Tobacco genre sample question :-)

Hi Napulitano,
First, welcome to the forums--lots of good, friendly people here with tons of info.
A very subjective question, so be sure, but here are a few you might want to consider:
Burley: Solani Aged Burley Flake, MacBaren Golden Blend, Carter Hall

English: Nightcap, Early Morning Pipe, GLP Quiet Nights

Aro: Rattray's Bagpipers Dream or MacBaren Vanilla Flake (both not fruity--mostly light toppings)

"Crossover English" (mix of English and Aromatic)--all Frog Mortons, MacBaren Plumcake, Sillem's Black

Virginia: Dunhill Flake, SG Full VA Flake, SG Best Brown Flake, Orlik Golden Sliced

Virginia//Perique (also called "VAPer"--Escudo or Dunhill Deluxe Navy Rolls, PS Luxury Bullseye Flake
You can go to http://www.tobaccoreviews.com/search and click on "Blend Type" and then sort them by number of reviews or average rating to find others that people like.
Finally, smokingpipes lists their top sellers in a number of ways:

Top 10 Tinned: https://www.smokingpipes.com/tobacco/tinned/bestsellers.cfm

Top 10 Bulk: https://www.smokingpipes.com/tobacco/bulk/bestsellers.cfm

Top 10 Trending bulk: http://www.smokingpipes.com/smokingpipesblog/single.cfm/post/top-trending-bulk-tobaccos

Top 10 English: http://www.smokingpipes.com/smokingpipesblog/single.cfm/post/top-best-selling-english-blends

Top 11 Burley: http://www.smokingpipes.com/smokingpipesblog/single.cfm/post/top-best-selling-burley-tobaccos

Top 11 Aromatics: http://www.smokingpipes.com/smokingpipesblog/single.cfm/post/top-best-selling-aromatic-tobaccos

Top 100 Tinned: https://www.smokingpipes.com/tobacco/tinned/bestsellers100.cfm
Also, check out this thread for Top 5 "must try" tobaccos:
http://pipesmagazine.com/forums/topic/top-5-must-try-pipe-tobaccos
Enjoy!!!

In no particular order:

1. Nightcap -Latakia and more, plus nicotine

2. Escudo -Virginas and Perique

3. ERR Match - Over the counter 'flavored' Burley

4. Rattray's Marlin Flake - smooth and delicious Virginias, cavendish and perique

5. C&D Autumn Evening - a Virgina based aromatic that delivers taste and nicotine and can be added to any of your less flavored over the counter blends for both economy and variety.
I bought bulk forms of Nightcap, ErrM, & Autumn Eve..these latter two I stretch by 'blending' with any of several codger blends I keep around. CH,PA,SWR,MidTown Mid Town 'copies', and PS702.

I also dabble with cutting up cigars and using that along with AE and maybe a dab of Lat blend.

Click to expand...

I've been smoking my pipe(s) since May of 2014, just over a year.

In the VaPer genre, my choices are:

• Brigham Acadian Blend
  
  Sam Gawith Spring Time Flake
  
  Sillem's Councilor 1695
  
  McClelland Collector: Beacon (or Beacon Extra for more Perique)
  
  Dunhill Elizabethan Mixture

...of course, things like this change from season to season, year to year.

Also, there are lots of VaPers that are seasoned with other types of leaf, not considered here.

Thanks for posting the links pipefish.

As a full time newbie mostly-lurker, that post by pipefish is one of the most helpful things I've come across. Well done and cheers!

Newbie and was wondering if you can help me pick a top quality loved 5 for each genre of Pipe Tobaccos

Click to expand...

In no particular order:
English/Balkan:

- Balkan Sasieni

- Wilke No. 10

- Wilke Highhat

- Dunhill 965

- Seattle Pipe Club (H&H) Plum Pudding
Aromatic:

- Wilke No. 191

- MacBaren Vanilla Cream Flake

- Savinelli Cavendish

- Hearth & Home Classic Burley Kake

- C&D Autumn Evening
Virginia:

- Dunhill Flake

- MacBaren/Capstan Original Navy Cut - Blue

- Orlik Golden Sliced

- Rattray Hal o' the Wynd

- Dunhill Royal Yacht
Va/Per:

- Escudo

- GL Pease Fillmore

- Stokkebye Luxury Navy Flake

- Anniversary Kake

- Rattray's Marlin Flake
Va/Bur/Per & associated hybrids:

- Robert McConnell Scottish Cake

- GL Pease Cumberland

- GL Pease Haddo's Delight

- GL Pease Cairo

- Stokkebye Luxury Bullseye Flake
Burley & Va/Bur:

- MacBaren Burley London Blend

- MacBaren Golden Extra

- Sir Walter Raleigh

- Peterson University Flake

- Peretti No. 333
Bonus category:
American/English // Aromatic/English:

- Wilke Bestmake

- Wilke No. 5

- Two Friends English Chocolate

- 310 Battleground

My fifth recommendation got list there on my final category. Should be Stokkebye English Luxury.

Glad to be of help, gentlemen; and as you can see, there are a ton of other recommended tobaccos to consider from other members.

You have some great recommendations here. Just to throw two more on the pile: Among English blends, Nat Sherman's 536 is among the most refined English blends, mild but full of flavor; and in the burley category, but a sort of outlier, I really like Semois Tobac-Manil, a Belgium variant of burley, just one kind of tobacco but totally unique. Some love it and some loath it, but if you enjoy it, it's like a blend all in one leaf.

That great thing about these threads is seeing how wildly opinions and tastes vary.
Here's what I would throw in to a custom sampler, OP
Full Virginia Flake, Medium Virginia Flake, Skiff Mixture, St James Flake, Dark Birds Eye, Grasmere or Ennerdale Flake.I choose these in part because I believe they are all currently available in bulk from P&C.