A Whole Lot of Shaking Going On
-
Kevin Godbee - Mar 19, 2014
- 6 min read
Fred Brown
Two of East Tennessee’s most iconic retail tobacconists, Smoky’s Cigar in Knoxville, TN., and The Gatlin-Burlier Tobacconist in Gatlinburg, TN., gateway to the Great Smoky Mountains National Park, have been in business for more than 30 years each. Combined, the two shops have more than a half century of history and experience from which to draw.
Dave Watson, owner of Smoky’s, and Ira Lapides, owner-founder of The Gatlin-Burlier in the resort town of Gatlinburg, bring an astounding amount of business acumen to the table when it comes to pipes, tobacco and what the future holds for those who enjoy the fruits of their labor.
Watson started his career with the media entertainment giant, Anderson Media Corp., which was born in a wood shed in Florence, Ala., and grew into a multi-billion-dollar magazines and newspaper distributor. Today, based in Knoxville, the company is the leading entertainment media distributor to North American Wal-Mart and Sam’s Club locations. The company is also a product distributor to Army and Air Force exchange stores at bases around the world.
Watson, 60, worked his way up, literally, from sweeping floors, delivering magazines and books to retail stores, and, finally, to becoming a regional vice president. He spent 33 years with Anderson before retiring in 2006 to set off on his own and taking over Smoky’s, one of Knoxville’s oldest tobacconists, which had fallen on hard times.
Smoky’s was opened by its former owners around 1983 and operated until about 2007, when Watson purchased the store and inventory Jan. 1, 2007.
“I took two weeks off in retirement and then began working to re-open Smoky’s,” Watson says with a chuckle.
Dave Watson, Owner of Smoky’s Cigar
He didn’t look back. Beginning with no employees and $70 in sales the first day he opened, he has brought the operation a long way, moving from a 1,200 square foot shotgun-size retail outlet in a strip mall to a 3,400 square foot modern retail store that includes a 280-feet-plus walk-in cigar humidor and a 900 square foot “Squire’s Club,” for members only. A $250 membership gets you a locker (there has been a locker waiting list since the club opened). He is now thinking of expanding the humidor.
Lapides, a PhD economist from the University of Tennessee, brings an entirely different perspective to the table.
In 1977, after completing his doctorate and doing some teaching, consulting, and other work, Lapides began to itch for his own business. The opportunity popped up while in Gatlinburg with his wife on a relaxing weekend. He ran out of pipe tobacco and tried to find a good blend.
“I couldn’t find pipe tobacco in the entire town,” Lapides said. “I went back to the chalet where we were staying and told my wife that we were going into the tobacco business. I decided right then and there.”
That was 1977. Lapides said he emptied “out my savings account, got a SBA (Small Business Administration) Loan and went into business.”
His wife joked that the only thing Lapides knew about pipes and tobacco at the time was that he smoked a pipe.
“But, I had the capacity to learn,” Lapides said.
Indeed.
Lapides opened the Gatlin-Burlier in the top floor of Mountain Mall, one of Gatlinburg’s main shopping outlets on the main street. It has been there since.
Smoky’s Pipe Board
He began with a very small inventory. Cigars had not yet hit the boom years. He built a small cigar humidor, which was too large then, but now much too small to keep up with business, he says.
The Gatlin-Burlier has always been “a pipe store featuring more pipes than cigars.” It also features Lapides’ excellent blends. Cigars amount to maybe 20 percent of the business today and pipes and tobacco the rest.
The Gatlin-Burlier has 20 blends that Lapides created.
“What I’ve done is stuck with a few dozen or so blends that pretty much covers the smoking universe,” he says.
He must be doing something right in the tobacco kitchen because the Gatlin-Burlier sells about 1,000 pounds of pipe tobacco a month.
Watson, on the other hand, has been a cigar smoker since he was a teenager. Cigar sales at Smoky’s represent about 60 percent of his business, but Smoky’s has 70 bulk pipe tobaccos. Watson said he sells about 100 pounds of his premier “Smoky’s” house blend per month.
In addition, Watson has put together roughly eight more blends from his own and former Smoky’s recipe book.
But both Watson and Lapides see a dire future for tobacco in general.
Watson says his biggest fear at the moment rests with the Food and Drug Administration, which has federal control over the nation’s tobacco products.
