By Bob Tate

packing

To dedicate or not to dedicate? That is a question that is asked frequently by pipe smokers. Before I give my answer to this question, I would like to explain a few things. There are some advantages to dedicating pipes to certain tobaccos and there can be some disadvantages as well. The reason why piper smokers wonder about this is; ghosting can and does occur while smoking pipes. A lot of pipe smokers wonder if the ghosting will affect the next blend that they smoke in the same pipe. Dedicating pipes to specific tobaccos mainly apply to briar pipes. Briar pipes have the most tendencies to ghost than other types of pipes. Ghosting is pretty easy to define and understand. It is when the flavor of a blend stays with the pipe after you have smoked it. It can and will affect the flavor and aroma of the next blend that is smoked in that same pipe.

Now a lot of you are going to say, “I must dedicate my pipes because I don’t want any ghosting to happen!”. Ghosting is going to happen to some degree or the other with every blend that you smoke. Since every blend tastes different, no matter how small the difference is, it is going to have some type of an effect on the next blend. Sometimes ghosting can be a good thing, so don’t get carried away just yet. When it comes to pipe smokers and pipe dedication, there are basically three groups;

Those who don’t dedicate at all (No Dedication*)
Those who dedicate a pipe to one particular blend (Strict Dedication*)
Those who dedicate pipes to different genres of tobacco (Genre Dedication*).

Now I will explain a little bit about each of these groups and some of the pros and cons to dedicating pipes to different tobaccos.

[Editors Note: The terms marked with an * are just terms that I made up to simplify the length of the wording.]

——————————

No Dedication*
The pipers that don’t dedicate their pipes just don’t want to deal with the hassle of dedicating pipes to certain tobaccos. If they want to smoke a particular pipe, they just grab that pipe and load it with whatever blend that they want to smoke at that time. They don’t care about ghosting and actually like the way that some blends play off of each other that way. It is also cost efficient because you don’t have to own a lot of pipes to enjoy a lot of different blends.

Pros
•You can smoke whatever pipe you want without regard to the blend
•You can smoke whatever blend you want without regard to the pipe
•No hassle in picking out a pipe and tobacco combo
•Sometimes the ghost can have a really tasty effect on the smoke
•Less expensive (than Strict Dedication and Genre Dedication) - You don’t have to own a lot of pipes to enjoy a lot of different blends

Cons
•You will have a ghosting effect on other blends
•Ghosts may take longer to smoke out
•You may lose the subtle nuances of blends
•You may not taste the intended characteristics and flavors of a particular blend

 

Strict Dedication*
The pipers that dedicate one pipe to one blend enjoy tasting every single nuance of a particular blend. They don’t want any other flavors intruding on the flavor of whatever blend that they smoke in that pipe. They don’t want any ghosting at all to take place. They have one pipe dedicated to one blend and that is the only blend smoked in that pipe until they want to change the blend. If you smoke less than ten different blends, this is OK. But if you are an eclectic smoker, who likes a lot of variety and smokes a lot of different blends, it will get very costly because you will need a lot of pipes.

Pros
•You will get the true flavor of a blend and every subtle nuance
•You will taste the intended characteristics and flavors of a particular blend
•There will be no ghosting effects on other blends because you smoke only one blend per pipe

Cons
•More expensive (than No Dedication and Genre Dedication) - You will have to own a lot of pipes if you enjoy smoking a lot of different blends
•If you want to smoke a certain blend, you have to smoke the pipe dedicated to it
•If you want to smoke a certain pipe, you have to smoke the blend dedicated to it

 

Genre Dedication*
The pipers that dedicate pipes to different genres of tobacco may have the best of both worlds. They fall in between both of the other groups. They dedicate pipes to each genre of tobacco. They have pipes that are dedicated to English/Balkan blends, Virginia and Virginia/Perique blends, and Aromatic blends. This gives them a variety of choices of different pipes and tobaccos to choose from for a smoking combination. There is a small amount of ghosting that can happen, but since the pipes are smoked with blends from the same genre, the ghost can be smoked out very quickly. It is a lot more economical than Strict Dedication and not much more expensive than No Dedication.

