aged at least four years in a federally bonded warehouse
  • Be bottled at exactly 100 proof (50% ABV)
  • Be produced under U.S. government supervision
For collectors, the appeal goes beyond regulations. These whiskeys are pure expressions of a distillery’s craft, untouched by blending or dilution. They capture a moment in time, with many of the greatest American whiskeys ever produced bearing the Bottled in Bond label.


——

85 years ago the world used at least one hundred times more Mediterranean briar than today and those Frenchmen who had the sole right to ship Algerian briar from the French province of Algeria did not allow bad briar on the ship.

They did peddle the highest and lowest grades both, of course.

Neither of these pipes are stamped Algerian briar but both are.

You can tell by smoking them.

The cheap one may have sold for a quarter or fifty cents and the 400 cost $25.

These are both outrageously good, dynamite smokers that color to oxblood the more they are used,

And the cheap pipe has had three smokes and the 400 no more than a dozen, and I keep them immaculately clean and cake free and oiled and waxed.

IMG_0813.jpegIMG_0814.jpeg
IMG_0815.jpegIMG_0816.jpeg

You can bet your bottom dollar that an old factory pipe that reads Algerian briar will smoke like Algerian briar smoked. You might find you don’t like the taste of Algerian briar.

Not everybody likes Scotch or Burgundy.:)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Bbailey324

newbroom

Lifer
Jul 11, 2014
6,460
11,274
North Central Florida
I have one of those stout French apples marked Algerian Briar by Rogers. I think it came as a bonus to a pipe rack I won on the bay. I've got some good old beaters this way and some display storage.WIN_20250517_08_03_09_Pro.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jacob74

Choatecav

Lifer
Dec 19, 2023
1,060
4,818
Middle Tennessee
Thank you for the thoughtful response! Unfortunately I don't know much about the French atrocities against the Algerians but I do know of the Rubber Terror of Leopold the second. Very sad and dark times for the people of Congo.

On a side note, I had heard of and listened to Eddie Cochran and had to look up if there was any relation to Hank Cochran. There is no blood relation but I did learn the two formed a duo called the Cochran Brothers that lasted about a year. So thank you for that as well.

I will keep a look out for the brands you mentioned and will pay special attention to ones stamped Algerian briar.

Thanks!
I have listened to both Eddie and Hank Cochran and did not think they were related, but I surely did not know that they performed together for a year. thanks for the info.