He thinks the FDA will eventually step up its harsh regulations on B&M shops by restricting, say, a cigar buyer from entering the humidor to make his or her own choices.
“I can see the FDA restricting you from going into our humidor. There are plans to stop the decorative cigar box and they will limit cigars that actually get to market,” Watson says.
“Government and taxation will greatly impede (tobacco) retailers.”
Because pipe smoking is a small “niche” market, Watson describes it currently as a “flat line.” Older smokers, he says, smoke pipes. As for pipes, he says, most are not looking for the high-end pipes. Smoky’s does carry some medium-priced pipes, but Watson says he caters to “that guy who wants a Chevy or a Ford” rather than a Lamborghini.
Lapides says the recent tax increases on cigars, which has spread across the board to the individual cigar rather than on weight, “played havoc with the small cigar businesses in Tennessee,” he says.
“Tennessee’s gross domestic product is one of the lowest in the nation and its OPT (an annual privilege tax on occupations) on tobacco is one of the lowest state taxes out there.”
Because of this and other taxes, Lapides said “a lot of stuff fell out of the market. Several imports decided not to come into the country.”
At one point in the shop’s history, Lapides could ship chewing tobacco to customers. That is illegal now, he says.
But one of the crushing blows to Lapides is that he now sees the new FDA regulations as preventing him from the ability to sell his business in order for him to retire.
Squire’s Club
“The major thing done to my business is that it (FDA regs) have decreased its worth for retirement purposes.”
A 35-year-old firm, he says, “should provide a good retirement income in the open market."
“But the tobacco business has lost value.”
Although he says he hasn’t tried to sell the business yet, he believes the real opportunity to sell out may have passed.
“The FDA continues to come up with (new) regulations, which has ruined my retirement plans.”
"No", he says, back in 1978 when he began The Gatlin-Burlier, he never thought this day would come.
Lapides said he would have had to be “clairvoyant to know that the business environment (for tobacconists) would get as rough as it has.”
For that reason, he does not see a bright future for mom and pop tobacco operations.
Watson puts the situation in a more straight-forward way:
“You got your product on one hand, the federal regulations on the other, and the amount of markup you need to stay in business.” He shrugs.
It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to see that, with the big elephant in the room, there could be a whole lot of shaking going on in the future.
|
|
Written by Kevin Godbee
7 Responses
Smokingpipes.com Updates
18 Fresh Dunhill Pipes |
24 Fresh Chacom Pipes |
12 Fresh Estate Pipes |
12 Fresh Mark Tinsky Pipes |
24 Fresh AKB Meerschaum Pipes |
Recent Posts
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 481! This week’s show is a unique holiday themed show with Brian’s Zoom Pipe Club looking at pipes and tobacco in a Charles Dickens’ ‘A Christmas Carol’ sort of way. The guys will talk about pipes and tobaccos of the past, present, and future. Joining the discussion with Brian will be Fred Hanna, Tad Gage, Barry Goldstein, Ronni B, Rich Esserman, Fred Janusek, Brad Pohlmann, Dave in LAX, Rob Cappuccio, Dino Argyropoulos, and several others. At the top of the show in Pipe Parts, Brian found some old tobacco ads, which you can find at this link – Almay.com. Sit back, relax with your pipe, and enjoy The Pipes Magazine Radio Show!
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 480! Tonight we have Rich Esserman back with us for an epic show. Rich is quite well known in the hobby. He has been smoking, collecting, and writing about pipes for over 40-years, and he is best known for collecting large-size Dunhill pipes. We will have Brian and Rich discussing the different types of pipe collectors. Find out which one you are … or are you just a “pipe accumulator”? This episode will go right into the conversation, and bypass the usual Pipe Parts segment. Sit back, relax with your pipe, and enjoy The Pipes Magazine Radio Show!
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 479! Our featured interview tonight is with pipe maker Brian G. Rowley of Growley Pipes. Brian is also a leather crafter and produces handmade merchandise in that area as well. He makes all types of pipe shapes, including some of the classics, but leans more towards the Danish freehand styles. He takes commissions on pipes as well. At the top of the show, We’ll have our “Ask the Pipemaker” segment with artisan pipe maker, Jeff Gracik. Sit back, relax with your pipe, and enjoy The Pipes Magazine Radio Show!
