SPC Plum Pudding

exbenedict

Starting to Get Obsessed

Feb 6, 2018

122

41

• Jul 25, 2018

• #1

Ok, this may sound a bit weird, but I opened my first tine of SPC Plum Pudding and have smoked a few bowls of it, and it tastes very odd to me. It leaves, what I can only describe as, a film on my mouth and tongue while and after smoking that tastes vaguely of some sort of chemical cleaner. It doesn't smoke very well, even after drying, and I'm wondering if it's just a bad tin,or has anyone else encountered this problem?

 

The Pipe Professor

Might Stick Around

May 14, 2016

66

15

Kentucky

thepipeprofessor.com

• Jul 25, 2018

• #2

One of my favorite blends. This does not sound characteristic of the Plum Pudding I've smoked. Granted, some tobaccos just do not agree with some people. I foresee a trade in your near future...cheers!

 

3rdguy

Lifer

Aug 29, 2017

3,472

7,293

Iowa

• Jul 25, 2018

• #3

Much as I wanted to I do not care for it either. I jarred and it and will revisit. Loved the tin note.

 

npod

Lifer

Jun 11, 2017

2,942

1,024

• Jul 25, 2018

• #4

I agree Benedict-ex. Plum Pudding has never tasted good to me and I also noted a film like residue on the palate.

 

grimpuffer

Can't Leave

Aug 29, 2016

350

2,416

• Jul 25, 2018

• #5

Interesting.
Although I much prefer Mississippi River, I have several tins of Plum Pudding and enjoy it very much in the cooler months.
The only issue I ever had was tongue bite if I pushed it too hard but never any negative aftertaste like that you speak off.
Will have to smoke some I already have open tomorrow and see.

 

mso489

Lifer

Feb 21, 2013

41,210

60,459

• Jul 25, 2018

• #6

I have Plum Pudding aging. This won't hurry me opening it.

 

brooklynpiper

Part of the Furniture Now

May 8, 2018

643

1,377

• Jul 26, 2018

• #7

Plum Pudding is something I gushed over when I first tried it. Nowadays I'm really trying to taste more blends and found out the ones I like before they go hasta la vista.
Maybe it's a you thing. Maybe something funky on Sutliff's end. Maybe trade it or return. Maybe jar it up and try it later. Maybe you'll always hate it and you'll smoke it as the last thing left in your cellar after the apocalypse.
Either way, it's a shame it didn't agree with you.

 

cwpiperman

Can't Leave

Jun 15, 2018

382

2,434

• Jul 26, 2018

• #8

I've got quite a bit of Plum Pudding and Plum Pudding SR. I just finished a bowl of Special Reserve, and I didn't notice any mouth film, or off taste. I really like Plum Pudding AND Mississippi River; they're different enough to smoke on different occasions. Looking forward to seeing how it ages, and stocking up.
CW

 

wyfbane

Lifer

Apr 26, 2013

5,117

3,518

Tennessee

• Jul 26, 2018

• #9

Plum Pudding is my favorite. No film, just smokey yumminess.

 

deckpiper

Might Stick Around

Apr 18, 2018

66

2

• Jul 26, 2018

• #10

Mississippi River is my favorite, but I do like Plum Pudding as well. No odd taste or film at all.

 

metalheadycigarguy

Lifer

Apr 26, 2012

3,381

5,594

Washington State

• Jul 26, 2018

• #11

Doesn't sound like any Plum Pudding I've ever smoked. I would say try it in a different pipe, and if that doesn't work, set it aside for a while and come back to it later.

 

Civil War

Lifer

Mar 6, 2018

1,552

396

• Jul 27, 2018

• #12

SPC Plum Pudding is one of my favorite blends!

 

exbenedict

Starting to Get Obsessed

Feb 6, 2018

122

41

• Jul 27, 2018

• #13

I've jarred it up and am going to let it sit for a few months and see what happens. I am not one to give up on a blend right away, but we'll see what happens. Cheers!

 

carolinachurchwarden

Lifer

May 9, 2018

1,687

86

Raleigh, NC

• Jul 27, 2018

• #14

Is there such a thing as an acquired taste for certain tobaccos? I know certain things are really good once you have had enough of it and acquire the taste, but not too sure how many bad bowls I'd want to put up with to get there. Maybe it would be better come winter. I know my palate greatly increases and changes come winter. Something that smells/tastes bad in the heat of summer usually is quite different in the winter for me. Hope it works out for you!

 

J. Mayo

Starting to Get Obsessed

Jul 18, 2012

234

3

Texas

• Jul 29, 2018

• #15

Not sure about the "film" you experienced...... But Plum Pudding was a very middle of the road Balkan for me. Definitely an enjoyable smoke, but nothing spectacular after all the hype I'd read. Sorry about your bad experience, ship the rest to me and I'll test it thoroughly for you :lol:

 

smokeyweb

Part of the Furniture Now

Dec 29, 2013

540

780

• Jul 29, 2018

• #16

Love plumb pudding. Wondering if halitosis could be the culprit here?

 

pepesdad1

Lifer

Feb 28, 2013

1,023

675

• Jul 31, 2018

• #17

Got some on order...looking forward to popping the tin.
Anything like Bengal Slices?
And how is the PP SR different from regular Plum Pudding?

 

exbenedict

Starting to Get Obsessed

Feb 6, 2018

122

41

• Jul 31, 2018

• #18

Halitosis eh? I don't think so.

 

cossackjack

Lifer

Oct 31, 2014

1,052

647

Evergreen, Colorado

• Jul 31, 2018

• #19

exbenedict

Maybe you need to exorcise your beard...its ghosted.

 

smokeyweb

Part of the Furniture Now

Dec 29, 2013

540

780

• Jul 31, 2018

• #20

Haha. Just trolling! I have smoked a few tins of SPC Plumb Pudding and have never noticed a chemical taste or mouth film. I love the stuff.