I haven't tried Marlin but BCDF is an amazing Virginia experience. It's not magical or transcendental of course but it is good. I think the Cavendish and perique would provide a much different although, I'm sure good, flavor. When it comes to something like Penzance or BCDF I think it's important to remember it's just tobacco. The hype doesn't make it better but it also doesn't make it worse. Just don't build it up to be the end all be all, I think that is where most disappointment comes from. So while I wouldn't pay ebay prices for a tin of the stuff, it's well worth a try. If you like it then join the game and if not, you've got it easier than those of us who do. There are blends that I am sure are every bit as good but it's not the same exact taste and I want that exact taste, as long as it doesn't get ridiculous trying to get some.