A faded Synoptic Weather Chart for the morning of Saturday, July 1, 1916 read “Light to moderate breezes between East and North, fair to dull. Some showers and mist.” A low-pressure system passing over the English Channel and onto the continent pushed a break in the rain on that first day of July. Bright yellow rays punched down into No Man’s Land and alighted on what poet Siegfried Sassoon described, as a “sunlit picture of hell.” That morning, as the winds changed direction, in the hour when the last mist still clung to the meadow, the whistles blew 8 divisions of British troops into the valley of the shadow of death. Overconfidence in the previous day’s bombardment led officers to conclude that enemy resistance would be minimal and that the allied troops would need their shovels and full 50-pound packs to reinforce captured German positions. General Sir Henry Rawlinson had given the command that the infantry should advance toward the enemy at a walking pace, in evenly spaced lines, some evidence suggests that this command was ignored. German soldiers would later report that the offensive looked more like a mass suicide than an assault, writing that they didn’t even have to aim, “We just fired into them, and they kept falling.” That first day marked the bloodiest battle in British history with 57,470 casualties and 19,240 deaths. Military historian John Keegan would later write, “[For the British] the battle was the greatest tragedy. . .of their national military history,” and, “marked the end of an age of vital optimism in British life that has never been recovered.” In 1914, Major-General Ernest D. Swinton was a journalist covering the front lines of the “War to End all Wars.” Exposed to a wide-ranging view of the newly deployed tactic of trench warfare; he happened upon an idea. He began to sketch out a design for an armored vehicle, mounted on tracks like the one he had seen on a Holt Tractor from the United States. Early adoption of the idea was slow with Lord Kitchener canceling one of his first meetings on the pretense that he was, “Too busy.” The introduction of slow-moving armor was a hard sell to the Gentleman Officers who placed supreme faith in the swift, mounted charge of British Cavalry. The project languished unfunded for over a month before Sir Winston Churchill in control of the Admiralty, made the unusual move of allocating money out of a Naval fund, for what he would call his, “Landships.” Swinton would later write, “Thus, at a time when the machine gun destroyer scheme had for six weeks been lying moribund at the War Office, abandoned as an impossibility, here was born on the other side of Whitehall a special organization, well supplied with the sinews of war for its support….In May [Churchill] severed his connexion with the Admiralty, though retaining an active interest in the landship project.” Tanks would eventually be deployed during the Battle of the Somme; but not until mid-September after the rains had intensified. If one were to calculate the delays in the project, the problems of cancelled meetings and intransigent officers; the tally would amount to at least 3 months. Had the idea not faced such an uphill battle; the armored “Landships” might have been available that fateful morning when the whistles blew. A German report of the psychological impact of the tank once deployed against their troops reads as follows: “The monster approached slowly, hobbling, moving from side to side, rocking and pitching, but it came nearer. Nothing obstructed it: a supernatural force seemed to drive it onwards. Someone in the trenches cried, “The Devil comes!” And that word ran down the line like lightning. Suddenly tongues of fire licked out of the armoured shine of the iron caterpillar…the English waves of infantry surged up behind the Devil’s chariot.” It’s hard not to wonder what a difference that factor could have made on the first day of July back in 1916 This Thursday, on the 11th day of the 11th month of the year, we celebrate Veterans Day, formerly Armistice Day, to commemorate the end of hostilities in the Great War. In the 1950s the Congress of the United States changed the name to Veterans Day to continue the extension of gratitude to Veterans of later wars; but they saved the connection to the Armistice of the Great War as a lingering message of remembrance. The lessons learned in that war were short lived; and it was little time before the sons of those fallen on Flanders Field would find themselves a long way from Tipperary, once again. The lesson of the importance of armor was quickly established by the younger men who survived going over the top and battlefield tactics and minds were changed. Except for Field Marshal Douglas Haig, who commanded the Allied Forces on the Western Front. The embittered old Commander would take his faith in mounted Cavalry to the grave. In 1926 Hage wrote that he, “Believe[d] that the value of the horse and the opportunity for the horse in the future are likely to be as great as ever. Aeroplanes and tanks are only accessories to the men and the horse, and I feel sure that as time goes on you will find just as much use for the horse—the well-bred horse—as you have ever done in the past.” One hundred years later, Staff Sergeant USMC [Ret] Jeremy Stafford walked into the famous gun room at Taran Tactical in Simi Valley, slapped his pipe roll down on the table and smiled. Stafford is well tanned after a summer working the streets of Los Angeles in an LAPD cruiser. Stout and trim, the 49-year-old veteran of the Iraq War is built like a college fastback, with shoulders as wide as a door frame. A sleek 1990s style USMC tattoo on his bicep occasionally peeks out from under the sleeve of his shirt. Unraveling a leather chord from his pouch he removed a stout, rusticated billiard […]
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 478! Our featured interview tonight is with novice pipe smoker Warren Byle. Warren is an IT guy that is working on a tobacco project of his own. This episode is another installment in our series of novice pipe smokers (those with 3-5 years of pipe smoking experience) that we pose seven questions to. At the top of the show, (hold onto your seats), Brian will have a surprising review of Captain Black Original. Sit back, relax with your pipe, and enjoy The Pipes Magazine Radio Show!
