I am a Frog lover, and would say "ditto" to the other responses. The only caveat might be the Bayou option. It would depend if the perique would influence the first impression too much or not.
I would say that FM would be the mildest, but I prefer the taste of FMC. Either way, you have a winner in my book. ::
Most definitely Cellar! That being said, all of them are wonderful! Of course all of them have Latakia, but On The Bayou also has Perique. I normally don't care for Perique, but OTB is one of the few blends containing the Louisiana leaf, that I really do enjoy!
I would have to agree with papipeguy. I have smoked them all and Frog Morton on the Town is my favorite, lots of stuff going on with this one. I am not a fan of FMC, I just don't like the bourbon taste. Which ever you choose, I don't think you can go wrong. All of them are top notch.