Pros
•You can smoke whatever blend you want with any pipe from the genre dedication
•You can smoke whatever pipe you want from the blend genre
•Less hassle picking out a pipe and tobacco combo
•Ghosts are easily smoked out
•Less bowls (than No Dedication) to pick up on subtle nuances
•You can more easily taste (than No Dedication) the intended characteristics and flavors of a particular blend
•Less expensive (than Strict Dedication) – You don’t have to own very many pipes

Cons
•Light ghosting effect may happen
•Slightly more bowls (than Strict Dedication) to pick up on subtle nuances
•Slightly more expensive (than No Dedication) – You need to own a few more pipes

——————————

These are just a few of the differences between the groups. Don’t take them to be the ‘end all, be all’ for pipe and tobacco dedication. I wanted to give everyone a good starting point. Now back to the original question of “Should I or shouldn’t I dedicate my pipes to certain tobaccos?” The only correct answer to this is; do whatever makes you happy and is enjoyable for you. If you enjoy Strict Dedication, then dedicate your pipes that way. If you don’t enjoy dedicating your pipes at all, then don’t. Don’t get caught up in all of the ‘rights’ and ‘wrongs’ of pipe smoking. There are very few absolute rules, most of them are opinions. I will say that you should give every technique a chance to see if you would like it or not and whether or not it enhances your enjoyment of pipe smoking, but other than that, there is only one absolutely right way of doing things in pipe smoking. And that is; if you are enjoying it, you’re doing it right.

Happy Puffing!

 

 

 

14 Responses to “Dedicating Tobacco Pipes to Pipe Tobacco Blends”

  1. Gary N said:

    Thanks for the article..this has been bothering me for awhile now..lol I started out Genre dedicating and now I am a No Dedication type guy…I have 7 pipes (1 is broken) and just switch off depending on the pipe…

  2. cortezattic said:

    That’s a nice way to break-out and organize the options, Bob.

  3. riptide said:

    Great article it solved a Problem for me I think i will stick to being a Genre Dedicator.

  4. Kevin said:

    I am so glad I am doing it right! ;-)

    I don’t dedicate at all. I just like to pick up whatever pipe I feel like smoking and whatever tobacco I feel like smoking and don’t want to have to worry about any rules.

    It’s a great article Bob, and I can certainly see why someone would do either Strict, or Genre Dedication. They’re just not for me.

  5. funn said:

    I belong to all three genres. I have my smoke anything in pipes,my catagorical pipes and,I’m only smoking Presbyterian mix in this pipe. My excuse??I want to appreciate all that pipe smoking has to offer. Great classic explanation of dedication. Has been long needed

    Funn

  6. tj said:

    One other problem with dedication - some tobaccos really “sing” with some pipes. If you dedicate, you may never find the perfect match!

    Fun article — thanks!!

  7. Jimbo said:

    I have been following “Genre Dedication”. I have a couple of pipes dedicated to famous ghosters (Erinmore flake and 1792), but the rest of my pipes are divided into “Latakia” and “Non-Latakia”. The latakia pipes don’t get much use in the summertime. :-)

  8. kcvet67 said:

    In 44 years of smoking I’ve accumulated nearly 150 pipes, the thought of trying to keep to a Strict Dedication regimen is way too much work. I do use sort of a modified Genre Dedication system since some blends burn better in some pipes than others, I just don’t limit those pipes to one blend.

    Bob makes the point early that “Sometimes ghosting can be a good thing” which I agree whole-heartedly with. There is sometimes a serendipity between two (or more) blends that can be very interesting. For me, even after 44 years, experimentation is still a very important part of the whole experience.

  9. storm said:

    Would it make any sense to dedicate pipes to tobacco by bowl shape and burn characteristics? For example, one could pair a pipe shape that is known to burn cool with a tobacco that is known to burn hot to get the desired result?

  10. Bob said:

    Storm,

    That is an interesting idea. That is one of the great things about this hobby; there are so many different ideas and factors that come into play to enhance the experience.

    I know that different bowl shapes can have an affect on the taste of the tobacco. So dedicating a specific blend to a specific shape could work nicely. As far as using a cool burning pipe to smoke a hot burning blend; it sounds like it makes sense, but I have never tried it.

    Try experimenting with your ideas and let us know about your results.

  11. juozapas said:

    Thank you for the insight and education !! Much appreciated !

  12. gigmaster said:

    Smoke a corn cob. They require no break-in, no char, or cool-down period between smokes. You can smoke a bowl of English Blend, then immediately wipe the bowl out and re-load with an aromatic, light-up again, and enjoy the nuances of both, with no ‘Ghosting’ (that I’ve ever been aware of).

    Meerschaum also does not require break-in, or charring. It gives a clean smoke every time, with no bleed-over of flavors (that I have ever noticed).

  13. Tony Suvie said:

    The only dedication I do with my pipes is one for straight VA’s ONLY and one for VA/Per and VA. Reason being is that Va’s are to me very delicate and I think they could get lost in a heavy blend pipe or smoked after an aromatic. One thing that I do now and then is smoke a straight VA in a pipe tht starts to get messy. VA’s smoke nice and dry and I feel that it helps dry things outa bit. This doesnt’ take away the need to clean a rest my pipes though. it just helps a bit in my opinion.