Welcome to The Pipes Magazine Radio Show Episode 477! Tonight we have Rich Esserman back with us for an epic show. Rich is quite well known in the hobby. He has been smoking, collecting, and writing about pipes for over 40-years, and he is best known for collecting large-size Dunhill pipes. Last time we changed things up, and had Rich interview Brian. We are changing it up again tonight with these two experts having a conversation on various topics in pipes and tobacco. This episode will go right into the conversation, and bypass the usual Pipe Parts segment. Sit back, relax with your pipe, and enjoy The Pipes Magazine Radio Show!
Great, great article, Fred. I haven’t been up to Gatlinburg since I picked up the pipe, so I have yet to meet Ira, but Dave Watson is a true gentleman. Dave greets every customer cordially and will listen to each request, whether it makes him money or not. And that is the definition of customer service.
Not affiliated with him, of course, except as a happy customer.
Great article! Next time I’m in Tennessee I’ll be sure to stop by one of them.
I’ve never been to Smoky’s, but I visit The Gatlin-Burlier at least once or twice a year. I’ve met Ira several times, he’s a top notch guy! That goes for Richard and the rest of the guys that work for him as well!
With all the BS surrounding tobacco in Washington, and at the state levels right now, it’s no small wonder that guys like these are able to even survive. It’s a damn shame that great shops like these are closing up left and right! I’ve been buying from Ira for more than a decade, and will continue to do so as long as he’s in business!
Long live the B&M!
How can Tennessee acquire not one, but two such great shops? I’ll keep those in mind when we travel South.
Our local B&M is for sale and we regulars are depressed about it. Things will change with the new owners and not for the better as far as we are concerned. I fear that we are entering a very bleak period for our hobby. So so sad.
When I’m in Gatlinburg, which is almost every year, I always visit the Gatlin-Burlier at least once and I have since I discovered this store after it first opened. I would hate to see it close. I would certainly miss seeing and talking to Richard whose always there to help you in your selection of pipes, tobaccos and cigars as well as others who visit.
On a side note I was taught in elementary school by his wife’s mother many years ago and attended school with his wife’s older sister.
I met Ira some time back and found him to be a very personable individual.
I would definitely recommend everyone to visit the shop while visiting Gatlinburg and the Smoky Mountains Park. You won’t be disappointed.
I try not to think about FDA regulations. It’s a frightening scenario.
It’s taking a substantial amount of time for FDA to figure out which regulations it will put in place, but I do believe they are coming; and when they do I have two words to offer: Black Market. Maybe those in the industry who wish to continue profiting from offering pipe related products could become the distributors or managerial personnel needed to bring the best of this market to their customers. As compared to now when they do so openly, why not become covert? I’m sure disinclination for such will arise as it would be illegal and involve penalty if discovered by law enforcement. The best response to that that I can give is that law enforcement is already fighting a losing battle given current staffing; how would they possibly take on these duties? Perhaps the feds would create an entire new agency of tobacco-policers such as they did with Homeland Security, the result of which has been training and paying those officials for airport security.
An off-the-cuff response that I nonetheless feel has merit in trying to analyze the coming tobacco future.