So, the question is what are my top choices for Virginias, not what's easily available Virginia, difficult to get Virginia, or you're SOL that ship has sailed Virginia. These are in the "cellar".
More or less easily available:
Astley's - #44
Astley's - #109
C&D - Yorktown - C&D Virginias aren't the best, but this particular one I really like a lot
Wessex - Campaign Dark Flake
SG - Full Virginia Flake
SG - Best Grown Flake, or plug if you can find it
F&T - Cut Virginia Plug
GLP - Union Square
MacBaren - Capstan Blue and Yellow
Robert Lewis - Wingfield Mixture
John Aylesbury - Luxury/Classic Flake
John Aylesbury - Sir John's Flake
Hard to find but still in Production:
Esoterica - Cardiff
Esoterica - Brighton
Germain's - Brown Flake
You're SOL, that ship has sailed:
McClelland 40th Anniversary
McClelland Chistmas Cheer
McCranie's Red Ribbon and Red Flake
McClelland 22, 25, 27
McClelland 2010, 5100
McClelland Blackwoods Flake
McClelland Dark Star
McClelland Aurora
McClelland Virginia Woods
McClelland Tawney Flake
McClelland Red & Black
Brigham - Klondike Gold
Va/Per:
More or less readily available:
STG - Escudo - STG's version is not the best, but it's still a good blend, just no longer a standard.
D&R - Rimboché AB, AP, SJ
Peter Stokkebye - Luxury Bullseye Flake - tastes like cardboard when fresh, but just magnificent with 4 or more years on it.
GL Pease - Telebraph Hill
GL Pease - Sixpence
GL Pease - Filmore
GL Pease - Haddo's Delight - not a purist's Va/Per, but one of my faves.
HU - Director's Cut
HU - Old Fredders
H&H - Louisiana Red
H&H - Anniversary Kake
Rattray - Marlin Flake
SG - St James Flake
Solani - 633
RO Perique Series - GP-11
MacBaren - Savinelli Doblone d'Oro
MacBaren - Acadian Perique
Seattle Pipe Club - Deception Pass
Hard to find but still in Production:
Esoterica - Dunbar
Esoterica Dorchester
Peter Heinrichs - Curly Block
You're SOL, That ship has sailed:
McClelland - Beacon & Beacon Extra
McClelland - 2015
McClelland - St James Woods
McClelland - Tudor Castle
Motzek - Strang Curly
A&C Peterson - Escudo - this is when Escudo was the standard.
Besides the above, I also like the following Virginia Based blends:
Rattray's - Hal O The Wynd
Solani - 600 Silver
MacBaren - Savinelli Brunello Flake
Esoterica - Tilbury and Stonehaven
GL Pease - Montgomery
GL Pease - Jackknife Plug
D&R - Two Timer
D&R - VIP
MacBaren - Modern Virginia
I've got a few other assorted tins of this and that, just can't remember what.