Raving About 1Q

nsfisher · Sep 15, 2012

I have seen it many, many times, the raving about this baccy. I have not tried it but have read the reviews on Tobacco Reviews. Can someone here, please make the comparison for me between this baccy and, let's say Capt. Black White and or MacBaren's Original Choice. It seems, from reviews, that these 3 Baccys have a similiar note. I would be interested in a comparison from someone who perhaps tried all 3 blends.

igloo · Sep 15, 2012

Dont forget Zander Greg Z-100,Seven Seas Regular and Boswells Best . I too was lured in by the hype and just had to try it . Lots of folks like these blends and make them thier all day smoke . Well worth a try if you have not had it .

kennerth · Sep 15, 2012

I am told that Captain Black White IS 1Q, with the usual drug store additives. Both are Lane Ltd. products.
http://pipesmagazine.com/blog/pipe-tobacco-reviews/captain-black-pipe-tobacco-review/#more-3374

pstlpkr · Sep 15, 2012

I've been smoking 1Q since the day I bought my first pipe.

A lot of people say that CBW is similar to 1Q... Not to me.

CBW to me has a lot more casing.

As for the McBaren... I thought it was closer to CBW than 1Q.
As for the note... I get more favorable reactions to 1Q than either CBW or McBaren.

YMMV

Just my humble opinion.

For me a big difference.

1Q for me every time over the others.

: puffy

:

taerin · Sep 15, 2012

It is very simular to Sail Green, however Sail Green is better.

nsfisher · Sep 15, 2012

Hmm, I used to smoke Green Sail yrs ago, but now I don't care for it, so I guess no 1Q for me then.

papipeguy · Sep 15, 2012

I have not smoked CB in decades but I agree with Lawrence that 1Q is not as heavily cased as CB. I'm not really an aro smoker but 1Q is the biggest selling blend in the USA for a reason. It is not complicated, just sweet enough and does not require a lot of attention. A decent time passer.

jah76 · Sep 15, 2012

CBW was one of those tobaccos i could taste something metal-like in. It felt thin and left a weird film more then a taste in my mouth. Re-reading that it sounds snobbish, but even if it was $20 bucks a oz I'd say the same thing.
1Q doesn't have the same metal taste to me, but has zero tobacco taste too me. Its like big empty smoke clouds of a muted sweetness. I like it when I need a break and just want to huff and puff.
Just my 2 cents.

puffy · Sep 15, 2012

I'm not sure what to call 1Q It's not as highly flavored as most aromatics.It doesn't taste like an English blend.I think it's a blend that almost anyone can smoke.It smokes cool without bite.You don't need an expensive pipe to smoke it.I smoke other blends but 1Q is what I smoke the most.It's also less expensive than a lot of other blends.

lordofthepiperings · Sep 15, 2012

I'd have to say 7 Seas Regular and 1Q aren't very similar. I can't really describe 1Q other than a great smoke. You can bulk order a 2oz sample for about $5. Might be worth a try.

chopz · Sep 16, 2012

Today i had a bowl or 1Q and later, a bowl of boswell's christmas cookie. the christmas cookie has the same sort of aro base to its flavor but with a little more something - perhaps more of a tanginess. it also stayed lit and burned easier. i'm gonna say advantage: boswell.

pstlpkr · Sep 16, 2012

I've mentioned this before on several occasions I'm sure.... So, please forgive me.
One advantage that 1Q has over many tobaccos is its functionality.

For me, after smoking several different boutique tobaccos the tastes (to me) become harder and harder to discern.

So, I'll smoke 1Q for a week or more, exclusively. Then have a bowl or 10 of the Boutique tobaccos and the flavors will become much more lively and discernible; and thus more enjoyable.

1Q is a good tobacco for that "go to" everyday smoke and works to "reset" the palate, helping me to enjoy the boutiques all the more.

: puffy

:

hawk60ce · Sep 16, 2012

1Q is what i give to friends who come over and are not pipe smokers but want to try. most of my friends are cigar smokers which i have plenty of, but i try to get them to try the pipe, and broaden there horizons.

baronsamedi · Sep 16, 2012

1-Q is more like CBR than CBW, but to me it's lighter and less goopy. It's a good all-around smoke for the price and I will likely always have some around.

grafikchaos · Sep 17, 2012

+1 to what Baron and Lawrence have said. Great all-around aromatic. It's not goopy by any stretch, and it doesn't overwhelm the senses. It has good flavor, an excellent room note, and it's not expensive. However, if you don't dig on aromatics for the most part, then you may want to not even bother.

daytonsean · Sep 17, 2012

Lawrence hits it correctly. I've been smoking 1Q for a few weeks now, and it's definitely just an easy going tobacco. Sit back, char it, light it, and the bowl just rolls smooth. A very mild vanilla flavor. Doesn't get hot. Others don't complain about it. And, the best part - it's insanely cheap. I get it at like 2.32 an ounce at my local shop. Plus they do percentage discounts per 2 ounces you buy. CBW kinda makes me a little sick. It's overly sweetened, and just messy. Smells like a chewing gum wrapper. I'm not a big fan of it.

daytonsean · Sep 17, 2012

+1 Jah, I get a weird film on the roof of my mouth too when smoking CBW.

morton · Sep 17, 2012

Hey nsfisher, send me a pm with your mailing address and I'll send you some 1Q. I bought a few ounces one time to see what the fuss was about. I'm in Canada too so shouldn't be too hard to do, eh? I like it ok not being much of an aro guy but others like Lawrence and the good Baron are right, its got a great room note, no one gets up in arms if they smell it and to me, its not bad as a once and awhile tobacco.

Raving About 1Q

Log in

SmokingPipes.com Updates

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Site Sponsors

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor

Lifer

Lifer

Can't Leave

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Can't Leave

Lifer

Lifer

Lifer

Starting to Get Obsessed

Lifer

Lifer

Part of the Furniture Now