It appears the Black Mallory is safe from the chopping block. I've heard it compared to BS and FR but apparently there is no top-note that the BS/FR share. Anyone smoke both or all three and have a comparative opinion to offer?
Rattrays Black Mallory Compared to Bengal Slices/Fusiliers Ration
- Thread starter pipedreamin
- Start date
.gif)
SmokingPipes.com Updates
Watch for Updates Twice a Week
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
Site Sponsors
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
PipesMagazine Approved Sponsor
- Status
Because there is no top note they are very different in my opinion. That's really what makes it unique though, the top note.
Yo pip
Amplifying hawk's comments, I can add that the BM's characteristic Rattray Cavendish is quite prominent, muting the LatBomb effect of the excellent BengalS and FR. My Top300 Cellar has the latter two, but not so the Rattray.
Are you near Wilmington, DE much? If so, we could run a taste test side by side.
hp
les
Amplifying hawk's comments, I can add that the BM's characteristic Rattray Cavendish is quite prominent, muting the LatBomb effect of the excellent BengalS and FR. My Top300 Cellar has the latter two, but not so the Rattray.
Are you near Wilmington, DE much? If so, we could run a taste test side by side.
hp
les
Les,
I do get down there a bit, Probably within the next month or so...
I'll send a pm. Is Tobacco Village still hanging in there?
I do get down there a bit, Probably within the next month or so...
I'll send a pm. Is Tobacco Village still hanging in there?
- Status