  14. Elton Weaver said:

    dedicated to pipes and cigars with enterchange of each from time to time. makes for a most enjoyable passtime. smoke many different cigars from time to time with great pleasure but keep the same mouth and wouldn;t haveit any other way, whatever turns you on or floats your boat or fills your pipe, enjoy the hobby:)

 

 

Most Popular Posts



  • Pipe Tobacco Storage
    :   By Bob Tate A lot of pipers wonder if and how they can store their pipe tobacco. There are ways to store your tobacco and it will last for years and if done properly, it will allow the ... 36 comment(s) | 77 view(s) per day


  • A Few Pipe Lighter Reviews
    :   By Bob Tate When it comes to lighting your pipe, there are always discussions about what is the best thing to use. There is the famous debate about lighters VS matches. Because whether ... 31 comment(s) | 37 view(s) per day


  • Flake Pipe Tobacco Preparation
    :   By Bob Tate Flakes are one of the ways that pipe tobacco is made. Flake tobacco is made by pressing tobacco under extreme pressure for a period of time forming a cube. The cube is then ... 23 comment(s) | 32 view(s) per day


  • English Blends and Latakia Blends - One and the Same?
    :   By Bob Tate Some of you may know from reading my articles, reviews, and from discussions in our forums, that I normally use the term ‘Latakia Blend(s)’ and not ‘English Blend(s)... 17 comment(s) | 31 view(s) per day


  • Tobacco Pipe Packing Methods - Part 1
    :   By Bob Tate [Editors Note: Be sure to read Part Two of this article, Tobacco Pipe Packing Methods - Part 2 (With Videos), to see instructional videos on how to perform these methods.] ... 10 comment(s) | 29 view(s) per day


  • How to Rehydrate Pipe Tobacco - Rehydrating Pipe Tobacco
    :   By Bob Tate If you store your pipe tobacco properly, it should not dry out. But I am sure that it has happened to us all at one time or another. We open a tin, pouch, or baggie to smoke... 16 comment(s) | 25 view(s) per day


  • Routine Tobacco Pipe Cleaning (With Videos)
    :   By Bob Tate *Editors Note: These cleaning instructions are for use on wood pipes such as Brair, Olive, Cherry, etc. It is not recommended to clean Meerschaum pipes using these instructions.... 27 comment(s) | 24 view(s) per day


  • Pipe Smoking Tips
    :   By Bob Tate When I first started smoking a pipe, I had no mentor to talk to and nobody to show me tips on how to make pipe smoking more enjoyable. I had to learn a lot on my own from re... 14 comment(s) | 20 view(s) per day


  • How to Ream a Tobacco Pipe
    :   By Bob Tate Although this article is ultimately going to explain and show how to ream your tobacco pipes, I thought that I would first talk a little bit about cake. After all, you won... 4 comment(s) | 20 view(s) per day


  • Dunhill Early Morning Pipe - Pipe Tobacco Reviews
    :   By Bob Tate *Editors Note/Correction: I have to make a correction to this review. After further investigation, I have found out from Orlik that this blend does contain Latakia. Here ... 15 comment(s) | 18 view(s) per day


  • Dunhill My Mixture 965 - Pipe Tobacco Reviews
    :   By Bob Tate The tin aroma of this blend is a strong, sweet and smoky tobacco smell with a light hint of spice to it. It smells very good. The moisture content is good for smoking right ... 5 comment(s) | 17 view(s) per day


  • Tobacco Pipe Packing Methods - Part 2 (Videos)
    :   By Bob Tate This is a companion piece to my article, Tobacco Pipe Packing Methods. I apologize that it took me so long to get this piece up, but here it is. It is the video tutorials on... 6 comment(s) | 17 view(s) per day


  • Interview with Greg Pease of G.L. Pease Tobacco - Part 1
    :   By Bob Tate Greg Pease is the owner of G.L. Pease, Intl. Greg began blending pipe tobacco over 30 years ago and in 1998 left his regular job of 18 years to pursue tobacco blending full ti... 10 comment(s) | 14 view(s) per day


  • Dedicating Tobacco Pipes to Pipe Tobacco Blends
    :   By Bob Tate To dedicate or not to dedicate? That is a question that is asked frequently by pipe smokers. Before I give my answer to this question, I would like to explain a few things. ... 14 comment(s) | 14 view(s) per day


  • The Mystery of Balkan Blends
    :   By Bob Tate Balkan Blend. That term is very mysterious. Is there really such a thing? If there is, what is it? What distinguishes a blend as a Balkan Blend? These and many other questio... 22 comment(s) | 13 view(s) per day


  • Reading Between The Lines - Pipe Smoking Tips
    :   By Bob Tate I would like to talk a little about the information that novice pipers will come across. The reason that I named this article “Reading Between the Lines”, is because I w... 15 comment(s) | 12 view(s) per day