Would You Rather...

tschiraldi

Lifer

Dec 14, 2015

1,813

3,555

55

Ohio

• Oct 16, 2017

• #1

So, here's the thing. Let's say you bought an old pipe, say a Castello (ahem) from the early days of the company. You discover that pipes from that era had a very restricted draw AND it whistles you a tune when you draw air through it. Would you rather have the pipe opened up so it would smoke better or leave it as is for the historical value of the piece? This pipe would be a keeper, not one for resale.

 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate

Nov 12, 2014

43,411

109,201

• Oct 16, 2017

• #2

If keeping it, I'd open it up.

 

wyfbane

Lifer

Apr 26, 2013

5,117

3,517

Tennessee

• Oct 16, 2017

• #3

There is a chance no one would notice if you DID sell it. Either way, if you are smoking it, there is no point in having an unenjoyable smoke. Open it!

 

scrooge

Lifer

Apr 24, 2015

1,341

14

• Oct 16, 2017

• #4

Open it you might get lucky just by running the same sixe bit thru it 1st. Since old it wouldn't take much to whistle. Unseen build up. Maybe.

 

jaytex1969

Lifer

Jun 6, 2017

9,520

50,597

Here

• Oct 16, 2017

• #5

 

anthonyrosenthal74

Lifer

Jan 8, 2013

7,493

733

• Oct 16, 2017

• #6

Do what you must to make the pipe more enjoyable to you.

 

nevadablue

Lifer

Jun 5, 2017

1,192

4

• Oct 16, 2017

• #7

Drill away!

 

A

auburnfan

Might Stick Around

Sep 19, 2017

89

0

• Oct 16, 2017

• #8

Just me, but if I was keeping it and didn't like the way it smoked, I just wouldn't smoke it. Chances are, you won't like the way it smokes after altering it. To me there is something about preserving the original state and not altering it.

 

A

aldecaker

Lifer

Feb 13, 2015

4,407

42

• Oct 16, 2017

• #9

I'd blast it out to 5/32" and smoke the hell out of it.

 

pipesmokingtom

Lifer

May 4, 2015

3,210

16

• Oct 16, 2017

• #10

. Chances are, you won't like the way it smokes after altering it.

Click to expand...

Why are those the chances, pray tell?

 

pruss

Lifer

Feb 6, 2013

3,558

370

Mytown

• Oct 16, 2017

• #11

I'd mess around with my loading technique a bit before making the decision to bore it out... I like to get a feel for what the manufacturer was doing before I go modding.
But failing finding a sweet spot, if I liked the pipe's looks I'd have it opened up.
Alternately, there's a guy outside Toronto who happily accepts free Castellos of this vintage and smokes the shit out of them... I'd be happy to help you dispose of that pipe.
-- Pat

 

PaulTheScandinavian

Lifer

Jul 28, 2016

7,617

36,623

Finland-Scandinavia-EU

• Oct 17, 2017

• #12

If I got this like problem, should I file the stem airflow(tenon)more open or mortise airhole or perhaps both?

 

philobeddoe

Lifer

Oct 31, 2011

7,433

11,713

East Indiana

• Oct 17, 2017

• #13

Open her up! If the pipe is not a great smoker and a simple drill bit can make it one, then there really is no question.

 

tschiraldi

Lifer

Dec 14, 2015

1,813

3,555

55

Ohio

• Oct 17, 2017

• #14

Pruss- I haven't put ANY tobacco in it and it's already more of a pull than a fully, and properly loaded pipe! Cleaned thoroughly. No obstructions. The problem is the stem, not in the shank. I think I'm going to have Jesse Jones open it up a bit. Thank you all for your input. Its a beautiful piece and I want to like smoking it as much as I like looking at it.

 

newbroom

Lifer

Jul 11, 2014

6,109

6,594

Florida

• Oct 17, 2017

• #15

One such specimen does not speak for all of its litter mates.

 

tschiraldi

Lifer

Dec 14, 2015

1,813

3,555

55

Ohio

• Oct 17, 2017

• #16

One such specimen does not speak for all of its litter mates

Click to expand...

Oh, I love my Castello pipes. I have some older ones, though this is the oldest. Never had this issue with any of them. Incredible smokers, all! This particular one needs a bit of help, though.

 

mikethompson

Lifer

Jun 26, 2016

11,326

23,458

Near Toronto, Ontario, Canada

• Oct 17, 2017

• #17

If you can't enjoy smoking it as-is, then open it up.

If you want to keep it on your rack and just look at it, don't bother.
I'm in the camp of "pipes are meant to be enjoyed", but how you enjoy them is of course up to you.

 

crashthegrey

Lifer

Dec 18, 2015

3,817

3,607

41

Cobleskill, NY

www.greywoodie.com

• Oct 17, 2017

• #18

Unless it really speaks to you and you want to alter it, I'd recommend selling it for what it seems to be worth and buying an equally awesome pipe that you will enjoy. Someone else may want it for the historic value.

 

mso489

Lifer

Feb 21, 2013

41,210

60,455

• Oct 17, 2017

• #19

I'd second the motion, but by now it's more like thirty-seconding the motion. Drill baby drill. No, carefully and lovingly open it up a bit or have the pro do it. Enjoy your heritage Castello. 'Glad I never got on the Castello bandwagon -- clearly it's an obsession!

 

woodsroad

Lifer

Oct 10, 2013

11,772

16,062

SE PA USA

• Oct 17, 2017

• #20

You can always have a new stem made for it with a 5/32" opening. That way you can enjoy it now and if you want to sell it, later on, you'll still have the original stem. But I suspect that the pipe really sucks, most Castello's do, and you'll just want to send it to me for disposal.