Recommend a Straight Virginia?

nevadablue

Lifer

Jun 5, 2017

1,192

4

• Oct 14, 2017

• #1

I am learning what I like and am attempting to identify the various components of blends as I try them. I know now that I like blends with Virginia, Latakia, Perique and 'Cavendish' in them.

I am trying to see which components are my favorites and be able to 'taste' them. Retrohale is helping I think.
So, recommendations for a straight Virginia tobacco? I know I like Golden Slice, Frog Morton Cellar and My Mixture 965 blends.

 

bosmer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Jun 27, 2017

100

2

• Oct 14, 2017

• #2

I like McClelland's matured virginia series, No 24 and 27 are worth checking out. No 24 has a whisper of Basma leaf that I really enjoy.

 

fmgee

Part of the Furniture Now

Sep 26, 2014

922

4

• Oct 14, 2017

• #3

I would recommend trying a couple of different styles of straight Virginia. Anything by McClellands is a good start. On the other end of the spectrum one of the meatier European style Virginias like Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake or Capstan are worth a try.

 

leacha

Part of the Furniture Now

Jun 19, 2013

939

8

Colorado

• Oct 14, 2017

• #4

You can't go wrong with any of the McClellands. Since you like FMC try Stave Aged 35.

 

Chasing Embers

Captain of the Black Frigate

Nov 12, 2014

43,445

109,364

• Oct 14, 2017

• #5

Black Twist XX.

 

johnbarleycorn

Lifer

Dec 28, 2015

2,337

1,003

• Oct 14, 2017

• #6

Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake for sure. And Capstan Blue second.

 

txpiper07

Starting to Get Obsessed

Sep 18, 2017

152

0

• Oct 14, 2017

• #7

+1 for Capstan blue.

I’m also a big fan of Orlik Golden Sliced. I know it’s technically a VaPer, but the perique is so mild I can’t detect it in taste at all, only a little bit in the spicy mouth feel.

I’ve got some C&D Opening Night in the mail, it was on sale at P&C, and jiminks gave it a good review on tobaccorreviews, unfortunately I’ll be out of town and won’t get to try it until next week

 

6

64alex

Part of the Furniture Now

May 10, 2016

566

339

• Oct 14, 2017

• #8

[I would recommend trying a couple of different styles of straight Virginia. Anything by McClellands is a good start. On the other end of the spectrum one of the meatier European style Virginias like Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake or Capstan are worth a try.]
I second that. You should try American style with McClelland being the leader and the European particularly with the twin Gawiths (now back under the same roof). Difference is that American source American grown Virginia while The Gawith source from the former British Empire (mainly Indian and African particularly Malawy) so in some way they are different. Both great and worth to try.

 

6

64alex

Part of the Furniture Now

May 10, 2016

566

339

• Oct 14, 2017

• #9

[Black Twist XX]
I question I always had in my mind is if Black Twist is a true Virginia as my understanding it is the Brown number 4 which underwent steeming and the brown number 4 is listed as cigar leaf, kentucky and Virginia.

It would be interesting to see what is really.

 

nevadablue

Lifer

Jun 5, 2017

1,192

4

• Oct 14, 2017

• #10

Lots of good suggestions, thanks everyone!

 

unkleyoda

Lifer

Aug 22, 2016

1,126

69

Your mom\\\'s house

• Oct 14, 2017

• #11

GLP Union Square
JimInks 4 star review

 

bosmer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Jun 27, 2017

100

2

• Oct 14, 2017

• #12

I have been smoking out of an 8 year old tin of Union Square recently and it has been excellent!

 

metalheadycigarguy

Lifer

Apr 26, 2012

3,381

5,593

Washington State

• Oct 15, 2017

• #13

Two of my favorites are Dunhill - Flake, and Dan Tobacco - Patriot Flake. Two excellent blends.

 

mawnansmiff

Lifer

Oct 14, 2015

7,423

7,367

Sunny Cornwall, UK.

• Oct 15, 2017

• #14

Another vote for Samuel Gawith Full Virginia Flake. McClelland's straight Virginias I find to be far too mild, the flavour is there but it has to be hunted out. FVF on the other hand is dripping with flavours from start to finish.
Regards,
Jay.

 

thomasw

Part of the Furniture Now

Dec 5, 2016

862

24

• Oct 15, 2017

• #15

Mac Baren - HH Pure Virginia

 

bosmer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Jun 27, 2017

100

2

• Oct 15, 2017

• #16

Does Full Virginia Flake have that Lakeland essence?

 

johnbarleycorn

Lifer

Dec 28, 2015

2,337

1,003

• Oct 15, 2017

• #17

^ I’ve never had any with the essence. But I have heard some people say they have.

 

skydog

Part of the Furniture Now

Jun 27, 2017

581

1,537

• Oct 15, 2017

• #18

I've never detected any essence in FVF. Just quality VA's. I am a huge McClelland fan and Matured Virginia No. 27 and 40th Anniversary are both amazing but Blackwoods Flake is hands down my favorite.

 

nevadablue

Lifer

Jun 5, 2017

1,192

4

• Oct 15, 2017

• #19

I read all the advice and then dug in my 'cellar' and found Sutliff Virginia Slices. It is supposed to have 'light topping' but I didn't detect it. I am dedicating a virgin MM Little Devil Cutty to this project. First bowl was nice. I have learned to dry my tobacco before I try it. This sat for several hours and was still a bit moist in the little pipe. I am leaving the rest of the rubbed out batch out overnight.

 

fitzy

Lifer

Nov 13, 2012

2,937

27

NY

• Oct 15, 2017

• #20

MCCRANIES RED RIBBON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Also:

McClelland 40th Anniversary

McClelland Christmas Cheer (any year you can find)

McClelland Stave Aged

PS Luxury Twist Flake (Very light vanilla/coconut flavor but still considered a straight va)

McClelland Fragrant Matured Cake

McClelland Old World Classic Cake